Femininity.
14 years ago
General
For once I'm not feeling particularly sensitive on the issue of femininity but more that it's on the brain and I'm thinking about it in I guess a more detached and analytical way.
And I don't know that I see it this way because of societies objectification of women (not that it's necessarily a bad thing or one sided. Men are equally objectified or at least idealized to be a certain type and are by no means left out of this sort of expectation, just only in their own flavor.) but the whole expectation as to what's attractive or pretty for women.
Do women themselves dictate what is to be found attractive and feminine or do men?
Which is another good question I think. Because these days we more or less get to choose our attire with no repercussions. It's not like you're mistreated for wearing breeches or what ever these days, at least in the American culture.
Any how I guess I haven't really made any point yet I've just been rambling on some "disclaimer to avoid drama" topics.
But I guess what got me on the subject was that trash hole known as Facebook.
Now I tend to use it kinda for family and just in general to see what everybody's up to. I'm nosy what can I say. I don't post often myself and if I do it's always cryptic BS because that's how I am. I have no need to make momma worry any more about me than she already does. Aaany way. A friend of my Dad's posted a picture of her 72 year old mother sporting her mid-30's daughter's prom dress. Admittedly she looks good in it and I was impressed that she kept herself in that sort of shape. Now my Father posted on there that the lady's dad was a lucky man.
Which eh I guess is none of my business or anything but it gets me to thinking about what men find attractive, and from all ages. I grew up in an odd household. My Dad was 20 years my mother's Senior. Dad was born in the mid 40's to a poor farming family and grew up in I guess the "mountain man" sorta way. Fishing, hunting, trapping and farming for the necessities and working hard to earn money for the things they couldn't supply themselves. He grew up where the word "pregnant" was a hushed, almost a "bad" word. Women wore dresses and men got first servings from dinner and everybody took a bath on the same day in the same tub outside. It really was a different way of life and I gotta admit I really respect having gotten a taste of it in my upbringing. I feel it gives me some of my more wholesome/old fashion principles that a lot of folk from my generation don't have.
My mother on the other hand was born in the mid 60's and was a child of the 70's and 80's with her rock music and punk clothes, and leather pants. If you think of the television series "That 70's Show" where the whole gang hung out and was in and out of the houses and just in general growing up. That was mom. Now it wasn't in suburbia but it was back in the "hollar" so to speak. Infact it was "Tonghollow road". So, mix a little hard working redneck in there and knowing how to do with out as well.
And then I'm a product of all that plus the 90's and the new millennium. So I have a great conflict as to what's expected with femininity.
Anyone that knows me knows I do a fair amount of garbing/costuming and sewing. I attend renaissance festivals and enjoy Amtgard. For both of these the sort of "medieval" attire is accepted so I've become a pretty decent seamstress.
While sewing a friend's skirt as I would never dream wearing a dress or skirt myself, my dad commented how good a job I had done and that he missed that girls don't wear dresses any more and we got on the discussion of what was acceptable and attractive then and then to now. And why I wouldn't ever wear dresses because I felt like it took my "power" away. Now he's never said I had to wear anything in particular or dress a certain way and this wasn't one of those conversations, it was just a conversation.
But we got into the discussion that I felt wearing skirts or dresses made me feel vulnerable and like my power had been taken away and that I was useless and couldn't do anything. That it made me feel demoralized and objectified as a woman. And it's truthful. I do feel that way. If a dress even makes me look "sexy" or "grown up" or "buisnessy" I still feel vulnerable and powerless. I feel like I personally see women. Now wearing pants I feel empowered, in control, and independent. It was a little gut wrenching and weird to see my Dad tear up over me saying I was too independent and proud to be a stay at home housewife and such. I had too much bearing over myself to allow myself to be taken care of. To this day I'm not sure if he was proud of me or sad or both.
Growing up my mom was my friend. She often dressed in hand me down clothes and rarely bought herself new things and was often the sweatshirt and what ever pants she had around type. Then mom graduated college and got a teaching job. And you have to dress nice for that, and wear makeup to interviews, and that sort of thing. Now I was 7 or 8 at the time she started student teaching and substitute teaching and it was so odd to see my mom dressed up...that to me she wasn't my Mom when she was. She was this strange lady. Not that I didn't recognize her, but she just wasn't..."mom" any more. I felt she'd fallen into the category of "woman"...that was powerless and weak willed.
