I will admit, I love both. I just feel that there should be a price difference between the two that reflects the time spent. :D

plus, I do really love how clean the cell shading is. Typically that is what I'll be drawn to because it looks simpler and faster to complete.

thank for your opinion. I'm not planning on giving the two different shading different prices but people who commission me are gonna be able to choose which one they want.

sounds good, though I would consider adding even an upcharge for complexity. Can't make it too easy for people to throw you absurdly complex characters and expect to get away with it... :D

I think the softer shading looks better here

to GIVE pain
or to receive it?

I think I prefer the cel shading honestly. As much as I like the soft shading, I just don't see it fitting with your colorful art style. :)

First

2

They are both nice. I prefer the soft shading.

Both are awesome but I prefer the first one!

Either or. They both look decent. Try and switch it up for future works

The 2nd. I feel like it's easier to look at, you know?

2

i personally like the first one, but i think how you feel is most important! but i guess its not about what i think

1

Both look good but I prefer 1 ^^