Question for Non-Native English Speakers
13 years ago
So I have quite a few characters who don't speak English as a first language, and I love writing short stories about my characters. But I myself speak only English and have very little experience with learning other languages.
So, my question is, for those of you who speak multiple languages and/or learned English as a second or third language, what was the hardest part? Is there anything about English that makes it really difficult to learn, or anything that took you a while to get the hang of, or that you still have problems with? Or even for people with English as a first language who speak a few others, is there anything you've noticed about English that is very different compared to other languages? I've always heard people say it's one of the hardest to learn if you don't grow up speaking it, so I'm very curious.
I have tried learning so many languages but I think I have some mental block in my brain, I can never get the hang of them. Different strengths, I guess. Anyway, thank you all in advance!
So, my question is, for those of you who speak multiple languages and/or learned English as a second or third language, what was the hardest part? Is there anything about English that makes it really difficult to learn, or anything that took you a while to get the hang of, or that you still have problems with? Or even for people with English as a first language who speak a few others, is there anything you've noticed about English that is very different compared to other languages? I've always heard people say it's one of the hardest to learn if you don't grow up speaking it, so I'm very curious.
I have tried learning so many languages but I think I have some mental block in my brain, I can never get the hang of them. Different strengths, I guess. Anyway, thank you all in advance!
FA+

Hm, Well. I had problems with learning the time tenses. I think it's a bit difficult :/
But still if I compare English with the other languages I speak, it's otherwise the easiest one (especially if I compare it with languages such as German where I keep forgetting a lot of the vocabulary and grammar whereas with English I get to see the language written everywhere and keep learning more words). But would definitely say the main "trouble" I ever had with English was about pronunciation. And still if I see some words I haven't seen before or that often, I might have no clue how to pronounce it as there's not many distinct rules about that whereas in some other languages I speak, including my native, everything is pronounced like it's written... if that makes any sense XD but basically the letters are always pronounced the same way, no matter the order they are in or the length of the word etc.
Apparently many people's brains have trouble distinguishing certain sounds if they have not heard them when they were young. For example, "l" and "r" can sound the same for someone who has not heard both growing up.
But I also have trouble listening people talking in different accents, like the British accent. And, yeah, the time tenses weren't so hard for me since my mother tongue has the hardest time tenses ever (It is Portuguese by the way).
English is my first language, and I have had some classes in French, German, Spanish, and Portuguese. I think in general I find reading the easiest, then writing/hearing are pretty close, but speaking a foreign language is definitely hardest.
With writing you don't have to worry about pronunciation but you do need to remember grammar and vocabulary. With listening, it is more recognition of vocabulary and grammar so that is easier except you have to deal with pronunciation and people speaking too quickly. With speaking you have to deal with grammar, vocabulary, AND pronunciation! ugh
So i guess that's three points for tenses :p
But I really hope that I would get better at pronouncing English becouse I have a terrible Finnish accent.
http://www.tumblr.com/tagged/lexica.....aps-in-english
Like, here are some English lexical gaps. Might not be very helpful x3 but hey.
Actually , I had a lot of problems, pfft.
-Time tenses
-Not using too many words (we overuse words)
-an and a
-correct order
-phrases and tenses
-emotions. In english there are a lot of different words for one emotion. I'm not used to most.
Also a lot of people I know who aren't native English speakers tend to have problems with a lot of phrases which are just said differently in their language. I used to have a neighbour who was a native French speaker who always said 'close' instead of 'turn off' ("Close the lights", "Close the TV", etc.). It's probably worth looking into what expressions don't translate from your character's language to English/vice versa.
Also pronunciation, as a lot of sounds are more commonly used in one language than another, particularly accents and such.
Really! In english you've not the same Humor, the same Joke time... And sometimes I feel REALLY akward when I talk to native english person!
And the Passive/active form are really hard to me... Yeah. It seem idiot , but this is problematic x)
English was exactly the same, grammar-wise. I'd mix words together in a sentence not knowing my grammar is wrong, and only sometimes I notice that it's wrong. Everything else was fairly simple. Spanish for me can be a pain, but English is what I mainly use because it's easy for me to communicate. :>
But all in all i love English, I often intend to think in English and sometimes I can't find the words in my own language, haha.
We also start learning English very early, which helps a great deal. I will probably never get rid of the accent that reveals me as a non-native speaker but other than that, my English is pretty much native-level (at least according to my English/American friends).
However, I actually have great fun learning languages. So far I've had French and English in school, Spanish for a year in Uni and Korean for half a year, and my major is Japanese studies... so yeah, languages are fun to me! Which makes it a bit harder to assess how others who are not as enthusiastic might think about it... I know my friends used to hate grammar stuff (I love it, actually) and learning vocabulary. If you were looking for typical mistakes that a German character would make in English, I think I could help you with that.
A lot of the problems with learning a new language probably come down to the other language being from a different language family. As far as I know, German and English (and several other European languages) are from the same family and thus have more things in common and are easier to learn respectively. Whereas if you start to learn Japanese or Korean, you are confronted with a completely different system (starting with a whole different "alphabet") but if you already know Japanese or Korean, learning the other becomes easier since you'd be familiar with the system...
I hope all of this makes sense to you somehow... I probably digressed far from what you were asking for xD Oh well