And now I'm married. So I finally feel like I have some femininity all the time. I am a wife, a house keeper, the mother of planned children later, I am...well woman. To a loving man who some how sees all the good in me and doesn't care about all the bad there is. He loves me in my jeans and t-shirts and messy pony tail and bed hair and being covered in paint and grass and mud and dirt and sweaty and hard working little woman. He loves me for me being me. But he says he also finds the elusive dress wearing, make up dabbling, perfume scented me. The me I'm afraid of being...afraid of becoming.
Now I know honestly nothing changes if I put on a dress, he or anybody doesn't see me any different. In fact it's usually the opposite of how I feel. A woman who dresses femininely is empowered and confident and full of well...being a woman and has control over men and others simply by being a woman.
I still don't feel that way though.
I didn't grow up with being a woman.
I grew up being a tomboy who understood women in the sense of a dress and house wife being old fashioned, and quiet, and obedient. I never understood or saw my Mother or any of the women in my family as women. We were all equal to everyone. If something needed done it didn't matter what was between your legs. A woman is just as capable of holding the front end of a tractor up in the middle of January with only a tarp for protection and a lantern for heat in her second trimester as a man is.
To me I grew up with no difference between men and women and gathered some odd fear of it.
This was mostly an odd ramble to get my thoughts out of my head. And some place I can see them.
Feel free to post your own opinions or ignore entirely.
And I don't know that I see it this way because of societies objectification of women (not that it's necessarily a bad thing or one sided. Men are equally objectified or at least idealized to be a certain type and are by no means left out of this sort of expectation, just only in their own flavor.) but the whole expectation as to what's attractive or pretty for women.
Do women themselves dictate what is to be found attractive and feminine or do men?
Which is another good question I think. Because these days we more or less get to choose our attire with no repercussions. It's not like you're mistreated for wearing breeches or what ever these days, at least in the American culture.
Any how I guess I haven't really made any point yet I've just been rambling on some "disclaimer to avoid drama" topics.
But I guess what got me on the subject was that trash hole known as Facebook.
Now I tend to use it kinda for family and just in general to see what everybody's up to. I'm nosy what can I say. I don't post often myself and if I do it's always cryptic BS because that's how I am. I have no need to make momma worry any more about me than she already does. Aaany way. A friend of my Dad's posted a picture of her 72 year old mother sporting her mid-30's daughter's prom dress. Admittedly she looks good in it and I was impressed that she kept herself in that sort of shape. Now my Father posted on there that the lady's dad was a lucky man.
Which eh I guess is none of my business or anything but it gets me to thinking about what men find attractive, and from all ages. I grew up in an odd household. My Dad was 20 years my mother's Senior. Dad was born in the mid 40's to a poor farming family and grew up in I guess the "mountain man" sorta way. Fishing, hunting, trapping and farming for the necessities and working hard to earn money for the things they couldn't supply themselves. He grew up where the word "pregnant" was a hushed, almost a "bad" word. Women wore dresses and men got first servings from dinner and everybody took a bath on the same day in the same tub outside. It really was a different way of life and I gotta admit I really respect having gotten a taste of it in my upbringing. I feel it gives me some of my more wholesome/old fashion principles that a lot of folk from my generation don't have.
My mother on the other hand was born in the mid 60's and was a child of the 70's and 80's with her rock music and punk clothes, and leather pants. If you think of the television series "That 70's Show" where the whole gang hung out and was in and out of the houses and just in general growing up. That was mom. Now it wasn't in suburbia but it was back in the "hollar" so to speak. Infact it was "Tonghollow road". So, mix a little hard working redneck in there and knowing how to do with out as well.
And then I'm a product of all that plus the 90's and the new millennium. So I have a great conflict as to what's expected with femininity.
Anyone that knows me knows I do a fair amount of garbing/costuming and sewing. I attend renaissance festivals and enjoy Amtgard. For both of these the sort of "medieval" attire is accepted so I've become a pretty decent seamstress.
While sewing a friend's skirt as I would never dream wearing a dress or skirt myself, my dad commented how good a job I had done and that he missed that girls don't wear dresses any more and we got on the discussion of what was acceptable and attractive then and then to now. And why I wouldn't ever wear dresses because I felt like it took my "power" away. Now he's never said I had to wear anything in particular or dress a certain way and this wasn't one of those conversations, it was just a conversation.
But we got into the discussion that I felt wearing skirts or dresses made me feel vulnerable and like my power had been taken away and that I was useless and couldn't do anything. That it made me feel demoralized and objectified as a woman. And it's truthful. I do feel that way. If a dress even makes me look "sexy" or "grown up" or "buisnessy" I still feel vulnerable and powerless. I feel like I personally see women. Now wearing pants I feel empowered, in control, and independent. It was a little gut wrenching and weird to see my Dad tear up over me saying I was too independent and proud to be a stay at home housewife and such. I had too much bearing over myself to allow myself to be taken care of. To this day I'm not sure if he was proud of me or sad or both.
