Laptop Recommendations?
12 years ago
Just a quick question for you experts out there: anybody have a suggestion for a reasonable but semi-modern laptop? The one I have is starting to get a little long in the tooth and I was thinking about upgrading. Then I might actually be able to draw efficiently while away from my main workstation!
I'd be looking for something that could smoothly run Manga Studio 5, ArcGIS, Civilization V and Europa Universalis IV. Because really, what more does one need in life? :P Beyond that I don't think I have a need for any other bells and whistles.
Any suggestions???
[EDIT] Wow, thanks for all the suggestions! I think I've got plenty to go on now :D
I'd be looking for something that could smoothly run Manga Studio 5, ArcGIS, Civilization V and Europa Universalis IV. Because really, what more does one need in life? :P Beyond that I don't think I have a need for any other bells and whistles.
Any suggestions???
[EDIT] Wow, thanks for all the suggestions! I think I've got plenty to go on now :D
FA+

Don't buy an HP unless it's an Envy or Pavillion, they have some of the worst reliability ratings [I've seen evidence of this first hand].
Also don't bother with an Alienware, 50% of the money you spend is for the name "Alienware" anyhow.
Though for that price anything with an i5/i7 and a discreete graphics card will do you good o u o Asus, Acer, and Toshiba have some really nice models~
I would Gladly get another one, matter of fact, when my HP dies I plan on getting another Acer
and this is coming from a guy that worked at IBM for three years
You can easily get something with an intel core i5 or i7... Those are currently the best in terms of processors... You'll also need a good graphics card, which I think you can get too, I personally prefer AMD RADEON IF you can find something above the 5000 series... But anything with a GPU of more than 2 GBs should be perfect for a laptop!
As far as brand goes, I don't know how much of a difference the brand really makes. I've had good experience with Toshiba, but then I've only owned two laptops of my own. ^_^;;
From http://www.videocardbenchmark.net/
PassMark - G3D Mark
Radeon HD 6250 - 117
Radeon HD 5770 - 1,680
(Figured I'd look 'em up after pulling the model numbers out of thin air, just to make sure I wasn't giving you bad information. Didn't think the difference was THAT huge, but it makes sense.)
Though I must admit it was an expensive one....
It just depends on your budget, what you intend to do with it and how long you wish to use it.
Go for a cheap Acer: it will function fast enough, though not very reliably. You will buy a new one after 1-4 years depending on use. 6 years if you stretch it with repairs and upgrades.
Go for an expensive ASUS: it will function fast, reliably and solid. You will buy a new one after 4-7 years depending on use. 9 years if you stretch it with repairs and upgrades.
But MOST importantly is aesthetics:
make sure that the keyboard, mousepad and buttons are comfortable to use,
the screen is easy to read from,
and that it's not too noisy.
Speakers that are able to have a loud volume is a plus.
These things make a difference in between loving your notebook or being utterly annoyed, whether expensive or cheap.
I wish you good luck in finding a laptop to your liking!
(btw, lots of advice on this page =p)
Don't just look at the sticker cost: See what's inside the unit first.
Really look at the warranty that the unit comes with at that price.
Does it cover everything?
How long does it take the company to fix things based on this warranty?
Do they send someone to you?
Do they just mail you parts, email you a manual and a "Good luck...?" card?
Do you have to ship the system to them?
Who pays for the postage on parts and service?
How long is this covered?
What if I drop it at the train station and crack the screen? Is that covered? (surprise: in most cases, NO, that's not covered, and you get to foot the bill for all the parts and labor to bring it up and running.)
If you can, call the company that will end up supporting the machine and talk to someone in tech support. Keep the call brief, if you can -- five or ten minutes of the agent's time. Ask them a few questions about the current line of systems, and emphasize that you'd prefer to ask someone who has to help support the machines about things you should know about before buying. Most support agents I've encountered actually appreciate the time to help someone make smart buying decisions, instead of hearing about it two months after you buy the machine and hate half of all the shit in it.
Don't just look at the consumer systems -- you might find more agreeable deals looking at the small to medium business line of systems.
