Some thoughts in the wake of Christchurch.
6 years ago
Stay tuned for a totally unimportant announcement!
Alright, probably gonna lose some watchers over this one.
I'm sure that most of you are probably still reeling from the massacre down in New Zealand. After thinking it over, I have some things I'd like to say about all this.
This latest shooting is the culmination of years of Islamophobic hate speech, anti-Muslim memes, and general bigotry. You want to know why I have zero tolerance for hate speech? Because it never just stops at speech. It infects the minds of those who listen, sways them into embracing ignorance. They parrot it back at each other, riling each other up into a bigger and bigger frenzy. Until finally one of them decides to act on their hate and shed blood.
Us folks on the left have warned for years that alt-right talking points and memes aren't "just an edgy joke." Over those years we've been ignored, told we're overreacting, just a bunch of hysterical "regressives" trying to take away "free speech." Well, my friends, look what has been wrought.
With all that in mind, I have a message to my fellow furs:
Let it be known that we have no place within our fandom for bigots.
If you believe that the victims of the massacre brought it upon themselves, or you try to blame "immigration," get out.
If you are scrambling to defend your favorite alt-right memes, YouTubers, and pundits from scrutiny, get out.
If you refuse to acknowledge the shooter's politics, or his idols' roles in motivating him, get out.
If your first impulse in the wake of this is to say "But the Left..," get out.
If you believe that Islam, Judaism, or any other established religion is fundamentally incompatible with so-called "Western" values and norms, get out.
If you believe a person's skin color or nation of origin is a reliable indicator of their character, get out.
Folks who match the above don't have a place in our community. All they know how to do is tear down others. They take pleasure in seeing harm come to people who are different than them. We need to say, as one voice, to these people: "You are not welcome here!"
No more negative peace. No more excuses. No more false equivalencies.
Islamophobes and white supremacists need to get the fuck out of my fandom, and preferably out of my country.
I'm sure that most of you are probably still reeling from the massacre down in New Zealand. After thinking it over, I have some things I'd like to say about all this.
This latest shooting is the culmination of years of Islamophobic hate speech, anti-Muslim memes, and general bigotry. You want to know why I have zero tolerance for hate speech? Because it never just stops at speech. It infects the minds of those who listen, sways them into embracing ignorance. They parrot it back at each other, riling each other up into a bigger and bigger frenzy. Until finally one of them decides to act on their hate and shed blood.
Us folks on the left have warned for years that alt-right talking points and memes aren't "just an edgy joke." Over those years we've been ignored, told we're overreacting, just a bunch of hysterical "regressives" trying to take away "free speech." Well, my friends, look what has been wrought.
With all that in mind, I have a message to my fellow furs:
Let it be known that we have no place within our fandom for bigots.
If you believe that the victims of the massacre brought it upon themselves, or you try to blame "immigration," get out.
If you are scrambling to defend your favorite alt-right memes, YouTubers, and pundits from scrutiny, get out.
If you refuse to acknowledge the shooter's politics, or his idols' roles in motivating him, get out.
If your first impulse in the wake of this is to say "But the Left..," get out.
If you believe that Islam, Judaism, or any other established religion is fundamentally incompatible with so-called "Western" values and norms, get out.
If you believe a person's skin color or nation of origin is a reliable indicator of their character, get out.
Folks who match the above don't have a place in our community. All they know how to do is tear down others. They take pleasure in seeing harm come to people who are different than them. We need to say, as one voice, to these people: "You are not welcome here!"
No more negative peace. No more excuses. No more false equivalencies.
Islamophobes and white supremacists need to get the fuck out of my fandom, and preferably out of my country.
