Super star destroyer for the win!

<plunges into uncompleted Death Star like a poorly made paper airplane>1

GO ENTERPRISE-E!!!!!!!!!!!

Photon torpedoes...full spread! FIRE!

DIRECT HIT!!!!!

hmm..in firepower...star wars (so far as i can tell) in realism though its gotta be divided...star trek is polically more accurate. but star wars has more realistic aliens(I refuse to believe that the only sentient lifeforms in the galaxy all appear human with a few small differences) but I still love them both lol

Hard to compare the two sets of technology. The Star Wars capital ships are certainly much larger than the Federation starships; but I don't recall there being any kind of force-field shielding technology in Star Wars, and the Federation ships would be much more manueverable than the Empire's ships. (remember The Battle of Salamis?) But overall I thought the result of the video portrayed exactly what each side would do if they came into contact.

As far as the sentient lifeforms go...that's a whole nother journal entry right there! But for me, even the Star Wars aliens are still too humanoid - sure they have better costumes instead of just having ridges glued to their foreheads, but they are all still upright bipedal humanoids with opposable thumbs, except for Jabba The Hutt, and there doesn't seem like there was even a race of his kind...

I'd like to see more variety of sentient beings like the Horta from Star Trek: The Campy Generation, or the Navigators from Dune, or the intelligent Dolphins from David Brin's Startide Rising...

From my standpoint it was almost a tie. SInce the destroyer was destroyed and not the enterprise. However the enterprise retreated when the death star was about to fire.

As they should have. They were vastly outnumbered!

Star Wars would whoop Star Treks ass, I do like both as well

I dunno...

•The Star Wars technology didn't seem to have any shielding technology that didn't involve slabs of reinforced metal.

•Their capital ships are very unmanuverable and large compared to the Federation (or Klingons or Romulans or Jem-Hadar...).

•The Death Star's weapon could seriously only be used against something as large and slow as a planet or Star Destroyer.

•They are very dependant on Tie-Fighters which could be all quickly taken out by a couple of starships.

•And they are stupid enough to build their Death Star with blast ports that lead to their reactor chamber allowing a single photon torpedo to destroy the entire thing. Mr. Worf would have picked that weakness up on sensors within minutes of contact!

•Also the Star Trek crews (also Klingons, Romulans) are highly trained, creative and motivated individuals...the Empire ships are commanded by guys afraid for their very lives if they make one mistake, and their stormtroopers can't see where they're going and bang their head when they enter a room and couldn't hit the broad side of Jabba The Hutt with their blasters!


I think it's a matter of how many Federation ships there are, and if any Klingons, Romulans or others are assisting them. Because the Empire's fleets shown in the movies are very massive indeed!

I was kind of thinking Jedi vs. some Starfleet officer

Oh....yeah! No contest whatsoever!

Jedi are so cool

You know it!