Hey guys, I wanted to develop a permanently incontinent character that wears diapers 24/7, coming close to finalizing one.

I thought it over, and I have 2 ideas for a character, but I need help finalizing who I want. I won't give the species, but heres the story of each:

Character 1:

Code name: Pessimist

A much different character than all the other ones I have. He has had a bad background growing up leaving him in a poor circumstance in life. Some of these misfortunes have been caused by his environment growing up, the others his bad decisions.
In order to avoid jail time, the government allowed him a second chance which he accepted: to grow up again. Through the use of catheters and butt plugs he completely lost control of his bathroom skills, becoming incontinent. Until he reforms, he has no choice but to use diapers, which he isn't a fan of but accepts due to the threat of jail. He will warm up to the very few people he trusts and act like a normal individual, being happy and such. This may include Nathan.

Character 2:

Code name: Hyper

An extremely overactive individual who bounces off the walls with excitement. Because of this, he has overactive bladder and frequent accidents. So much so his bladder control never formed and he is stuck in diapers. He doesn't mind them but prefers if they are a secret. Very happy and energetic, this character fits right in with all my other ones. Will become a quick friend of my other characters.

_________________

So, I pose you this question: Character 1, Character 2, or both?