(-) means I don't like it
(+) means I like it
(o) means indifferent/undecided

I'm using Vera's list since it seemed to cover the most

Anal (o)
Breast (++)
Breast Expansion (o)
Bondage (+)
Clothing (o)
Leather (++)
Stockings (++++)
Socks (++)
TRAINERS/SNEAKERS (o)
Muscle Male (o)
Muscle Female (o)
Herm (-)
Fur (++++) lawl DUH
Babyfur (

---

)
Transformation (+) I had a morph character
Macro (+)
Micro (o)
Multi-boobs (-)
Impregnation (o)
Pregnancy (o)
Lactation (+)
Vore (-)
Monsters (+) Can be nice sometimes
Paws/feet (o)
Incest ( +) Only fake incest is good
Yuri (F/F) (+)
Yaoi (M/M) (-)
Sissy Boy (-)
Tomboyish girls (+) They are cool
Mind Control (+)
Rape (++)
Uniform (++)
Orgy (o)
Biting (++) fun!
Encasement (-)
Birthdaycake (+) not sure what this is, but sounds nice
Solo Masturbation (+)
Watersports (

---

)
Scat (

---

)
Inflation (

---

)
Fat/Pudge (+) A little looks cute

There ya have it