Reading and Reviews
a year ago
Some musings on furry reading and writing.
The newest of the furry writing awards, the Leos, announced they were cancelling due to not having anyone volunteer to be a judge. I thought about volunteering, but honestly, a lot of the nominated books didn’t look that interesting, and I didn’t want to obligate myself to reading half a dozen tomes with plots I found boring.
In their post on Twitter, the person making the announcement commented that there were a lot of furry writers, but not a whole lot of readers. I’ve run into that issue myself. Since I have written a number of reviews in the past, sometimes I’d get people asking me to review something. Unfortunately, if what I’m given isn’t that good, or has major flaws, I tend to be brutally honest. So at this point I don’t get a lot of people asking me to review stuff anymore.
But there’s always writers out there begging for Amazon reviews. The more reviews on there you get, the more likely your book is to be seen. Since I have books on Amazon that I’d really like to get more ratings on, if I see a furry author begging for Amazon reviews, and their work looks reasonably interesting, I’ll offer to review it on Amazon (and Goodreads, for good measure) in exchange for an Amazon review of one of my books.
I made this offer to 4 furry authors.
One agreed, and I wrote up a pretty extensive review and posted it. After a decent amount of time I asked them about my review. They said they ‘couldn’t read (my book),’ and vanished without even an apology.
Another writer had a book on a Kickstarter that I backed, and was asking for reviews. When I made my offer, they said they ‘didn’t have time’ to read anything. In retrospect, that was a good call on their part, because the book was pretty bad.
I made the offer to another furry author whose books I actually enjoyed. They agreed, and I sent the PDF to them, but never heard back. Good thing I waited for them to come through before I posted my own review….
Another author was asking for beta readers. Since, by coincidence, I was also looking for beta readers, I made a mutual beta reader offer. They accepted. I got it read, and wrote up my thoughts, as well as filling out a questionnaire for the beta readers. After a bit, they finished the beta read of my book. They didn’t really have many comments beyond a couple, but hey, at least they read the damn thing, so no complaints on my part.
Thing is, there are some really good furry books out there that I’d love to post positive reviews about. But, as bad as I am at self-promotion, trading reviews is one of the only ways I can think of to get more hits on Amazon.
The perpetual problem of an indy author…
The newest of the furry writing awards, the Leos, announced they were cancelling due to not having anyone volunteer to be a judge. I thought about volunteering, but honestly, a lot of the nominated books didn’t look that interesting, and I didn’t want to obligate myself to reading half a dozen tomes with plots I found boring.
In their post on Twitter, the person making the announcement commented that there were a lot of furry writers, but not a whole lot of readers. I’ve run into that issue myself. Since I have written a number of reviews in the past, sometimes I’d get people asking me to review something. Unfortunately, if what I’m given isn’t that good, or has major flaws, I tend to be brutally honest. So at this point I don’t get a lot of people asking me to review stuff anymore.
But there’s always writers out there begging for Amazon reviews. The more reviews on there you get, the more likely your book is to be seen. Since I have books on Amazon that I’d really like to get more ratings on, if I see a furry author begging for Amazon reviews, and their work looks reasonably interesting, I’ll offer to review it on Amazon (and Goodreads, for good measure) in exchange for an Amazon review of one of my books.
I made this offer to 4 furry authors.
One agreed, and I wrote up a pretty extensive review and posted it. After a decent amount of time I asked them about my review. They said they ‘couldn’t read (my book),’ and vanished without even an apology.
Another writer had a book on a Kickstarter that I backed, and was asking for reviews. When I made my offer, they said they ‘didn’t have time’ to read anything. In retrospect, that was a good call on their part, because the book was pretty bad.
I made the offer to another furry author whose books I actually enjoyed. They agreed, and I sent the PDF to them, but never heard back. Good thing I waited for them to come through before I posted my own review….
Another author was asking for beta readers. Since, by coincidence, I was also looking for beta readers, I made a mutual beta reader offer. They accepted. I got it read, and wrote up my thoughts, as well as filling out a questionnaire for the beta readers. After a bit, they finished the beta read of my book. They didn’t really have many comments beyond a couple, but hey, at least they read the damn thing, so no complaints on my part.
Thing is, there are some really good furry books out there that I’d love to post positive reviews about. But, as bad as I am at self-promotion, trading reviews is one of the only ways I can think of to get more hits on Amazon.
