Pecan

Chocolate pudding pie, my mom used to make it when I was younger…

Key lime pie! :D

A completely valid choice.

Thiiiissss ♥💕

The best!

Pumkin or Shoofly pie! (Pennsylvania local recipe! tis a molasses pie)

Cherry or lemon meringue if there on the sweet side

Cheesecake. It's by all definitions a pie!

Can't argue with that. not to mention that there are SO many absolutely delicious takes on cheesecake.

Agreed

Nation's Hamburgers has a seasonal pumpkin pie cheesecake. The best of both worlds!

Peanut butter dream pie
Or
Cherry pie

A properly made key lime is top tier, but I wouldn't bother if it was going to be a by-the-numbers take. If I can't have that, then hot pecan pie a la mode all the way!

You and I, Slither, have complete agreement.

High five!

I gotta say French Silk

French Apple. Classic, delicious... <3

this, but in a pie https://insanelygoodrecipes.com/dea.....-by-chocolate/

Key lime or custard.

Raspberry pies !

I love raspberries ! =D

Pecan pie~

You

Pinkie Pie.

Oh wait...

Best answer

Nah. The best answer is a Creampie. I love creampies, especially when I make em myself ;p

Either key lime, pumpkin, or lemon merengue

It's a tossup for me; pecan pie, lemon sponge, and dutch apple pie all vie for favorite.

Pumpkin or French Apple, both a la mode.

PUMPKIN PUMPKIN

Boston Creme or Banana Creme

Pineapple.

Raspberry pie, though it is also the only one I've had xD
But I do love it!

I'm a sucker for blueberry pie, but strawberry and rhubarb pie is just as good in my mind.

Is cheesecake a pie? Some citrussy cheesecake then. Or any other sweet-sour one.

I would say no because the preparation is not like a classic pie, but I must say that the key lime pie and the cheesecake are my favorite desserts (if you call it a light dessert) ❤️🥰

I'm not really a pie guy, but have you heard of Edward's chocolate cream pie? It is HEAVENLY, especially when frozen!

Pumpkin pie

Lemon Meringue pie mmmmm

Apple and raspberry pie.

Favorite type of pie?

3.141592653

Boobberry.

My two all time favorites are Blueberry and Strawberry Rhubarb

Strawberry.

pumpkin or sweet potato pie
apple after that
lemon meringue after that lol

Tied between Pumpkin and Pecan.

Maybe its not to everyone's taste but bannoffee pie

Oh, I've been meaning to try this for years, and maybe I should try making it for Thanksgiving.

Bannoffee pie is seriously just pure delicious in my opinion, I hope if you try it you like it...been a while since i had it and now i want to

blackberry

bananACREAM

strawberry rhubarb

Pumpkin.

Key Lime

Once, I got to have an olallieberry pie, and it was amazing. It's got all the flavor and pop of a blackberry pie but the tartness is muted and it's sort of a smooth flavor again.

They're hard to find so it doesn't really help your decision >.> but if you ever get the chance to try one or order one shipped, they're divine.

So barring that I'd say a nice classic dutch apple pie.

Never heard of olallieberries, but that sounds wonderful.

Tough one, cuz pie is almost always good, but I'm gonna say pecan.

Pecan seems to be coming in really high here.

Good taste, peeps.

You've gotta let us know what you decide on and how they came out, too!

Flex on that pah!

Bit o' whipped cream as an extra doesn't hurt either!

Pumpkin, Chocolate and Vanilla pudding , Banana or Coconut Cream , Keylime... I like lots of pies lol

Grape pie. Only had it once, but it was unforgettable. The taste was more complex than grape jam like you might expect—more like sweet wine.

Pecan

fur pie.

fur real.

Might not go over well with the fam, though.

xD true!

Dutch apple pie with a scoop of french vanilla has always been my go to for everyday anytime pie. The buttery flaky crumb crust always makes it so much tastier to me.
When the holidays come around, gotta go with classic pumpkin, or pumpkin cheesecake. Although I always need a large amount of kool whip to make it complete.
But my favorite pie of all time, the one I get for my birthday every year is the infamous Blueberry Sour Cream Pie from Marie Callender's. I've yet to ever try making this pie at home because it's just so perfect they way they make it.

Cherry :3

There are so many types of apples, as well as combos. It's a classic for a reason.

Add some vanilla ice cream and you've got a winning combo.

I’m a fan of cheesecake and key lime myself.

Whipped cream with pumpkin

Rhubarb pies are really good, especially Strawberry rhubarb!
You can't go wrong with an Apple Pie either, with some crumble on top and a bit of cinnamon.

Rhubarb rhocks.

pumpkin is always a classic, and im fond of cherry pie, tho i guess it depends on how the top crust is done

I'm surprised no one said cream pie
oops

hmm.. Probably Bündner Nusstorte - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%.....dner_Nusstorte
and for less dry, Princess cake - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_cake

No idea how hard they are to make tho.
For something more easy to make, Hedgehog slice. Looks ugly, is tasty and you have enough after very little

lemon meringue!!

