Doctor Who's October Surprise!
3 years ago
Recently a reviewer charitably called the 13th Doctor's past four years of sporadic activity "erratic". That was a kind way to say "more often lousy than not." The writing simply was not up to the quality 21st Century fans had come to enjoy since the new series began and flourished in the time of four Doctors and two showrunners who came before, and Jodie Whittaker rarely evoked the gravitas and emotional depth the show and character had become known and loved for.
So her adieu turned out to be an overstuffed season-ender style special like the show had enjoyed before, with several recurring villains, several returning guest companions both new and old, several returning guest Doctors in cameo roles, and several confusing plot threads all competing for screen time. While my heart was no longer really in it, at least I found the proceedings amusing and nostalgic. Even the Doctor's small final farewell speech felt well-handled. and then...
"...What? ...What? ...WHAT?!"
Introducing DAVID TENNANT as the 14th DOCTOR.
It was already known Russel T. Davies was returning as showrunner for 2023, as well as producer Phil Collinson, stars David Tennant and Catherine Tate, and one would expect the show to feel like its 2008 season with those people back. As far as I can tell it's going to be just 3 specials to air more than a year from now. I'm fine with that, since it's clear this regeneration was atypical, gone awry in some manner, and not destined to last more than one 60th anniversary story before it introduces the 15th Doctor. What's going to be wild is seeing David playing a different Doctor from the 10th.
So her adieu turned out to be an overstuffed season-ender style special like the show had enjoyed before, with several recurring villains, several returning guest companions both new and old, several returning guest Doctors in cameo roles, and several confusing plot threads all competing for screen time. While my heart was no longer really in it, at least I found the proceedings amusing and nostalgic. Even the Doctor's small final farewell speech felt well-handled. and then...
"...What? ...What? ...WHAT?!"
Introducing DAVID TENNANT as the 14th DOCTOR.
It was already known Russel T. Davies was returning as showrunner for 2023, as well as producer Phil Collinson, stars David Tennant and Catherine Tate, and one would expect the show to feel like its 2008 season with those people back. As far as I can tell it's going to be just 3 specials to air more than a year from now. I'm fine with that, since it's clear this regeneration was atypical, gone awry in some manner, and not destined to last more than one 60th anniversary story before it introduces the 15th Doctor. What's going to be wild is seeing David playing a different Doctor from the 10th.
FA+

They really need to jettison all the hackwork he did. Turning the Doctor into an immortal basically ruins the character.
I did rewatched all the episodes from Eccleston-Tennant-M.Smiths and some of the better ones from Capaldi as well. Those were entertaining. Gave Jodie's doctor a chance (3 episodes), but I was bored, and I am very against Wokeness since it's a bad thing and a direct enemy of Escapism, the very reason what I enjoy in entertainment.
Doctor Who is now just another "Go Woke. → Go Broke!" franchise for me. I'd wish it would returned to the glory days, but for that, Chinball-Jodie's run should be avoidable/skippable. Just take over from where Capaldi left, and pretend what was after never was...or at least make it so, that the audience can choose...Woke companies sadly NEVER retcon their BS, since it's a source of income (HAH-barely!) a form of investment, and their virtue signalling propaganda. They will never fully erase what was done...but they could make it so, that we just skip that era, and pretend it never was. It could work...I mean, I could have fixed Star Wars episode 9 easily and in a way, that Ep 8 would be fully accepted, with all it's craziness.
I hope things turn out good for Docotr Who. But as of yet, my interest level in it is at Apathy. I wish for DW to soar high once more! I'll be keeping my eyes open, and hoping...
No, my problem with chibnall is that he's a hack. His writing has always been mediocre at best, and ranged from just adequate to.... well.... "the worst piece of television ever written" as I call it, aka the Cyberwoman episode of Torchwood. Putting him in charge of Doctor Who seemed like a statement of intent from the BBC: "We've given up on this show."
That he then proceeded to go on to vandalize the show's entire history with his fanwank just proved to me that I was right. The BBC stopped caring about Doctor Who and handed it to whatever talentless loser they could dump it onto. I blame Moffatt for that. The show was not in a good place under his stewardship. By the end of his run I was basically hatewatching the show, waiting for him to leave in the hopes that someone who knew how to make television would be put at the helm again.
