Surface Pro, opinions?
9 years ago
~ ๐พ ~
EDIT: Nevermind guys... I bought one...
With potential travel interfering with July and the possibility of taking on more than 2 cons next year I was hoping to look into a more portable way to work on digital art than my laptop. I've spoken to a couple of people but would like further opinions as buying a computer tablet... Thing is an expensive prospect for me. Just in general, how does working on a surface pro or anything of the like compare to working on a computer? Is it worth the investment or should I just stick with my Mac for travel?
But I don't like SAI on my SP3 because for some reason the pen pressure doesn't work in SAI and there doesn't seem to be a fix for it. So I would keep that in mind.
All of my friends (including several artists) who have picked up a SP3 or 4 have sworn by their purchase. One of them even runs games on it, which is downright impressive. They're definitely a high end tablet.
If you have access to a nearby Microsoft Store you can demo an SP4 there in person. Ask them nicely and you might even be able to install your art software to give it a whirl. The digitizer is comparable to that found in low and mid-range Wacom tablets, but is not as good as the kind that can be found in the Cintiq models. For a similar price as a new Cintiq, though, you're getting an entire laptop out of the deal.
Anyways. The portable experience varies depending on the art program. I have no access to Photoshop to test. On my i5 yoga, Paint Shop Pro chugs to the point where any type of painting on it would be extremely tedious and annoying, I presume it to be very CPU intensive. Black ink (which runs on GPU) on the other hand, runs smoothly, but wasn't a full solution to me. My current primary art program, Clip Studio runs perfectly fine, at canvas sizes up to A4 300dpi with many layers. I regularly work in Clip Studio while streaming with OBS and talking on discord with no issues.
As for the physical experience, I have a few. If the surface model you're looking at has a glass screen, I HIGHLY recommend a matte screen protector. My yoga has a matte screen to begin with and it makes the device much more pleasant to use. I have always hated the immense drag a glass screen puts on your palm, and this screen doesn't have that. I suppose if you use a smudge guard you can avoid that, but I would think it would then be too slick, and you may lose tactile response. What you prefer is up to you, but it is definitely something to keep in mind while you shop.
The last thing to think about is availability of pens and nibs. The newer surfaces use N-Trig digitizers rather than wacom. This may actually work in your favor over the wacom 'penabled' technology that is in non-wacom branded devices. The reason being, while I can find, quite a few replacement styluses that are "compatible" with my device, they are always significantly less sensitive, and often cut out after extended use. This has lead me to continue to use the nubby stylus which came with my device, which is very high quality in terms of performance, but is in no way intended for artwork.
While the technologies differ, my recommendation is the same. If your demo location has them available, try some other styluses out and see how they compare. If nothing else, choose a model where if you were limited to the pen that came in the box, you would still be happy.
Lastly, if you have the budget for a cintiq companion (Laptop with built in cintiq screen, made by wacom), I totally recommend that route over a surface. They're made for art, and therefore address basically every issue I mentioned working on laptops. Plus being a cintiq, you get double pressure sensitivity, tilt, angle, and many more pen choices directly from wacom. Jazza did a great review of it on YouTube.
Hope my rambling thoughts help!
Edit: lol just saw your edit. Whelp, I hope you enjoy the read anyways.