"Transgender" and "cisgender" are ridiculous, outdated terms
11 years ago
There's a gigantic, wonderful grab-bag of different gender identities out there - why on Earth do we keep on insisting that people who have a more "traditional" gender identity should be labeled separately from those with a "nontraditional" one, and vice-versa?
By trying to divide these identities into two overly-broad categories, we do nothing but promote discrimination and hatred and all sorts of negative bullshit... this is holding us back as a society from growing towards mutual respect and understanding.
Seriously, though... by continuing to use those two terms, we keep bringing the focus back to the very thing we try to move past: the equipment we have in our pants.
If someone identifies as a specific gender, it shouldn't matter whether or not they were assigned that gender at birth, or had bottom surgery, or whatever - what matters is one thing, and that's the fact that they identify as that gender.
By trying to divide these identities into two overly-broad categories, we do nothing but promote discrimination and hatred and all sorts of negative bullshit... this is holding us back as a society from growing towards mutual respect and understanding.
Seriously, though... by continuing to use those two terms, we keep bringing the focus back to the very thing we try to move past: the equipment we have in our pants.
If someone identifies as a specific gender, it shouldn't matter whether or not they were assigned that gender at birth, or had bottom surgery, or whatever - what matters is one thing, and that's the fact that they identify as that gender.
FA+

I guess I just don't believe in the concept of gender and see gender as nothing more then a character's sex and my simplistic view seems to piss people off because they want to be gender identified when it in truth does nothing but support their desire not to be trait identified simply because they have a socket or plug.
The thing is, it's not the same as biological sex in the slightest, but the use of "transgender" and "cisgender" keep tying it back to biological sex, which is ridiculous.
Transgender and cisgender have their use psychology study but outside of that to me just seem as a way to segregate people like other more infamous labels of various segregation acts in the past. I have met a fairly decent amount of people who gender identify opposite their sex. And while I may have assumed their gender wrong because of our stupid gender pronouns having no neutral and are sex/gender based once they've informed me what they identify as I have no issue with it. It's no more insulting really then a guy with long hair being hailed as ma'am from behind, hell it is more embarrassing to the person addressing them because our language forces them to make a gender choice since we cannot say "Hello (fill in the blank)" or "(fill in the blank) you dropped something".
Perhaps that is one of the big parts to the problem. That our language has their ideological requirement that sex and gender must be linked when addressing each other.
I'm not arguing against your point, just stating my opinion on why it's so difficult for people to handle. Frankly, I'm in total agreement. I have friends who were born a gender, and even dress/act in ways that many would associate with that gender, but prefer the use of adjectives associated with another. One of the major stumbling blocks of all this is that unless you knew a person already, your mind will already switcdh to a set list of words for using regarding them. Just like many great conflicts of the modern age, both sides have to be understanding.
I'm cis-gendered. Why? Because I have a linear tetrahedral molecular geometry motherfucker
Fair enough.
Of course nowadays I tend to use the term "genderqueer" for myself, or even more commonly "queer". For me there's just no better way to describe it.