Need Windows 7 instead of Windows 8? Best reason to look at the business systems.
If you have a sense of paranoia that won't let you return storage devices if a hard drive fails, ask the company at, or within the return period after purchase, if they have a provision that would allow you to keep your hard drive, should one fail. As of the time of this message, I know that Dell offers a 'Keep Your Hard Drive' warranty, and that it's pretty doggone cheap.
Consider weight when looking. I'd be at home with, for example, a Dell Precision Mobile Workstation M6700, but the machine weighs ten pounds at the very least. Some users aren't comfortable with a portable workstation of that weight.
Don't skimp on the screen. Generally, they will try to use the cheapest screen they can, which yields a 1366x768 pixel resolution, even on a 15" display.
If you're drawing, chances are this is too small.
If I distilled all of that stuff down (tl; dr) to the essences, they'd taste like:
Get accidental damage coverage unless the warranty already has it.
Get an onsite warranty - depot boxes suck and take two to three weeks to be handled.
Expect to pay more up front to not get screwed in the back.
Consider opting in to keep your hard drive instead of sending it back if you have to replace it.
Phew. I'm not normally this chatty. Sorry. ^^;
I do tech support for a living for a certain company.
Much of what I bring up is based on half a decade of answering these questions for callers.
To that end, I can fill in some of the blanks if you're considering a Dell. My data's based on purchases made in the USA. Unless country-specific, the data should apply worldwide.
1: No, your default warranty does not include accidental damage coverage. Feeding your laptop a smoothie does not a free repair get when the laptop proves it's food intolerant. If it's a laptop, get the accidental damage coverage. Yes, it's probably $100 up front. The cost of replacing parts without it in an accidental damage based situation is not cheap: $179 for the tech, plus the cost of parts.
2: PLEASE, opt for a machine with a next business day onsite warranty. When sending a machine to Depot if you're dealing with Dell in the USA, one of the cost saving measures is to pick the machine up via FedEx SmartPost, which means it'll take two weeks for the depot in Texas to receive the machine, IF it doesn't get snarbled up in the grand machine that is FedEx + USPS. It'll ship back quickly, though.
A corollary in the form of 2a: Guarantee and Warranty aren't the same word. This is important to point out for all companies. Next Business Day isn't a guarantee. It's a warranty offering that suggests that once the part is available to be shipped from warehouse to the tech or the end user, it should arrive on the next business day. Emphasis on 'part is available'. I've had so many calls where it is suggested that we promised everything will arrive on the next day and the computer will be up and running. If a part's on backlog, then we're stuck waiting for it, unless we find a way to prove the part's not needed.
3: Business line machines get better support offerings. One of the most voiced complaints I get is based on support in India (often accompanied by "Thank God you speak English!"). I've listened in on a warm transfer or fifty, and can say that the complaints I hear are well founded. I won't touch specifics, but I will say that some support queues, not just Dell's, but even their competitors, are filled with warm bodies collecting a check. Based on my own observations, the customers I deal with loathe being transferred to our Basic Consumer queue, which is mostly based out of India, but don't seem to mind being transferred to our Basic Small Business Queue, which is generally out of the Philippines.
4: Opt for the operating system media when purchasing. Dell was one of the last companies in the USA to switch away from shipping media by default. The discs usually cost $2 or $3 a piece at time of ordering. It'll save you from needing to go out and get a handful of dual layer DVD-RW discs when you buy the machine to make your own OS media.
... I've done it again.
I've gone chatty.
Sorry. ^^;
You can easily buy a ridiculously powerful Sager for under $2000, but the sound quality of the speakers is kinda bad, the built in mic is going to be bad, and while the keyboard isn't bad, it isn't optimal for perfect-precision gaming. The plus side is that you get a crazy powerful computer with a durable chassis, decent cooling, nice screen.
I don't know exactly how to relate it in terms of car brands.. but think of Sager as spending almost all the money on the engine and the interior of the car, while keeping the outside on the downlow =p. Basically, you get good graphics/processor performance and a good screen, which are the parts I'd assume you are prioritizing.
