Erf. As far as I can tell, your art has been improving. Keep moving forward!

Happy bday man!

As far as I see from my eyes your male anatomy is still one if the best and sexiest. However perhaps broaden things than keeping it just line work as epic as it is perhaps colouring in your pics is a way to move forward. I'm no where near a good artist but looking at your anatomy is great and I can't ever see faults my only thought is that of colouring and working on that side aswell as much as I don't do it but drawing females aswell broaden it beyond ink work :)
I hope that helps

Happy boifday Beach~ *throws a party for you and Unrepentant filled with a variety of men of various sizes and builds in various states of (un)dress...and there was no Fratbear*

And as for what you can improve on, well...this may be a personal preference (of either yours or mine), but...I don't know. It feels like there's not a lot of variety in your drawn characters. Many of them are similar in build...but then again, if one actually looks, they see that you draw guys without cobblestone abbs, how potbellies do occur, and if Fratbear is anything to show, you also do make chunkier guys rather than just runner/jocks.

It's honestly hard for me to really critique you when I'm not only not a visual artist, but your stuff is just so appealing. :/

I think you're thinking of the wrong artist here. I've never done animations. XD

Omg! xD Lol. Sorry. It was very early when I wrote that... ^^;;;;;;

Using this as an example: http://www.furaffinity.net/view/10767851/

Improve your shading, to give accessories a more circular and less flat appearance

Improve your perspective, so angles of held items seem to more correctly correspond to their surroundings (eg, the knife appears to be held at 80-90 degrees away from the viewer, but the handguard appears to be facing 20-30 degrees away from the viewer, instead of being 90degrees away from the blade.)

And finally, I'm pretty sure feet don't look that spread out normally, but as I can only compare mine, as viewed from above, I cannot be sure of this criticism.

I love your artwork and always have. I love the subject matters always too. Could you draw better? Sure, but what you doing right now, I enjoy and it helps make you stand out from the rest of the pack of artist here.

Happy bday. So critique... Well, one thing I notice is that most of your characters tend to look the same. Such as, one wolf looks nearly identical to another. Not all the time, but I have noticed it between drawings. So perhaps find ways to give a little extra detail, perhaps in the faces, to help distinguish characters that look alike. Sometimes your anatomy is spot on, while other times I feel like the pose of the character was off, but I could not say precisely why I felt that way. I think your line work is wonderful, and is very fluid.
You have a good range of character physiology, but I think you tend to draw more muscle on lithe characters than perhaps they should have. Of course, my memory might be off, and i might be forgetting some pieces that contradict this. I know it takes more time, but maybe add color to more pictures when you have the time, to help make it pop out.

Other than that... I got nothin'. What do you think about my critiques? Do you think they hold true? My memory could be wrong, so think about everything carefully before you let criticism nag at you.

Footpaws. Paws paws paws. Try drawing some, as opposed to the FREAKISH CLOWN FEET your characters always have. Okay, I exaggerate. But yeah, experiment with animal anatomy; your characters look like humans with animal heads and tails. Just try stuff out.

Also, happy birthday and I hope it was most excellent! Want any bound jocks?

I echo the above Re: feet and the somewhat-generic look of characters. There almost seems to be a random generator: species, belly type, package type, age, with a set look for each thing.

Other than that it's all subject things and the way situations go down.

Oh and the lack of females. But that appears to be a personal preference matter.

Pay closer attention to your commission emails and/or be sure to respond to each of them.
Though, I'm fairly sure I got lost in the shuffle of you moving house, which was both forgivable and fortuitous as it turned out I didn't have anywhere near as much money as I thought I did.

I love your art, but one trend I have noticed is that when you do backgrounds, you tend to not finish lines (Naga Shower, great example of this with unfinished tiles and what not) which tends to leave alot of noticeable empty spots ^_^
That said, most everything else is gravy. ^_^

More Seth and Naga stuff, more daddy puma.. Your art has improved though, noticeably. maybe try posting more art, I may be wrong but it seems like you haven't been drawing as much lately and you have fans wanting to see your stuff for many reasons so ^^

Yes. Draw more of my own preferences, desires, and submit to the whims of whatever particular thing I want to see drawn.

If you can do this, truly you will have mastered the craft.

Seriously though, I'm not an artist so I'm vastly under-qualified to give critique, but I saw this: You keep getting better. Just look at Favor for a Friend and that Once-Every-Other-Year series. Picture to picture, your art is cleaner and clearer.

I was afraid that I would not be able to give you a “gift” for your birthday when it seemed all you wanted was negative feedback on what you were doing “wrong”.

Personally I find your technique to be excellent (you know how to tell a story with your pictures -- something that a lot of artists around here have never learned to do). Your faces are distinct (other artists’ faces all seem to be drawn from the same store dummy) and your display of anatomy is delicious especially since you age-vary it appropriately. And I particularly enjoy the UCLL “world” (and the other “worlds” and characters (the Naga, the Charn Family, Fratbear, Professor Lion, etc)) that you have created.

All in all, you are an artist who is a pleasure to watch (and download).
Happy Birthday, Beachy.

I love the drawing, there just needs to be more of them along with puma daddy shenanigans.