Art advice: Badmouthing?
11 years ago
Fellow artists, I need some advice.
I made a head for someone a few months back, and the commission ordeal aside, when they got it, they had a number of complaints, which instead of telling me, they posted a really scathing review. The review was never posted(to the review group) because most of their complaints were.. very strange(Complaints like I used elastic instead of rubber bands, or didnt use straps in their head). I found this out VIA SOMEONE ELSE, contacted them and asked them to clarify what the problems were, and if they told me I would be more than happy to either refund them for the head or fix any issues.
They freaked out at me, told me I ripped them off and that they'd have to make "A number of changes but they'd probably sell it because it was so terrible".
Fast foreward to this week, and holy crap are they everywhere. Before posting anything about their suit, they're all "Don't commission this person". And I mean everywhere. They don't list whats wrong publicly and tell people they have to contact them for details- obviously because a lot of the complaints are ridiculous. But people probably won't, they'll probably take what this guy is saying and run with it.
Now, I've got a pretty good reputation because in the 5 years I've been doing this I've only had 2 people who were dissatisfied(That includes this person), but I'm constrained by "Professionalism" not to jump on their posts and say "Actually here are the problems you listed, I offered to fix them, you turned me down".
I really don't know how to approach this on a professional level. Suggestions?
I made a head for someone a few months back, and the commission ordeal aside, when they got it, they had a number of complaints, which instead of telling me, they posted a really scathing review. The review was never posted(to the review group) because most of their complaints were.. very strange(Complaints like I used elastic instead of rubber bands, or didnt use straps in their head). I found this out VIA SOMEONE ELSE, contacted them and asked them to clarify what the problems were, and if they told me I would be more than happy to either refund them for the head or fix any issues.
They freaked out at me, told me I ripped them off and that they'd have to make "A number of changes but they'd probably sell it because it was so terrible".
Fast foreward to this week, and holy crap are they everywhere. Before posting anything about their suit, they're all "Don't commission this person". And I mean everywhere. They don't list whats wrong publicly and tell people they have to contact them for details- obviously because a lot of the complaints are ridiculous. But people probably won't, they'll probably take what this guy is saying and run with it.
Now, I've got a pretty good reputation because in the 5 years I've been doing this I've only had 2 people who were dissatisfied(That includes this person), but I'm constrained by "Professionalism" not to jump on their posts and say "Actually here are the problems you listed, I offered to fix them, you turned me down".
I really don't know how to approach this on a professional level. Suggestions?
FA+

2nd, a customer should not bad mouthing an artist if the said artist did the service that way requested
EXAMPLE : http://www.greenbookblog.org/wp-con.....st-service.jpg
3rd, if you are anxious of your reputation, start to improve it imediately.
I have no other advices, but i wish you the best luck
2nd, a customer should not bad mouthing an artist if the said artist did the service that was requested
I'm working on always improving my standard of work, but I'm open to suggestions for further improvement.
And work can improve no matter the time, some people improve faster some slower or never, it depends on each individual.
But I understand your frustration, i've got few customers like that in visual art commission.
TY for the suggestion
its a good practice, I think.
When I posted my defence on AB, it was the best thing I could have done because word in this fandom travels fast so if you don't meet it head on, you'll regret it later :(
A long, detailed and professional ToS are a good way to win such cases when crappy customers attack you.
Good results outweigh bad gossip.
Then there's always AB. I'd only do that if you think it gets out of hand.
Sounds like someone I wouldn't want to work with.
You've always been super nice to me and your stuff improves with every suit you make! Everyone that I've see with a suit from you has been happy. I agree with Bahn, it sounds like a scam, that or the guys has no clue what he is doing. I mean your heads are for fitting, so no need for straps...and what jack wagon is going to want rubber bands for their jaw with will dry rot and deteriorate far quicker than elastic???
If you say anything at all in a public response I would just say something along the lines of 'Please message me about any problems you may have with the suit and I will be happy to work with you are correcting the matter.' Correcting them publicly may feel gratifying, but it could also make you look like an ass hat.
Don't let the guy get to you Art. You are fantabulous! <3
Just saw this happen to a newbie maker and unfortunately for them it's probably going to destroy any chance of them being trusted again.
Thankfully you have years of experience on your side and more than enough examples to prove even if there was something the customer was not satisfied with (no matter how silly their reasoning was) it's not anything constant and can be taken as a one off. What baffles me though is why folks don't speak to the artist if they feel something isn't wright? I don't understand why this doesn't happen?
They don't know how good they got it clearly hahaha.
post a public entry about this, you don't have to name names unless you really need to (like if you need to make an AB about this). but you have to stand up for your reputation, it's incredibly important :)
i'm really sorry you're having this experience.
Sadly though, my concern is that if people seriously have to live by AB, chances are they aren't even going to look for at the reasons. If the name is up there, then people just look at it and immediately assume no good, which is a huge shame with those kind of communities. What should be a helpful tool ends up being a drama magnet that dare I say competes with FA at times...