Growing up my mom was my friend. She often dressed in hand me down clothes and rarely bought herself new things and was often the sweatshirt and what ever pants she had around type. Then mom graduated college and got a teaching job. And you have to dress nice for that, and wear makeup to interviews, and that sort of thing. Now I was 7 or 8 at the time she started student teaching and substitute teaching and it was so odd to see my mom dressed up...that to me she wasn't my Mom when she was. She was this strange lady. Not that I didn't recognize her, but she just wasn't..."mom" any more. I felt she'd fallen into the category of "woman"...that was powerless and weak willed.
And now I'm married. So I finally feel like I have some femininity all the time. I am a wife, a house keeper, the mother of planned children later, I am...well woman. To a loving man who some how sees all the good in me and doesn't care about all the bad there is. He loves me in my jeans and t-shirts and messy pony tail and bed hair and being covered in paint and grass and mud and dirt and sweaty and hard working little woman. He loves me for me being me. But he says he also finds the elusive dress wearing, make up dabbling, perfume scented me. The me I'm afraid of being...afraid of becoming.
Now I know honestly nothing changes if I put on a dress, he or anybody doesn't see me any different. In fact it's usually the opposite of how I feel. A woman who dresses femininely is empowered and confident and full of well...being a woman and has control over men and others simply by being a woman.
I still don't feel that way though.
I didn't grow up with being a woman.
I grew up being a tomboy who understood women in the sense of a dress and house wife being old fashioned, and quiet, and obedient. I never understood or saw my Mother or any of the women in my family as women. We were all equal to everyone. If something needed done it didn't matter what was between your legs. A woman is just as capable of holding the front end of a tractor up in the middle of January with only a tarp for protection and a lantern for heat in her second trimester as a man is.
To me I grew up with no difference between men and women and gathered some odd fear of it.
This was mostly an odd ramble to get my thoughts out of my head. And some place I can see them.
Feel free to post your own opinions or ignore entirely.
FA+

Although that would be one hell of a door mat.
Just... wow
It's like, I feel more confident with myself in like a plain, kinda fitted black t-shirt and dark blue jeans than anything else.
Put me in a blouse and nice slacks and sensible shoes, and oh god I'm like a terrified chihuahua.
I'd just more or less have to desensitize myself to it.
It honestly doesn't matter enough to me to change it, but it's a random thought. Like I said this wasn't so much a rant of oh woe is me, as it was thoughts on femininity itself.
I'm male, but "scruffy" ... but to me attire is like playing to an audience, I've always thought. If you have to dress up to get a job because of a need to meet a clothing standard of "professional person", then the hypocrisy / inanity of the situation is with the audience, not the player (you). If anything, you can probably pat yourself on the back a bit for realizing and managing that factor to your advantage; and if you feel it goes too far for your comfort, then you've got to find the comfort zone of their expectations and your limits ... and if they don't like that, then that would probably be a good thing as you'd not be happy either.
I guess the ramble is that you wear whatever/ act however for yourself and THEN "everyone else" to some degree ... if you want to do something for a single audience (Hoss) then that won't brand you as some stereotype (or as **not** some stereotype if you don't!) and doesn't say you have to act the same in front of a different audience. Femininity / masculinity is the same - varies by audience, and the judgement standards of some audiences/cultures (Facebook?) are so distorted/fickle as to be nearly insane... As for your mom, maybe just think of it as you got to see her in her dressing room everyday before the performance?
Enough ramble... but do talk it over if it's making you feel unhappy?
I have a very powerful personality and a lot of less-than familiar with me friends (M and F) are completely intimidated.
My wife and inner circle of female friends are total strong willed piratessess... they do things because they want and if anyone trashes them for looking "too girly" or "too butch", they learn where the term 'verbal cutthroat' comes from
just don't forget the powdered wigs.
I didn't feel I compromised anything I stood for or believed by doing it. Now im a banker of 16+ years with a bankers haircut and not crazy wardrobe, but I also have tattoos no one at work can see and wear a silver multiskull ring on one hand.
Guess what Im saying is, maybe work on accepting you are you no matter the clothes, and to hell with what society may think or judges..be it in dress or jeans, coarset or tshirt :)
More or less this was a rant or a thought process on femininity and how it's perceived by folks and what some consider it, or how unimportant or even intimidating to some. Not that I was looking for anything for myself, just yanno a thought process.