FA+

#DemocraticPartyForever
#FeelTheBernIn2020
"This brutal terrorist attack in New Zealand which left 49 people dead did not take place in a vacuum - it is part of a global onslaught of Islamophobia that has today manifested in a way that is horrible but not surprising. Nothing about decades-long racialisation, demonisation and othering should come as a surprise to anyone. It is impossible to distinguish the manifesto of the terrorist from comments made by politicians the world over. The rhetoric that they use to get votes, to stir up their base, to radicalise and indoctrinate non-Muslims has tangible consequences for Muslims and people racialised as Muslim everywhere. Words matter - whether it’s in the form of demonising refugees and migrants, the tabloids that peddle Islamophobic drivel, or comments made around a dinner table. It’s this same rhetoric that harms black and brown bodies in immeasurable ways.
This was a targeted terrorist attack against a marginalised community and it’s well passed time that we call out anti-Muslim, racist comments made by our families, friends and politicians. We are complicit in this if we do not actively take steps to dismantle the white supremacist, Islamophobic structures that facilitated this attack. White nationalism is terrorism and there should be no ambiguity about that.
I hope that one day our fellow Muslim students can feel safe in your own skin, in your own clothes, in your own places of worship."
I'm really fed-up with this idea that "free speech" should actually mean giving an unrestricted platform to people with hateful views. And there's nothing these various mass shooters do that bigoted politicians haven't been doing for years. In North America, Europe, Oceania, and beyond, there's a longstanding history of Muslims in particular being targeted as not only different, but hostile and incompatible with the societies into which they immigrate.
When we live in societies where an extreme, outspoken subset is constantly shrieking about how Muslims are terrorists, hostile to our society, and a threat to our values. They go on and on about how this is an oppressive religion that fosters violence and holds women in subjugation. And then when some nut takes them at their word and goes on a killing spree, the same people who have been adding fuel to the fire simply say "whoa whoa whoa, we never said to KILL them!" and then go straight back to propagating the same vile, incendiary narratives that, frankly, should be treated as a criminal action in the same way as shouting fire in a crowded theatre.
I'm glad that statement was posted at your uni. American universities have gotten too chickenshit, especially the ones with GOP-appointed boards of regents.
There's a really strong undercurrent of anti-Muslim sentiment in the UK and it's not uncommon to hear otherwise-liberal people express bigoted and ignorant sentiments about Islam.
I just look at it this way: Conservatives constantly feel attacked by mass media that depicts white Christian conservatives as terrible people. They see characters that represent them being torn down while women, the LGBT community and minorities get to rise up. So they retreat to Fox News, which pats them on the head and tells them that they're good people and leftists are psychotic idiots; they become more and more isolated from society, and get more insular and weird; their thoughts become more tinged with hatred as they feel society has turned on them.
Reach out with love, hun. Focus on ways you connect with people, instead of shunning them for their differences. Maybe they wouldn't be so hateful if their only friends weren't just other hate-filled people.
You yourself might not be a hateful person, but you seem to have no qualms enabling hate speech by tone policing and scolding anyone who tries to stop it. Also, your "shunning them will only make them more hateful" thing isn't true. Ask any former Nazi some of the reasons they chose to leave, and losing their friends and family is often near the top.
The far-right deserves no platform, no mercy, and very little sympathy. Anyone who tries to lecture us on civility and being a pacifist in the face of people who want us dead is immediately suspect in my eyes. Perhaps you don't want to see the US, UK, EU, etc descend into fascism. If that's the case, kindly step aside and let the people who see the threat for what it is take care of it.
I'm pretty left-leaning myself, but it's just exhausting seeing everyone flinging hatred at each other: they hate minorities, so you hate them, and nothing gets accomplished aside from the battle lines getting drawn more clearly.
Wouldn't it be better to extol the virtues of Muslims and try to show that they're good people instead of just dumping another steaming barrel of hatred on the internet?
Sometimes, there are people in this world who cannot be reasoned with. Sometimes, fighting is the only option. I'm no more eager to do it than anyone else, but if pressed I sure as heck will rise to it.
I think your best bet now is to stop with the "both sides" BS. That's a false equivalence. One "side" has a sizable body count here. White supremacists and Islamophobes have murdered hundreds since the 2016 elections, and their numbers have ballooned in that same amount of time.
Hell, I have a really detailed timeline of white supremacists committing mass shootings over on Sofurry if you'd like a link.