Depending on how long you want to wait, if you're willing to wait until the end of 2013 to early 2014, AMD will have their next generation CPU and GPUs out. i7's are pretty overkill for any GPU you can get in a laptop and AMD is almost always cheaper than Intel for good performance. I'm hoping their next gen CPUs compete in the high end with Intel than their current offerings. Also, AMD APU's are miles better than even Intel's latest APU's.
Other than that. I recommend ASUS.
Toshiba Satellite C655-S5132 w/ windows 7. the thing has no hdmi port, can barely run Portal, and a derped internal wifi card
...yeah I know nothing :P
Therefore my recommendation would be Crusader Kings II, to get the most time out of your century spanning empire in EU4. And yes, play with Sunset Invasion as well, like the hardest of hardcore. >:)
Now if you excuse me, the Wendish Empire does not manage itself. I have a handful of plotting brothers and cousins that I'm- OH GOD REVOLTS!
Is there an EUIV to Victoria II converter? It would be fun to take your Wendish Empire all the way into HoI3 :3
With CK2 I feel I have to make more strategic choices with more than just battles of soldiers, but battles of diplomacy... including marriage proposals. Although, I've only played CK2 and EU3, and never have actually reached the end of a game before my save file explodes, or Russia happens. But I still hope to one day play as the Inca and survive past the Spanish invasion! Only then will I consider myself worthy of venturing into the world of Victoria II and beyond!
Oh... maximum digression from the topic, whoops. :P
-Atma
I'll check those websites for sure. (Good lord, that 17 incher must be huge!)
Good luck!
-Atma
If you want it to fly off in terms of speed, exchange the hard drive for an Samsung pro series SSD ;3
I had good luck with HP and bad luck with Toshiba which I have now. Every now and again it has epileptic fits and freezes for about three seconds with a loud buzzing sound.
Mac - definitely if you can afford it.
V.
Hadn't even considered a Mac! Good point! Plus my employer seems to be gradually moving toward them over PC's... I should probably figure out how to use Apple products to stay ahead of the curve.
V.
Solid quality laptops with decent prices
Though their customer service is a little lacking they make a great laptop
The Y series is the gaming laptops with dual hard drives one solid state and the other a typical hard drive with HD screens on them
http://shop.lenovo.com/us/en/laptop.....-series/y510p/
the normal one is under 1,000$
Get it and buy a larger solid state hard drive (MSATA type) and cram more memory into it for the ideal laptop
Your can even get a secondary graphics card in them for SLI fun
http://shop.lenovo.com/us/en/laptop.....01C9:0000ECB1:
Anyway, for about $2500 back in 2010:
Intel Core i7 Q740 (quad core, each core running at 1.73GHz)
4GB DDR3 RAM
500GB HDD, 7200RPM
ATI Mobility Radeon HD 5850
15'' HD monitor (1920 x 1080)
Windows 7 64 Home Premium
Blu-Ray drive (read only)/DVD and CD burner
Mind you, that was 2010, it was pretty powerful at the time for a notebook. I actually honestly had some problems with the stock Blu-Ray drive, and bought a Sony Optiarc drive from Newegg and installed it myself. I've also since upgraded it to its max memory of 8GB.
I honestly find the case to be one of the most durable things I've ever seen with a laptop, though I realize the design is not to everyone's taste. (I also admittedly really wanted the lights in the keyboard and such.) Speakers are decent, too, by the way.
Anyway, I guess not so much a recommendation as it is to tell you that I've had no regrets choosing an Alienware, and this system is approaching on 3 years old, and can still run most modern games on normal settings. It also tends not to get too hot or anything, though I keep mine on a desk and use an external keyboard since the desk is uncomfortably high to be trying to type on.
