More feedback wanted! [s](w/ art raffle incentive!)[/s]
7 years ago
General
Hi guys! I'm here begging for advice again :3. Every time I've done a journal like this in the past I've left with something to work on. Last time my focus was on improving lighting, which while I know it's something I can vastly improve on still, I feel like the research that that prompted has hugely helped my understanding and made me adjust my process in a positive way.
This time, I'm going to be asking a little more from you - I've got a trio of pics that I'd love to have critiqued but ALSO I'd love to have some feedback from people who have commissioned me relating to the service I provide. I want to know how I can make the entire commission process better for you, everything from when you decided you wanted a commission (like, what made you pick me? could I be presenting myself better?) up to when you receive your finished commission. Obviously I have the consider my own needs when thinking about this process, I still absolutely want to know if there's anything I can be doing to improve your experience.
So since I'm asking more from you guys, it would be terribly rude of me not to offer something in return, right? So anyone who provides some well insightful piece of advice or critique will be entered into a raffle to win a SFW or NSFW pinup of a character of your choice! I'll give you a number so I can keep track and use a RNG to decide the winner. I don't want to set a minimum amount of text or anything like that to qualify, but I do want to be able to tell that you've thought it through (so just "draw more girls" doesn't qualify ;P). And as much as I loooooooove praise (pls praise me more pls) it's not the most helpful thing for working out how to improve so try to focus on my weaknesses.
I'll leave the journal up for a couple of days before I draw the winner so you can take your time. Enter any thoughts or comments as a response to this journal so it's easy for me to keep track :)
Raffle is finished!
Here are the three pics I'd like to offer up as an example of my bast current work (all NSFW sorry):
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28532488/
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28342818/
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28264427/
Remember your critique doesn't have to reference any specific detail from these pics, more general advice is also fine. And of course, any advice about the service I provide.
Thank you thank you
This time, I'm going to be asking a little more from you - I've got a trio of pics that I'd love to have critiqued but ALSO I'd love to have some feedback from people who have commissioned me relating to the service I provide. I want to know how I can make the entire commission process better for you, everything from when you decided you wanted a commission (like, what made you pick me? could I be presenting myself better?) up to when you receive your finished commission. Obviously I have the consider my own needs when thinking about this process, I still absolutely want to know if there's anything I can be doing to improve your experience.
I'll leave the journal up for a couple of days before I draw the winner so you can take your time. Enter any thoughts or comments as a response to this journal so it's easy for me to keep track :)
Raffle is finished!
Here are the three pics I'd like to offer up as an example of my bast current work (all NSFW sorry):
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28532488/
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28342818/
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28264427/
Remember your critique doesn't have to reference any specific detail from these pics, more general advice is also fine. And of course, any advice about the service I provide.
Thank you thank you
FA+

Now I went and looked at a lot of your work to see if this was a pattern, and it doesnlt seem to be, lots of your other work shows fur, so it's those 3 pics in particular. but even with the rest of what I saw, your work has a smoothness to it. Now that being said, that could be your style. If it is, all my kvetching is kinda moot lol.
I do like how you can mix things up though and seem to be comfortable with changing styles a bit.
Lotta good use of color too.
Someone I'd love to grab a piece off of someday. 8/10 easy
Raffle number: 1!
Enough about me, I'll say what I can about what I've come up with when seeing the three images, plus I also decided to browse your gallery.
Backgrounds! I know this may or may not be the right place to even mention. I don't know if these are commissions, and too much detail might be too much work/expensive, but detailed backgrounds are always amazing to see! A bed is one thing, but even an outdoor romping can be super fun too! It sets an even more interesting (and sexy) atmosphere. I can't speak for everyone on that matter though.
It may sound tough, but I saw this awesome artist do one really amazing thing with their backgrounds that blew me away because there's no way I could've noticed this. Note, I tried for the past half an hour to find their tutorial on twitter and FA but I couldn't for the life of me. But it was a robotic character on a beach with robot-like octopus tentacles on their back, and what they did with the background was add simple shapes and colors that still resembles certain objects such as trees, leaves and rocks, but then they would blur the whole background like a camera on focus to the character. It would blur those simple shapes, and your brain would process that there's indeed trees and rocks behind her!
It's just one neat tutorial that came to mind, but I'm sure there's countless simple tutorials for backgrounds that aren't so tough to try and you wouldn't have to worry about spending hours on end towards.