I've seen your work; quality is not an issue. If someone gave you a stylized reference and didn't further clarify it, then any issues are wholly their own mistake. Given your already significant reputation, I doubt this is going to put much of a dent in it. You've done all you can. Let it go, and if you're still anxious about it, make sure that next time you do a commission, you and the commissioner are wholly on the same page before you ship it out. That way you can make last minute fixes while it's still in your possession.
Good luck, and don't sweat it.
~Shino Puppy
Ignore the idiot, your work stands for itself. And your reputation should be just fine. If scummy crazy people avoid you because they believe someone who is also scummy and crazy good riddance. I am sure you will have plenty of potential customers no matter what smear campaign these assholes decide to put on.
Maybe consider posting to AB, I know some clients are just clients from hell so it helps to do an AB scan to make sure a new client won't shit on your life for accepting a commission for them.
You're in a good position in that you have an impressive foundation to your reputation. Five years with minimal trouble and a substantive work base that's high quality. Sometimes you will see people that simply do not appreciate freelance work.
I'd use this to look at your practices, just review your TOS to be sure it covers everything you want (I know you don't know me well but I write these often and would be happy to look it over for you)
Look at your communication. with 5 years and 2 problem cases there probably isn't a lot there, you actively stream which allows buyers to review the process and have an idea of what's to come. Still if you think there's something you could add to add to buyer/builder communication then it couldn't hurt.
The rest is history really.
there's always that one bad customer. I know plenty of stories where someone buys a fursuit then complains about things like "it doesn't have a hard nose" when such a feature was never requested, is not offered by the builder, and was never made by the builder before in the first place.
Groups in general, but the fandom in particular, have a very small attention span. Of those that are conscientious buyers you have a positive history, clear practices, and solid quality.
When you put out more suits people will see them and want what you offer. Unless it's a suit literally falling apart at the seams, or you constantly mess up, you should be fine.
Heck there's one popular fursuit builder that for a very long time had abysmal quality and practices (you probably know who am thinking) and yet they remained popular and in business.
You'll be fine, AB post is the way to go :3
I haven dealt with customers like this and its hard because they flock all over before even discussing things with you...Sorry that you are going through this!
The offending party sent me an apology in note form, which makes it even harder to commit to an AB, I'm a fucking softie(Don't tell anyone).
Thanks for the empathy, unhappy customers who don't want to work with you are always so confusing and frustrating to deal with.
I wish you luck and I hope this issue gets resolved soon. Seems to me like the customer had a case of "I know all" and just decided that their odd "knowledge" on fursuit making was better then, well, a professionals.
Again, good luck, and I do hope you will get that A_B up soon.
And no worries because the ONLY thing you could have done to prevent this would have been to NOT sell to this person, but they weren't a butt-hole before they commissioned you, so really, there's nothing you could have done.
First off, I was supposed to be an adorable blue fox, but you waited until you had my money then told me "JAYKAY YOU'RE GOING TO BE A MONSTER!" All I wanted was a fluffy tail and cartoony eyes and a strategically placed hole in the no-no spot, and you couldn't even do that. YOU, ma'am, are the monster, here. My tail has NO fluff. No fluff! I specifically asked for fluff. You can see it very clearly on the 18th page of my favorites of someone else's character I didn't tell you about.
I came to you because all of your work would lead me to believe that you create cute foxes, but what I got just gives me nightmares. Also, it wasn't even properly built! You made my stitches out of some crummy thread when I SPECIFICALLY asked you to use dental floss so that I'd be minty fresh all the time. And yeah, I think rubber bands would have been much better than this crummy elastic. You also wasted all kinds of time using hot glue when you should have just stapled the elastic down. I swear, you're terrible at this.
Furthermore, your punctuality was a real problem. I told you that I needed it done before Anthrocon and you waited until a WEEK BEFORE AC before finishing it. The stress of not knowing what was going on with my suit was almost too much for me. I got put on suicide watch at school because I was crying too much in class. And my running eyeliner ruined my favorite shirt! I'm going to send you a bill for that. Really, you should consider streaming so that people know what's going on.
Well that's all I'm going to talk about, but THERES A LOT MORE WHERE THAT CAME FROM! Please PM me and I'll give you the worst stuff.
I hope you get no business ever again. Clearly, my experience matters and people need to know the truth about how terrible you are.
Sincerely,
Adorable_Blue_Fox (JK IM A FUCKING MONSTER)
As a prospective customer, I knew roughly what style I wanted, hadn't even settled on a creature, but I knew I wanted to adapt the subject to the artist so that I'd get the best possible outcome. Your work is an outlier in the fandom, with only a handful of people doing monsters at all. I looked at your work, I looked at your comments, and I looked at how you handled yourself when talking with people. I messaged a few of your clients, all who had nothing but good things to say, and locked down a coveted space in your schedule.
If you do respond, keep it short. Just because someone is wrong on the internet doesn't mean that you need to set them straight, because chances are, that isn't going to happen. So say something along the lines of you're sorry that he's unhappy with what he's received, and that you've offered to address his concerns, but regret that he hasn't given you that opportunity. And really, you don't need to at all. He'll show everyone how silly he is all on his own.
-Nexu (AKA Adorable_Fluffy_Tailed_Fox)