A very long complaint about Inktober.
7 years ago
Commissions are OPEN
If you are interested in commissioning me, come drop me a line! Let's see what we can make together! https://forms.gle/rWtK2fLXYUkNzPvo8 I honestly fucking hate the traditional vs digital art divide and the elitists who make each one exclusionary against the other. Neither is easier than the other, and comparing them, while not as close to the apples and oranges arguments as I’d like for this topic, may as well be close enough. There are things you can to with traditional art that you can’t do with digital art, and vice versa. There are tons of people who are intensely skilled in one who have never once touched the other, and even people intensely skilled in one who are absolute garbage fires at the other, just because they are intensely different worlds. However, there are also people, myself included, who breach both worlds and do just fine with both. Despite being adept with both, I can’t say which one is easier, I can just say which one I have a preference for, and that’s digital. It doesn’t waste paper or use up my pens, and it doesn’t leave a mess behind for me to clean up afterward.
Despite their differences, they go hand in hand like strawberries and cream. Do you know how I learned to be a digital artist? I applied what I learned from traditional art. How did I learn to be a traditional painter? I applied what I learned from digital art. I practiced my digital art by sketching traditionally and finishing it digitally. I practiced my traditional art by drawing and painting all on one layer digitally. Doing these things made me a more rounded artist, and for that I’m thankful.
Because I can recognise this, though, it makes me bitterly angry when I see people shitting on digital artists for doing Inktober digitally. I’m not doing Inktober digitally because it’s easier, it’s because I know that there’s no fucking difference between doing traditionally or digitally, you still end up with art in the end, which brings me to my final point, which is the simple choice of wording in “traditional” and “digital”.
To say that something is “traditional” is to imply that it’s the “normal” way of doing it. To say that there’s the “traditional” way juxtaposed to anything else implies that the other option is “not normal”. As I’ve stated, there are artists who do things one way having never once touched the other. Take a look at one artist on YouTube, Borodante. He’s a digital painter by profession, and recently reached 100,000 subscribers, and to celebrate, he did his first painting with real paint. He spent the entire video lamenting how he had no idea what he was doing, but consider that using “traditional” methods is not “traditional” for him. His “traditional”, his “normal” way is digital painting. I’m not saying this to try to cry that “artistic methods are a social construct” or anything like that, what I’m saying is that everyone has their method, and if it’s not yours, who are you to judge?
So if you’re going to sit back and deny digital artists the satisfaction of doing Inktober digitally, here’s an idea that’s truly groundbreaking in its simplicity: don’t.
Despite their differences, they go hand in hand like strawberries and cream. Do you know how I learned to be a digital artist? I applied what I learned from traditional art. How did I learn to be a traditional painter? I applied what I learned from digital art. I practiced my digital art by sketching traditionally and finishing it digitally. I practiced my traditional art by drawing and painting all on one layer digitally. Doing these things made me a more rounded artist, and for that I’m thankful.
Because I can recognise this, though, it makes me bitterly angry when I see people shitting on digital artists for doing Inktober digitally. I’m not doing Inktober digitally because it’s easier, it’s because I know that there’s no fucking difference between doing traditionally or digitally, you still end up with art in the end, which brings me to my final point, which is the simple choice of wording in “traditional” and “digital”.
To say that something is “traditional” is to imply that it’s the “normal” way of doing it. To say that there’s the “traditional” way juxtaposed to anything else implies that the other option is “not normal”. As I’ve stated, there are artists who do things one way having never once touched the other. Take a look at one artist on YouTube, Borodante. He’s a digital painter by profession, and recently reached 100,000 subscribers, and to celebrate, he did his first painting with real paint. He spent the entire video lamenting how he had no idea what he was doing, but consider that using “traditional” methods is not “traditional” for him. His “traditional”, his “normal” way is digital painting. I’m not saying this to try to cry that “artistic methods are a social construct” or anything like that, what I’m saying is that everyone has their method, and if it’s not yours, who are you to judge?
So if you’re going to sit back and deny digital artists the satisfaction of doing Inktober digitally, here’s an idea that’s truly groundbreaking in its simplicity: don’t.

Thank you!~
silvermane
~silvermane
Isn't the point of the challenge to actually do 30 days or art. Regardless of traditional or digital (I've done both before) isn't it more important to just do it?
Kraest
~kraest
OP
It started as a traditional challenge for the creator, but you are correct, the creator himself has put into the "rules" that, yes, digital is fine, even going so far as to start in crayon, taking a shitty picture, and then doing the inks digitally, so long as you're inking in the end.
AsylumPatient
~asylumpatient
Really? Last year he was trying to discourage people from doing Digital :/

https://inktober.com/faq/ He encourages people to use their medium of choice here, even if it's writing and not drawing at all.
silvermane
~silvermane
heck I start alot of my work as traditional sketches then clean them up and color them digitally because its easier to fix any mistakes along the line. There's sadly no undo button for doing inks in particular traditionally.
Kraest
~kraest
OP
Honestly, for the elitists who think digital is so much easier, all you have to do to almost perfectly mimic traditional inkling is just...not erase. >.>'
Robert Chretien Ruskin
~rcruskin
*stands up and applauds*
Frostypuppy
~frostypuppy
Many methods for every art piece~ I didnt even realize there were people upset with digital artists for that
Kraest
~kraest
OP
Dude, it's nuts. I posted this to Facebook as well, and got a response from someone who claimed that Inktober is all about making physical art specifically to sell.
Frostypuppy
~frostypuppy
wonderful e_e
Hornedandscorned
~farellfoxx
Elitism and gatekeeping exists for everything, sadly.
FA+