rate your commission/trade (FEEDBACK~!)
14 years ago
i saw someone doing it a long time ago, and i'm interested in getting some feedback!! MAKE SURE TO BE HONEST THOUGH! i don't need no asspats
these are the FACTS! and i think it'll help people if they want to commission me in the future.~
please note that if you're going to review for an old piece of artwork, things do change, so just be aware of that. i realize my older stuff was messier, so maybe something from this era? P:
counts for trades/commissions, of course. this also counts for designs~ :3
you can include the link to the art if you want to, but it's not necessary!!
★ - terrible
★★ - bad
★★★ - decent
★★★★ - great
★★★★★ - perfect
(remove anything in parentheses if you post!!)
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
(if there is someone from da/nabyn/other art sites i will post the ratings myself with links to the original rating comments)
these are the FACTS! and i think it'll help people if they want to commission me in the future.~
please note that if you're going to review for an old piece of artwork, things do change, so just be aware of that. i realize my older stuff was messier, so maybe something from this era? P:
counts for trades/commissions, of course. this also counts for designs~ :3
you can include the link to the art if you want to, but it's not necessary!!
★ - terrible
★★ - bad
★★★ - decent
★★★★ - great
★★★★★ - perfect
(remove anything in parentheses if you post!!)
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
(if there is someone from da/nabyn/other art sites i will post the ratings myself with links to the original rating comments)
★★★★★ contacted me often about every commish, very enjoy.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★★ shown progress sketches for each commish that wasn't just a sketch, so very good at showing prog.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★★ extremely well-priced and fair!!!!
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★ blew my ass apart with how amazing.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★ extremely satisfied!!!!
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
nope except that anyone who doesn't commish is stoop.
Well, you basically started it like the second after I paid you so..
★★★★★
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
IT WAS VIA STREAM SO..
★★★★★
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
★★★★★
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
I loved it. :3c So... ★★★★★
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
VERY SATISFIEDDDDDDDDD!!
★★★★★
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
COMMISSION HER, FAGGOTS.
*****
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
**** great she didn't need to show me w.i.p.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
***** great pricing
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
*****
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
***** very satisfied
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
Nope
(don't know if I did the stars right D:)
*****, we were able to keep in contact.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
*****, i was actually about watch you finish it on steam.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
****, something i was able to afford.
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
*****, i just loved it. ;_;
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
i was very satisfied.
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
nah.
★★★★, good enough, and that's good c:
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
★★★★, 8 dollar for an icon is a good price
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★, it was exactly what I wanted
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★, I was delighted x3
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
It's all good! Keep up the good work, Ali c:
★★★★★
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★★
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★★★★ (lol...I agree you kind of undercharged me for my commission ;p)
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
noop. pretty well satisfied. :3
Actually, this is a pretty neat idea and maybe something that should be implemented on a more official basis like with the Commission tab. That way people get find out more about who to commission and who to avoid, how well they can expect some artists to take direction, etc.
★★★★ very easy to get a hold of and friendly to talk to.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★★ showed me the sketch and then livestreamed, allowing me to watch her draw it. also, good jams going on in the background. lovin' the disney.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★ it was good considering the amount of effort that goes into the piece.
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★ it was finished quickly and flawlessly.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★ I love it, although i don't have a space to actually UPLOAD it.
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
none.
★★★★★
All of my notes were responded to promptly (I seriously felt bad for not responding fast enough when I got the lineart commission, haha)
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
★★★★
I did not receive a WIP, however the communication was such that I knew exactly what I would be getting because I am incredibly vague
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
★★★★★
I DON'T REMEMBER HOW MUCH IT WAS I GUESS THAT MEANS IT WAS REASONABLE
But no seriously, another thing was that when I purchased two characters from you/same person/Ali/hi I tossed in an extra...$10 I think? And got a very nice color comish in addition to the characters which was sweet
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★
Always quick and exactly what I wanted yay
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★
for the color commission in addition to the characters I got: I was pleasantly surprised by how awesome and adorable it was, reflecting the personalities I had in mind for the characters incredibly well.
On the lineart commission I got, of the same characters, once again I was very pleased. I love how well the personalities shine through! That's my favorite thing.
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
I felt that you very well kept contact, you where nice enough to tell me about lateness or delays of any sorts,or updates and made sure things where OK
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
I enjoy them,you did well on showing me when I ask to see sketches you showed them I didn't see any problems
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
A little high,but I understand why you would put them in such a range,the end process though makes it worth while,but still a bit to high in sense of what I could buy somewhere else
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★-perfect bby, you take your time but its not really not that much of a wait
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
Very, I squealed when I get them and awed at them for hours I am always happy to get art from you,sadly I don't have much to receive them all the time XD
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
Nope your a great artist and if haters hate on you they always gone hate,but your awesome and you should feel awesome,hope I helped in some way keep on doing what you do :>
★★★★★ Very well! You noted me a lot and kept me informed with the process of what you were doing, from 'is this fine?' to the finished product.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion?