Also yes, jeans jacket, metal shirts, and blue jeans...I am a fan of this XD
Also.. SLAYER! SLAYER.. ok, nuff rambling
If they ever "dressed up", it was merely a case of finding matching clothes...
To me, wearing dresses is actually a very sexy thing to do
sometimes slutty depending on how short it is...
but generally I didn't get much experience in with dresses other than what I wore to junior school (knee-length, green-chequered dress for summer) and what my elder cousins used to dress me up in for laughs ;3
I was at the airport coming back from EF, and I saw not one, but two ladies with the shortest skirts imaginable
I mentioned this to my mate, and on one hand he said "Doesn't bother me *winkwink*" and on the other hand (after one of them had crouched down to tend to her hand-luggage, showing knickers and all) he then said "Actually that's not a good idea"
so in essence he agreed with me that there's being feminine, and then there's trying too hard/becoming an object
If I can find the right sort of dress and the "right conditions", then I feel confident, sexy and feminine
though I can feel just as feminine with the right kind of t-shirt & jeans combo... it's mostly what's inside that counts ^^
the rest is up to how you see yourself (properly knowing your body type, being comfortable etc) ^^
And...dresses I donno, if I'm not terrified and staring at the floor I feel constantly slutty in them. And I'm talking knee length to mid calf length with a sensible neckline making me feel slutty.
I know it isn't true, but what goes on in my head doesn't have to be what everybody else thinks either. To me dresses have become the "special occasion hubby you did good I'ma wear this for you and we don't go out. Is only for you" thing.
And as far as dressing myself I can do it, I just choose not to put more effort into it than t-shirt and jeans...because there's no point and $$$$.
This journal was more about me just rambling than anything and seeing if anyone else had an opinion.
I bet you'd rock a Versace 3-piece though O.o
My day is complete <3
Too much titties for those furries and they may explode.
So I too have taken to that sort of, I'll dress practically but I'll wear a little eyeliner so I feel like I got boobs.
"If a dress even makes me look "sexy" or "grown up" or "buisnessy" I still feel vulnerable and powerless. I feel like I personally see women." ... "I felt she'd fallen into the category of "woman"...that was powerless and weak willed."
I don;t think that women have to be unisex to be strongly women; to be equal, to be.. anything etc. Like MLP teaches us, you can be Applejack OR Rarity and still be a woman. In the way that you can be a lot of different things and still be a man. You can be womanly and pretty and whatnot and still be just as powerful, strong, unique, whatever.
But! I get that it's just not you, and it doesn't have to be. There are clothes that are or are not me, and I'd feel less manly or dudely or sharp or whatever in. I have my fashion to suit who I am.
I'd try hard not to criticse anyone for thier fashion choices, though. ..though this year at Anthrocon some people TEST THAT LINE arrrgh fffff.
--Chi
But that is...I guess...uh Sexist? of me?
Now granted someone like Rarity can convince others' to do the job for her with her charms or what have you but even that isn't always an option.
I also see what you're saying though, a person can still be useful, feminine, masculine, or what ever they need or want to be. I admit I'm quick to judge some of these things as well.
I guess for me it comes down probably to being capable anduseful. By all means I'm capable of fashion choices in both categories but I'm more comfortable being casual.
Yes and Cons always bring out the best and the brightest fashionistas XDDD
I've seen girls who look great with no makeup, and I've seen some that honestly need it. There are some who MAJORLY over-apply it. Oy. :)
I understand your desire to be self-suffieicient , capable, useful, all such. These are good and grand things, and I think as long as you let your sense of fashion/comfort/self-image/femininity work for you.. and be understandign that it's not what works for everyone, a bit.. you're in good shape.
They key to it is to wear what you like. It helps if you look good in what you like; one cut of jeans can look good on one person but trash on another. I, personally, hated skirts and dresses for the longest time. Not because I felt like they made me too girly or anything, but because I have ENORMOUS FUCKING HIPS FROM HELL and I thought it looked BAD. I've only recently begun wearing them, because I've dropped enough weight that I don't look like a block of tofu with two toothpick legs sticking out from the bottom of it and an olive head.
Seriously. Picture that. That is totally accurate, yo.
I've found in my line of work that most people just don't know how to dress themselves. We've been crammed with images about what looks 'good', instead of being taught to love ourselves as the individuals we are. I can't tell you how many ladies I've seen CRY because they don't look how they think they should-- they're wearing a size too big, or their bra size isn't want they think it should be, or none of the jeans they try on fit right because the cut just isn't the right one...