Just one other thing, I've noticed on the character standing picture, and quite a few others in your gallery, that the waist to shoulders ratio feels long, making their legs seem shorter. The other images where we get different perspectives looks super good, but the standing character images feels different. Their belly and chest seems much longer, and their legs seem pretty short. It isn't as noticeable in the panther image you've provided, but others in the past I've noticed it.
You don't have to change any of that if you don't want to, but I figured I'd bring it up that it's what I see.
I don't have much else to go on currently! I've spent a ton of time as it is just researching and browsing your gallery, I still need to eat breakfast Hahaha!
On positive notes, I think you've nailed it perfectly with facial features, and hands! WE DREAD HANDS AND ARE SUPER JEALOUS OF YOUR SKILLS!
Hope I wasn't harsh, I'm trying my best to seem as passive as possible while still trying to help! Thanks for reading and keep up the amazing work!
I do know what you mean about the ratios too. That's just me trying to get a more animal-y look out of the characters but I think it needs a bit more thought put into it.
Thanks so much for the input! Your raffle number is 2, good luck!
I'm relieved there's no bad feelings hahahhaha!
Thanks mate for the raffle chance!
Raffle number: 3
My only critique is really just a peeve of mine but if you're going to have a guy wear pants with his junk hanging out of it, the pants has to look like the junk actually fits in there. I can't see him getting back in those pants lol
Another thing you can work on is anatomy from forced perspective angles.
http://www.furaffinity.net/view/28499455/ like this one. It is a really nice piece but you shouldn't be able to see his hips like that if you got him pulled up to be drilled. Like, if you look at it and try to picture your own legs being lifted like that it'd look like there is a weird gap between ass/cock and hips when it's all the same general area x3
Other than that, you've been drastically improving to a point where I have almost nothing left to critique. You got better with hands, faces, shading, expressions, everything. You are an amazing boy and once you tackle these things that I know you're just not used to, you'll be a pro at that too
Raffle number: 4
1) Penis detail. Given the amount of guys you draw, not surprised! But can see the small veins and different shades of red used to give it is look.
2) Pre-cum detail. Another almost given!
3) Also starting to notice some detail going into the sheets and clothing...
And did notice something on "Presenting" that could be improved. Just a small detail, but his elbow doesn't look to be pressing into the bed very hard. Almost floating against the surface. Could use a small detail such as bunched up sheets or an indention in the bedding to give more of an impression of weight.
Either way hope to see more!
Raffle number 5 :3
I'd suggest also playing around with different colors of light and how the colors interact to make your drawings more fun to look at and more unique at that.
As of late, you seem to be mostly drawing felines and canines. Try out other species, look for details that are unique to them and how you could differentiate the species further (although you already do a great job at that and have done already with drawing other species). Always develop as an artist and don't stop exploring :)
Raffle number: 6
Just keep trying.
Backgrounds for sure. But it's not like you can't do them. Your icon and that lion Sora picture. Both amazing backgrounds. I guess it's just trying to do more of them.
Some very clearly look like it was an after thought or so far from the main focus that they weren't important and come across as a bit off or lacking.
Maybe start with a scene before the subject and see how that goes. Or have it really fit the place.
More stuff on the beach...it's easier to think of what and who when you know the location.
Sure it won't help for every situation. But it's a start right into getting more practice in it.
Your dynamic posing stuff an look amazing at times. The last image I commented on kinda proves that. It didn't feel unnatural. And it looked good.
How about mixing it up and trying some different styles too? You've done a little cell shading things. How about some more or something not done before =)
Raffle number: 7
I know it's been said several times already, but backgrounds. Incorporating some good background work would definitely take your work to the next level. And it looks like you're starting to work into that, with the first and third pics you've linked. Building on that, also keep in mind how a character interacts with the backgrounds, as well. On the third pic, it looks great, anatomy and perspective are excellent, and the shading on the bed is good, but the background seems kinda stagnant. It honestly looks a little like he's just floating right above the bed lol. You're definitely getting there, though! Backgrounds can be super tough, but just remember how a character will interact with and affect a scene.
Past that, just keep working and learning, dude. Love seeing you put new stuff out, and seeing how much better you've gotten ^__^
raffle number: 8
Raffle number: 9!