Novel Question to my Trans Followers
6 years ago
General
For those who are unaware I am trying to right my first published novel, Hero Slayers. In it a transgender handmaid of the prince is one of the 5 main characters. While the Prince cares deeply for HER many others don't like him. Transphobia is a big issue for this girl and trying to prove she's more than just what she seems (the theme of the book)
HOWEVER
One of the reasons I'm doing this is to hurt the character, make her life hell like most writers do. I originally had there be no prejudice on non-cis-genders (there would be many trans, ace, fluid characters). This would eventually come down to a almost-torturous scene. I myself am Gender Fluid and remember the horrible struggle coming to terms with that. IT sucked yo!
So my question is this. Would you, as a transgender, feel better if it was accepted that there are trans people or are you ok with transphobia being a character struggle.
I will be putting these characters through hell regardless of their gender presumptions.
As a TRANSGENDER how do you feel about this? What are your thoughts?
HOWEVER
One of the reasons I'm doing this is to hurt the character, make her life hell like most writers do. I originally had there be no prejudice on non-cis-genders (there would be many trans, ace, fluid characters). This would eventually come down to a almost-torturous scene. I myself am Gender Fluid and remember the horrible struggle coming to terms with that. IT sucked yo!
So my question is this. Would you, as a transgender, feel better if it was accepted that there are trans people or are you ok with transphobia being a character struggle.
I will be putting these characters through hell regardless of their gender presumptions.
As a TRANSGENDER how do you feel about this? What are your thoughts?
FA+

While not to the same scale as an author to a novel, I have been creating stories and worlds for people to explore by running Dungeons and Dragons games over the last decade. Context is everything. My players understand (at least I hope they do) know that when a touchy subject is part of the story, I have not thrown it in as an afterthought, and if I can't handle the situation with tact, I won't use it in the story playing out before them.
Socio-political struggles such as Transphobia, Abuse, Racial or Gender discrimination, Religious zealotry... All of these need to be handled tactfully if you are using them in your novel. Don't treat them like a Dollar Tree bargain sale.
One of the more intriguing (to both of us) D&D stories I have told was a great conflict where the two main regions involved were:
A city-state founded on faith that zealously decries and eradicates those unwilling to follow the true faith they have, and have committed atrocities against any who dare speak out against them.
A magically-prosperous (though behind in tech) aristocracy where slavery is a common practice, magical aptitude takes precedence after race with humans, elves and dwarves being the only ones with any real rights, and slaves are kept in line with magical brands that act as shock collars and minor mind control.
Both are ideologies or cultures that I would damn in the real world, but then again, my players were (and still are) working to ensure both sides lose the conflict.
Edit: I forgot to add that I didn't do either of these on a whim. I wanted to see if my players would be able to see past the "which side should we choose" ideal and find a new path that won't clash with their own ideologies.
I feel that if a character is to become "real", real situations must happen; not all of the real things need to happen, mind you - but daily struggles and triumphs must happen. Consider looking into psychological, social, and emotional aspects through other reading; personal experience is ALSO very helpful in the creative process. As far as a story with a trans character goes? Go for it. Having a character to relate to can not only make the character come alive for the reader, but can also help the reader feel as though they are there.