Cheesecake or Key Lime would be mine

Key Lime, though that's not exactly in season. . .
My second favorite is strawberry rhubarb :3

something sweet, creamy and cold like peanut butter or mocha

Key lime Pie

Mixed berry pie: strawberry, blueberry, blackberry, raspberry, and/or cranberry.

steak and ale!

Blackberry. 😩

Lemon Meringue!

This topic is making me hungry lmao,

In no particular order:
Pecan
Banana Creme
Apple
Cherry
Rhubarb

I've found buttermilk pie to be a recent fave of mine

Pumpkin

blueberry pie (has to be cold for me)

Meat pie

I gotta go with a peanut butter pie with chocolate chips. Its delightful.

Key Lime with an extra sharp, limey bite to it - the best!

Does fish pie count?

Pecan. I did this last year, without making the crust, but I'm doing the whole thing tomorrow. It's good, but so are all of alton brown's recipes! https://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes.....recipe-2041499

Whatever you decide I beg if you can share the recipe! where I live there are no pie and it's something I always wanted to try! The recipes I found on the internet don't finish convincing me hahaha 🤣

Spinach pie (it's a Greek thing)

Dutch apple crumb

PIZZA PIE! :D

Apple Pie is the best, but the traditional Thanksgiving pies in my family were Pecan Pies and Pumpkin Pies

Pumpkin! And then a piece of chocolate pudding pie! It's a perfect combo!

Pumpkin pie with whipped cream, or apple pie with ice cream!!
I also imagine a peach pie would be good, as I love the cobbler.

Cherry rhubarb~ Or Apple rhubarb! ALA MODE!

Custard Pie!

Lemon meringue as dessert, mushroom and beef (maybe with bacon) for savoury, could top with potato as well

Pumpkin. Gotta stick with the classics during the holidays!

Tough to say, my favorite overall pie is probably pecan. But cherry pie comes in at an amazingly close second. I have made it a personal point to always have the ingredients for pecan pie in case somebody tells me they've never had one. It's weird because it wasn't like, a conscious decision, it just kept happening and eventually it felt weird if I couldn't.

I'm going to be basic and say apple pie.

Cherry, or Strawberry Rhubarb~

Lemon meringue for a tart taste, or classic apple pie for sweetness.

One hundred percent my mothers banana cream pie, look it up for a heavenly dessert.

P.S Keep blessing this planet with scalie art, its splendid!

Pumpkin.

Dutch apple for sure!

definitely rhubarb or pumpkin!

or texas yum yum

Cheeeeesecake. It counts, dont argue.

Mince pie is best ovo

Creampies. Ladies love it when I give em creampies ;p

Pumpkin

Classic Apple.
Either with sweet crumble on top or a nice generous amount of whipped cream.
Yum!

Pork Belly. Uses offal and has a great texture.

I like chicken pie....

I'm a sucker for apple pie. it's my American blood

Cheesecake. So many cheesecake.

Either apple crumb or rhubarb.

I'm genuinely surprised how long it took and how few people have made a creampie joke.
Can't tell if it's because the furry community is losing its touch, or if they just respect you too damned much to give you serious answers only.
Anyway, gonna throw my vote in the bucket and say anything strawberry pie.

is cheesecake cake or pie?

anyway, cheesecake.

-Real- Pecan pie. Dont use the KARO syrup. Its less insanely sweet, its really good :3 Apple-Cranberry is also very good!

Lemon meringue, rhubarb, and key lime are my top choices

My dad can make a mean pumpkin cheesecake~

Cherry pie. Probably the most crust centric pie I can think of. Good luck !

Cherry, apple, or mocha pie because a semi frozen oreo crust pie flavored with almonds, dark chocolate, and coffee just hits right.

Apple.

Pumpkin, Lemon, Keylime, Apple, Banana. The rest tend to be too sweet.

red velvet
with vanilla buttercream cheescake icing

Personaly I love pumpkin pie. I also enjoy a classic apple pie, or raspberry pie. Pretty much prefer classic.

Appul :3

Baker's Square used to make a chocolate peanut butter cup pie. That was my favorite. Not to be mistaken for Perkin's's vastly inferior peanut butter pie.

So many choices, but I think cherry pies skim away with it in terms of tart sweetness.

I'm not entirely sure if I've ever come across a pie I didn't like :P

Favorites would probably have to be Apple and Pecan though.

PUMPKIN!~

lemon meringue is my usual fave but for autumn in particular, gotta be apple-cranberry and my personal thanksgiving fave/tradition, salted honey (like a custard pie but it's sweetened with high-quality honey and gets a good sprinkling of sea salt on top)

Triple chocolate mousse cake. Such wobly and creamy one.

100% pumpkin pie. Amazing with a standard crust so A++ with a fancy one

Steak and kidney

French Silk
Lemon Meringue
Apple (if I'm in the right frame of mind)
Oh, and anything peanut butter.

Purple sweet potato pie! It's purple babey!

Why do you have to ask the impossible questions? It's not fair to make someone choose!

PIE FLAVOR *PTCHEEWWWWWW*

BRUHHH

The classics never get old.

Just like the game I just lost...