The perpetual problem of an indy author…
FA+

The problem I find with a lot of people is simply the time aspect. It's one thing to read a book in your off-time, it's another to DISECT it. That requires a vastly different time-budgeting skill-set that, bluntly, most people simply don't have
Vix
I hope my own beta-reading of your final Griffin Ranger novel was helpful in at least some small way. Believe me, if I had the pull, I'd probably be pitching it as a great adult anime series. Especially that last book has the feel of great anime or manga.
I keep staring at it. It should be as easy as just finishing the thing and putting up a review. Your review of my book was really generous and I keep worrying that I don't have as many good things to say. I don't have BAD things to say, but there's that weird nagging anxiety in the back of my head that if I just give your book three stars when you gave mine five I'd be an utter asshole.
Probably not as much as not finishing it though. I'll make myself do it tomorrow.
What the heck, you're a pro writer: If you'll review a story of mine that you've already seen (Love in the Arena, Meat on Her Bones, Kill them All, Children of their Fathers, whichever-), I'll do one of yours, of your choice. What say?
* A friend who claimed characters were one-dimensional and poorly written, and then 15 minutes later gushed about how great and deep the character based on him (a cameo included as a way to try to entice him into reading) was. I wrote that character exactly the same way I write all the others.
* A couple of people who complain the idea of a former human willingly being a pet (after being turned into a nonanthro dragon) "majorly creeps them out" and so can't get past the first couple chapters, even though a major thread in the book is exploring what that means and what her reasons are for asking for it. Honestly, if that kind of thing elicits that kind of reaction, maybe don't read a series that says directly at the start that it's the story of a dragon named Princess who is the pet of a mage.
I've certainly been struggling to balance writing with everything else competing for time. Got pulled into the La-Mulana game series again, after finding out there's a randomizer, and also recently discovered the series "The Nature of Predators". I've also got several books sitting on my shelf that I keep telling myself I'll read. I'd say energy is a more constrained resource than time, however, thanks to my health conditions. Really, I'd love to get back up to the "2-3 chapters per week" pace I was doing, instead of the "2-3 weeks per chapter" pace I've been failing to uphold lately. ~_~
I saw Griffon Ranger recommended just now, and it certainly sounds interesting, so I plan to add that to my list as soon as I can. ^_^
It's hard to get proper numbers, but a generous estimate says I have in the neighborhood of 50-100 actual readers, some of which only follow one series, but with quite a bit of overlap. Only about 5-10 actually ever comment/interact, though. Maybe once I'm publishing outside of FurAffinity, I'll gain more traction.
I haven't actually published my work in any paid form, though I'll likely start working on self-publishing with Amazon at some point. My current plan is that after I finish "Princess Tells Her Story" Book 3, I'll rewrite Book 1 (since it's very episodic and rough, as I wasn't actually planning to continue a series and worried each chapter would be the last thing I ever posted, and the "recap" at the beginning of each chapter quickly grates on anyone reading it from the beginning), at which point it should be in much better shape for publishing. Of course, cover art is one obstacle on that path, but who knows where I'll stand at that time.
Perhaps if Book 1 goes well enough, I can use the resources to then publish books 2 and 3, as well as start publishing "Exodimensional Hoofbun Flopsy" books 1 and 2 (since I'll probably have finished Book 2 by that point). If Princess goes really well (which I know it won't), then as a pipe dream, I could look into a comic book adaptation of Flopsy, since it's basically "a comic book in text form". Or if my health ever improved, as a super-duper pipe dream, I could even try to make the Metroidvania game that I was kicking around designs for before recycling the ideas into the story series.
"Modern Major Yinglet" probably won't be published in book form, ever. Being fanfiction, or at least using someone else's species, I wouldn't be comfortable trying to sell it. I also have no idea what Valsalia's stance on that would be. (I think he's had no problem with things like yinglet VR Avatars being sold, but I've never asked since I have no plans.) It's also more "slice-of-life" instead of having arcs that separate into books, really. Compound that with one or two people wanting to make their own fanfiction/companion stories to it, and I'd feel just awful trying to sell it.
One of the biggest hurdles would be trying to sell something that's already available online. I don't like the idea of removing stuff people have already had access to, especially with the adage of "Once it's posted on the internet, it's there forever", and I also don't really want to paywall people who are fans of my work. Since I'm not seeking to make a living off of this, I could leave it up and have the books be considered "A way to help support the author". It's a tricky subject.