BUT.....
Anyway, the show is wrecked. Any glimmer of nostalgia has been brutally murdered. And to top it off he made The Doctor immortal, removing any stakes the show once had. I keep mentally flashing back to that scene in Terror Of The Zygons, Tom Baker patches an alien circuit by running the current through his own body with the off-hand comment "Is half-power lethal?"
He didn't know if it was going to kill him. But he did it anyway. because the stakes were high and he had to do something.
A character who places themselves in danger and puts their life at risk for the sake of others is a hero. That is the very nature of adventure. And the more risk the hero has to endure, the more the story resonates with the audience. A good character doesn't just get you to cheer for their successes, but also to feel the pain of those moments when they fail.
And now The Doctor no longer has a life to risk.
Thanks to chibnall, The Doctor has been retconned as an immortal godlike being. Not a timelord. Not from Gallifrey. And completely free from the threat of death. Stakes have gone out the window. Daleks? Cybermen? He might as well be taking a walk in the park for all the "danger" he'd have from them now.
Immortal godlike beings just make for really boring stories. There has to be an element of danger to overcome. A threat. A risk.
DC comics found that out the hard way with Superman. They had to invent Kryptonite because of it.
So, erasing chibnall's era isn't just a good idea, it's an absolute necessity. The show is no longer dramatically functional thanks to the damage that he inflicted upon it.
Now that RTD has taken over again, he needs to address this and he needs to fix this, and he had better do it fast.
Or nothing else he does with this character is going to matter at all.
1. Main character's best ♂ friend is gay. And He even has a ♂ love interest who he had sex with in the past and their love to each other gets them out from a deadly situation. But aside of that, they don't go full pride gay and everyone should just accept it. They act normal and react normal. The gay ♂ just works! He's gay, yeah...but also a normal highscholler, and a human. Totally good characters...who happen to be gay.
2. ♀ main-ish character is one of the strongest hero in the whole series (Molecule Man / Mr. Manhattan level of OP) and fights an Earthquake-power having villain, who is a feminist and majored in Woman Studies with a minor in African Dance, but saying so much they continue top fight. The woke joke just happened mid fight, but then they continued and concentrated on what's important: Staying alive, since both of them could kill the other in every second. The scene in question...for mood-making - Both epic action and sfx, and working woke-jokes as villain-hero talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nWafqqBxUUw
3. Amber...sadly, that ♀ was always too woke, and the show did a race change to her too. She's the only one who brings things too far, but even with her around, the show is damn good!
Give it a watch, if (you didn't already) you are a fan of superhero stuff!
Also, the BEST working gay character for me is Captain Jack Harkness (actually bi) and Angel Dust. Both of them gay, but owning it naturally, and don't make a fuss about it, and doing their own thing. Totally entertaining characters to me.
and not to mince words or anything.. but to be honest.. its probably the 'republicans' having poisoned the well on it.. but whenever I hear people talk about "Woke" this or "Woke" that.. my mind just goes to ignore-the-hecc out of it mode.. Cause most of the times i've heard it in recent times... its been basically hijacked by the 'other' side and used as a derisive term to call 'everyone else' to separate themselves from the others..
Best thing is just to ignore it entirely and do what is tons of fun to you! Quality entertainment is where life is at!
Now personally, I would've made these 3 Tennant specials stories of events that were never "dramatized" during his original go-round as the Doctor (the same way the spin-off media (comics, etc.) come up with original Dr. Who stories featuring whoever's playing him/her at the time.)
Personally, the series lost me when Capaldi took over from Matt Smith; he was just way too dour a character to warm up to.
I would be fine with losing Smith, Capaldi and Whittaker if it meant also losing all of chibnall's continuity vandalism.
I will see if Doctor Who can be saved or not...as for now, I am giving my attention (and money) to more deserving entertainment...books. I am waiting for the woke-era to die out fully, due to lack of financial funds, and deserving entertainment getting funded over virtue-signalling, big corpos.