*see above*
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★★ Fair, definitely~
4. how would you rate your commission's completion?
★★★★★ The commission was finished rather quickly.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★ It was softly colored (which I always envy) and pleasantly sketchy, not the messy kind where it's difficult to see.
6. any other comments about the commission?
Mmmmm, not that I can think of. It just nice to work with you, and when I fudged on the reference piece you didn't freak out on me, so you were patient with my dipshittery, which is always good.
★★★★★ When I went to ask about the commission for Prick a while ago, you responded very quickly and hell, I even got to watch you color it.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? (sketches, wips, anything up until the finished product, i normally don't show process for trades unless it's requested however)
★★★★ I dont think I actually saw the sketch for the commission, but I did see just before lining/coloring which I was very pleased with.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
★★★★★ I agree with how you price your commissions, I wouldnt question it otherwise :3
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★ It was very fast paced from when I actually saw the lines just before. I was very pleased.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
See above
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
I do hope I get money to commission you again in the future x3
★★ - bad
★★★ - decent
★★★★ - great
★★★★★ - perfect
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
★★★★ - Although I wasn't around the last few days, you sent me notes that held a WIP, and also one that pointed me towards the finished product. Very convenient.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★ - I didn't see the WIP product, but the effort was made on the artist's behalf to show the WIP.
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★ - Cheap. Very good for those who have a tight budget.
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★ - Quickish.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★ - I absolutely love it! It's definitely an image that I might show when asked for a good image of my character, and it will show up in my favourites. Most of the views will probably be from me xD
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
Definitely one of my top commissioning artists. I'll be back!
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade? ★★★★★
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★★
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★★
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
Completely mind boggling! My stars are not biased, this was a first time commission, and I thoroughly enjoyed watching her stream my artwork. I giggled with excitement during the final stages, so thrilled to get my final piece. She was amazingly fast, and efficient. There's nothing to say to express my fondness of her artwork! She's absolutely amazing.
★ - terrible
★★ - bad
★★★ - decent
★★★★ - great
★★★★★ - perfect
(remove anything in parentheses if you post!!)
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
★★★★★
very quick and no other contact was needed
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★
completion was the next day, not even 24 hours had passed ^ ^
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission?
★★★★
not too pricey, but mine was a special thing so im not sure if it was regular pricing ^ ^
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★
Very good, one minor thing BUT I LOVED IT! it was a beautiful sketch
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★
Very satisfied
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
I will be a returning customer for sure <3
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade?
★★★★★
A very nice artist, works quick and is very nice!
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade?
★★★★★
Uhh, no processes were shown :'D But I'm happy witht he outcome anyways~!
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? (ignore for trades)
★★★★★
Very afforadable pricing for really good art. I can't wait to get more!
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion?
★★★★★
I loved the finished product, the way she drew his clothing was perfect.
5. how satisfied were you with the final product?
★★★★★
I am very satisfied ;v; so satisfied I want more!
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
The artist is easy to contact, kind and straightforward and works very quickly!
I'm deffinatly looking forward to coming back for more :D
1. how well was contact kept throughout the commission/trade? ★★★★★
Wonderfully. Ali kept me up-to-date with her progress, even if it was just to apologise for being unable to work that day due to RL things. She was also extremely up-front about my character choices - letting me know when she felt that what I wanted wouldn't suit the style of the experimental piece she was going to be doing. I know that she would have done any of my characters, if I'd insisted, but I was very happy to give options and shift around so that we would BOTH enjoy the commission.
2. how well were the processes shown up until completion/trade? ★★★★★
I was shown a sketch for approval and then at the color stage was asked if anything needed changing - but everything was just looovely~
3. how would you rate the pricing for your commission? ★★★★★
OMG INSANELY PRICEY. *shoot* Okay, not even close. The cost of my commission was more than fair, I was happy to pay and very happy with the result. Ali's commission costs are extremely fair for the quality of the 'end product'.
4. how would you rate your commission/trade's completion? ★★★★★
A+ dude~
5. how satisfied were you with the final product? ★★★★★
Well...let's just say that I've pimped Ali's FA page AND the art to my favorite RP forums and various groups. ;D
6. any other comments about the commission/trade?
Just that I had been watching Ali's work for a long time, waiting for the chance to get a commission. I was NOT dissappointed in the slightest, even though Ali warned that it was 'experimental'.
fa's like
don't cheat the star system son
/winknudge