Anyway, I'm certain my reply will be met with some criticism about "you bought a fancy glowing paperweight" or something, but as stated, I've had no issues with it (aside from the aforementioned Blu-Ray drive, which I admit was after the warranty had ended, and the upgrade consisted of taking the entire machine apart, but it wasn't a difficult procedure, keeping in mind that I do hardware support for a living.) I also will admit that a portion of the price is paying for the branding, but it's also noteworthy that the base install has NO crapware on it. It literally comes as a clean OS with all of your drivers and the programs for your various hardware installed... and I had them preload Steam and WoW since that was free.)
I personally couldn't recommend alienware for anyone, high end laptops are being offered by just about every manufacturer and the vast majority are cheaper. Most have at least equal specs and some have better.
Alienware used to have some of the best laptops around, of course at a premium price. But they usually offered features that other laptop manufactures didn't have. The highest definition screens combined with the latest graphics cards. Unfortunately since it's acquisition by Dell there has been a noticeable watering down of the technologically advanced components that they add in. Yes they update the laptops, but that is basically all they do now, falling into a rut of "just update them" without adding in new experimental features. Essentially, every other manufacture now has the same lineup that they do but the other manufactures are more willing to experiment and add in different things.
My favorite laptop over several decades of having various brands would be the lenovo I currently have (Lenovo Y580). Mainly because of the dual hard drive. A Solid State /Traditional 1TB hard drive (A feature only included on the highest priced, 17 inch+ only Dell (2,239$).. comes on the 800$ lenovo) combined with the high end graphics card and HD screen. The ability to later on add in a second graphics card (removing the blueray drive) turning the laptop into an SLI graphics combo is what really takes the cake. Doesn't hurt that it's half aluminum either.
The speakers are the best i've heard on a laptop so far, but my last two laptops were Asus's.. so *shrug*
I honestly don't mind Dell on the whole, I've personally had no problems with them, though my sister did because of incompetent IT support in India. (Like 3 calls she made to them, they did nothing to help her except have her do a factory restore. I called them once, stated what I had diagnosed the issue as, told them exactly how much shit they gave my sister, and they transferred me to someone who actually did resolve the issue. For the record, it was a bad driver on the factory image that they didn't have the fixed version of on their website. >.>)
I've honestly had a lot more trouble with HP as far as support (A previous help desk/hardware tech job involved pretty much negotiating with them to get a failed RAID controller replaced. Awful, awful hardware and support.)
Anyway, I realize that the Alienware is not the best, doesn't have all of the bells and whistles that it could, and all that. If I had gone with the M17x or M18x, they did have the dual HDD option available, as well as a full-sized keyboard with the number pad, but I ended up not going for that.
Also, a big part of why I went with the Alienware, and this is important... my family has a line of credit with them, and we can buy anything we want from them for 0% interest for a year. I probably could have pulled some strings and gotten something similar with another manufacturer, but we've got that standing, they had what I wanted, so that was that. :P
I will also admit that, at the time, I worked with this tool that had a Sager laptop, wouldn't shut up about it, either... and he really pissed me off because he was seen as the best thing ever (he honestly did a half assed job, was a naive twat, and eventually was instrumental in me losing my job. Mind you it wasn't like he knew he was part of the reason, but when he kept transferring calls for me to our COO that had a similar name to me, it really makes it look like I'm doing a poor job and they're demanding a supervisor...)
Uh, anyway... point is, when the time comes to get another laptop... I would likely get another Alienware, to be honest. But I'll see what's available at the time, you know?
Well since you have a relationship with them I would suggest trying to purchase future items from them through their business side. If you can swing that with them anyways, you'd probably have to make a business account with them to do it though.
The business support is vastly superior to the consumer support (having purchased several hundred servers through them over the years for work).
It seems the general opinion of them isn't as high as it once was, but as you can see in the comments above, I honestly like what I got for the money.
... and part of the price seems to be that they don't subsidize the cost of the hardware by installing adware on the machine to start. (Those $300 laptops you get at Best Buy almost always have 40,000 free trials of this or that on there, that actually is paid for by the companies that make the software, and then HP or whatever will take a small amount off the price.)
So that's something to keep in mind as well. Though I think some of the companies are seriously doing the "no crapware" thing without actually charging more. Not sure how they do it, though.