Results are in! Assigned everyone who commented a number (basically where you fell in the sequence of comments), punched them through a random number generator, aaand here are the results!

http://oi58.tinypic.com/1t6m4o.jpg

Winners are 10, 5, and 6, so congrats to

 Faye~ - Winner of a 9x12 full color bust portrait!
 BeastSoul - Winner of a badge of any style (excludes Couples Badge)!
 LindseySnowSprinkles - Winner of an acrylic or laminate keychain!

I'll be messaging you three shortly to get ref sheets and such. :3 Thanks to all who entered!