Wear what you like, Sarcy. Anything can be feminine when it's done right... and if you don't WANT to look feminine, then don't stress about appearing to be so.
But yeah I am capable of dressing myself, I just choose to wear t-shirts and jeans because...well they're low maintenance and I can do ANY thingin them...well maybe except for a highend dining experience...which I'm unlikely to do anyway.
I mean hell, I got married in bluejeans, a black t-shirt over a neon orange longsleeve T and barefoot...so who cares, right?
Mostly just thank you for putting your thoughts on the subject out there. YOu are a brave donk. :)
I've had to explain this a lot in my lifetime because folks think I'm sexist or just plain weird because of the odd ways I feel about these subjects. But I frankly think a lot of people do feel this way and don't bring it up, or put it this way exactly because of how heavy an emphasis there is on appearance in any culture and we don't wish to be ostracized for it.
I often feel powerless to even do or say anything about these problems, because what I say doesn't matter. What any guy says doesn't matter. If a woman was told by an entire bar full of men that she didn't need makeup to be pretty, she'd still wear it, because she doesn't "feel" pretty or feminine without it. Just another form of security blanket. But she has the freedom to do it, and there's nothing stopping her.. so... she does it.
I personally may only wear makeup (and mind you when I do it's more or less just mascara...that's it...) once every couple months, just to have a change of pace but you know the days that I get most complimented are on days I don't wear it? I have one man who tells me I don't need makeup to be pretty, if I had a whole bar of men tell me that I'd probably pass out from sheer joy that all that stuff could be thrown away and not exist.
But I have other security blankets. I won't wear anything shorter than knee length. I won't wear shirts that the sleeves aren't to my elbows or longer. Yadda yadda yadda. I'll rarely wear makeup in public to avoid looking trashy. I won't curl my hair and style it to go out for the same fear, but I'll happily jazz myself up for around the house.
But honestly what you say to some women goes in one ear and out the other, but I think alot of them take what you say in consideration for a later date. And then there are the hormonal days where nothing anyone says or thinks will make a difference to a woman....give her some chocolate and set her in a corner some where. Again though that's likely me being sexist.
To me, femininity isn't what you wear or some arbitrary set of just-so truisms derived from religious institutions. Femininity to me is just how a person with XX chromosomes, an endocrine system and ladyparts acts and what they do. Any way that a female acts is appropriately feminine, whether it's burping loudly and working on car engines and remaining single for the rest of their lives by choice (and none of these things is a packaged deal, just an extreme collection of examples) or doing the little wifey thing and popping out a dozen kids and having prim and proper lace parties and a dozen meaningless holidays just meant to socialize people. To me, it's all equally feminine because a female is doing it. There's no right or wrong way to be a woman. The only wrong way is to live by what society or other people say defines you by your sex. When they do that, they're trying to impose their values and power over you.
My personal stance on the dress code as it pertains to gender warfare is that one has complete reign of outfitting oneself, and advances in gender equality had opened up the previously inaccessible option of casual women's clothing - something chosen for its utility rather than attractiveness(although the two are by no means mutually exclusive, as often as they are found at odds with each other). Wearing overalls or their analogue strips the wearer of any announced purpose of their attire - it's just clothes. And the depressingly persistent tradition of heated rivalry in aesthetical self-advertisement equates having no added value of carefully chosen garments with diminishing the value of the person wearing the clothes, so I can imagine how one can develop an apprehension about that baggage of uncalled for connotations.
However, while I view the blatantly self-marketing, fashion-adhering outfits and impractical footwear with emotions ranging from indifference to contempt, I am easily swayed to show admiration of purely decorative garb in case they are presented as a piece of art. Craftsmanship is something to respect, and a tastefully put-together period dress prepared for a Renaissance Fair exhibition, or simply an evening dress that showcases the designer's creativity would find my praise in spite of my generally held conviction that any outfit that wouldn't be adequate for catching a but is a waste of thread and fabric. Something of a My Little Pony distinction that the character of Rarity represents: the creation is designed with artistic prowess and according to the artist's sense of coherence, rather than a trend-chasing duplication of the latest craze.
I often commit the crime of adding something to Favourites without saying anything, but lest I forget or neglect to say it further down the line, the "Hipposaloongal" drawing is gorgeous in many important ways, such as convincingly accomplishing the seemingly impossible task to anthropomorphize a hippopotamus, and is a magnificent collaboration overall, but that gown deserves special notice in connection to this journal, complete with flamboyant plumage. It's peculiar to wear something as screamingly vivacious as a uniform of sorts.
Thank you for the time it took to read it !