So, I freaking love Borderlands 2. It's awesome. I seem to be doomed not to play it, however. Months back, my controller started acting up. While I was trying to get it working again, I bumped the console, causing the disk to get a big circular scratch that made it unplayable. No borderlands for months.

I finally got it replaced a month or two ago. Today my chair got tipped over while I was taking something off of it. Fell over. Missed the console, but bumped the stand it was on. Now the replacement disk has the exact same scratch as the original. The. Exact. Same. Scratch.

I take good care of my games. I have never gotten this kind of damage on any other game I own. Ever. Yet it's happened to Borderlands 2 twice.
What the absolute fuck, reality?