Update: FA is asking for feedback. Please give it to them...
2 years ago
The post in question: https://www.furaffinity.net/journal/10560608
It seems that FA is finally entering a phase where they want to start saving face. The most recent update came with some periphery kink changes as well as a change of date that the policy is dropping. (From the 1st of June to the 7th)
I understand that a lot of us in these communities and especially in this fight are very tired. (I personally thought I’d spend this time trying to promote my game on here. Which is coming out on the 9th. The fact that this will continue till the 7th means I probably just… won’t be able to do that)
But this is probably one of the best times to push for change. FA’s reputation is so far in the ground at this point it might as well be burning in hell. It’s the only reason why they are trying to save face now, rather than their consistent strategy of just ignore and censor everyone. While I’m not gonna stop you from just telling them how shit they are (Cause they 100% deserve it). I don’t want to miss this opportunity to push to ensure the safety of our communities and the livelihoods of the artist still working in them.
Below I’m posting what I’ll be writing on my feedback ticket. Feel free to copy it, use it as a template for your own ticket, add your own ideas and demands. Or if you disagree with my approach, to send one with your own views.
___________________________________________________________________________
Regarding Upload Policy Section 2.7
Upon hearing these policy changes, I was instantly struck with how pointedly geared they were for abuse, and unfair treatment targeted directly at the Pokemon and Digimon communities. And none of the addendum’s so far have properly addressed the core issues of the policy.
To ensure the safety of these communities, change MUST be made to address the core failings surrounding the policies’ vagueness, and material assurance needs to be baked into the policy to ensure the Pokemon and Digimon communities aren’t treated differently from any other.
Firstly, the vague and non-quantifiable definition of childlike proportions, “Generally speaking, as characters age, their proportions change...” Means that the only metric for if something has ‘childlike proportions’ is that an FA staff said so. And this means the accused doesn’t have any grounds to argue against abuses under this policy, and ultimately whether the accused art falls in violation is completely up to the bias of the enforcer. Definitions around what is going to be under violation need to be exactingly clear, and quantifiable. With a reasonable minimum number of traits present to trigger a violation.
Secondly, if the policy is truly not targeting the Pokemon and Digimon communities as FA staff claims. The policy needs built in measures to make sure that fair treatment actually happens. If the same body proportions in an accused piece of work is found inside allowed work in any other fandom (Like Animal Crossing, Sonic the Hedgehog, Zootopia, My Little Pony, and General Furry) That piece of work CANNNOT be found in violation. And any false takedowns must be reversed immediately!
———————————————————————————————————-
To send an FA support ticket, click on the three lines on the top corner of the screen. Under the ‘Trouble Ticket’ category, click report a problem. Then change the category to feedback.
FA also suggests joining their discord, but I wouldn’t do that in a million years.
It seems that FA is finally entering a phase where they want to start saving face. The most recent update came with some periphery kink changes as well as a change of date that the policy is dropping. (From the 1st of June to the 7th)
I understand that a lot of us in these communities and especially in this fight are very tired. (I personally thought I’d spend this time trying to promote my game on here. Which is coming out on the 9th. The fact that this will continue till the 7th means I probably just… won’t be able to do that)
But this is probably one of the best times to push for change. FA’s reputation is so far in the ground at this point it might as well be burning in hell. It’s the only reason why they are trying to save face now, rather than their consistent strategy of just ignore and censor everyone. While I’m not gonna stop you from just telling them how shit they are (Cause they 100% deserve it). I don’t want to miss this opportunity to push to ensure the safety of our communities and the livelihoods of the artist still working in them.
Below I’m posting what I’ll be writing on my feedback ticket. Feel free to copy it, use it as a template for your own ticket, add your own ideas and demands. Or if you disagree with my approach, to send one with your own views.
___________________________________________________________________________
Regarding Upload Policy Section 2.7
Upon hearing these policy changes, I was instantly struck with how pointedly geared they were for abuse, and unfair treatment targeted directly at the Pokemon and Digimon communities. And none of the addendum’s so far have properly addressed the core issues of the policy.
To ensure the safety of these communities, change MUST be made to address the core failings surrounding the policies’ vagueness, and material assurance needs to be baked into the policy to ensure the Pokemon and Digimon communities aren’t treated differently from any other.
Firstly, the vague and non-quantifiable definition of childlike proportions, “Generally speaking, as characters age, their proportions change...” Means that the only metric for if something has ‘childlike proportions’ is that an FA staff said so. And this means the accused doesn’t have any grounds to argue against abuses under this policy, and ultimately whether the accused art falls in violation is completely up to the bias of the enforcer. Definitions around what is going to be under violation need to be exactingly clear, and quantifiable. With a reasonable minimum number of traits present to trigger a violation.
Secondly, if the policy is truly not targeting the Pokemon and Digimon communities as FA staff claims. The policy needs built in measures to make sure that fair treatment actually happens. If the same body proportions in an accused piece of work is found inside allowed work in any other fandom (Like Animal Crossing, Sonic the Hedgehog, Zootopia, My Little Pony, and General Furry) That piece of work CANNNOT be found in violation. And any false takedowns must be reversed immediately!
———————————————————————————————————-
To send an FA support ticket, click on the three lines on the top corner of the screen. Under the ‘Trouble Ticket’ category, click report a problem. Then change the category to feedback.
FA also suggests joining their discord, but I wouldn’t do that in a million years.
FA+

FA already lost time ago Zaush, one of the most watched artists in the whole furry fandom and for sure a bunch others are following, add that all the popufurs that simply stopped posting here for the previous controversial policies like the case of Iztli.
FA for a while was a kinda good place where was shared most of the furry artwork of the world... but now is on the way to lose its place as the #1 Furry site, being Inkbunny and E621 the next on the list: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_H9U1_J3dI
like one doesnt like cutebolds cause they kobolds but cute. now all kobolds must fit HIS idea of what kobolds look like. aka world of warcraft gnoll kobolds.
not the cute kobold made popular by Rakkuguy.
flat chest? cause they lay eggs and dont have need for breasts. banned for underage
short, child like porportions? kobolds grow to waist high to humans, heck they grow to full adult hood in a matter of months. average age they die at is like 16-20. they can live to be over 300.....but they a race that thrives off overwelming enemies with weight of numbers, so alot die young.
bleh...rip furrafinity. inkbunny and e621 it is
All sites has different rules and some allow stuff that FA don't allow and viceversa, FA allows stuff that is forbidden in other sites. Right now the most friendly ones would be Inkbunny, E621 and Pivix.. being Inkbunny the most popular site after Furaffinity.
I honestly wish that all the artists leaving the site would be a wake up call for the FA admins... but years of experience makes me doubt it and am sure they will later attack other kind of artworks in the future.