try etsy, i see stuff like that floating around (thx spam email)

https://twintailcreations.com/
https://www.exotic-erotics.com/store/

Wandering Bard Toys on Etsy is great!

All of these and more on Etsy :3

NawtyToyBox
MadeToWere
FlirtyDawg
YiffMonkey
DesiresToys
IvyToys
Fantasticocks

https://weredog.co.uk/

They have some interesting choices.

Me lol https://qimera-forge.com/

https://kuduvoodoo.net

personal fav!

https://www.primalhardwere.com/category/all

I'll second this suggestion. I had a great experience with Primal Hardwere.

Personal faves!
https://neotori.com/
https://goblindildoemporium.com/
I've had very pleasant conversations with both shops and ended up with the toys of my dreams

https://xenocat-artifacts.com/ for the more exotic side~

I've purchased and used Twin Tail Creations and they do good work!

I usually buy from DreadTheEmpire on etsy/twitter. I also have stuff from PPsculpt coming in this week but they do some pretty pours and are a smaller creator so it isn't too stressful when they do drops, but I imagine them being very popular when they take off. They do some really ambitious stuff.

I have not bought from them (yet!) but Dread The Empire is high on my list for really cool high quality looking fantasy peepee
https://twitter.com/DreadTheEmpire
https://www.etsy.com/shop/dreadtheempire/

their pours are also so insanely fucking gorgeous, BD could never

All the ones I know of~

A Krow's Nest ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/AKrowsNest
The Crafty Hedonist ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/TheCraftyHedonist
DamnAverage https://www.etsy.com/shop/DamnAverage, https://damnaverage.com/
Dread The Empire ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/DreadTheEmpire
Exotic Erotics ~ https://www.exotic-erotics.com/
Fck Buddies ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/FckBuddies
Foxy Rabbit Toys ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/FoxyRabbitToys
Hodgepodge Compendium ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/HodgepodgeCompendium
KuduVoodoo ~ https://kuduvoodoo.net/
New Folklore ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/NewFolkloreSilicone
PhoenixflameForge ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/PhoenixflameForge
Pleasure Forge ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/PleasureForge
Qimera Forge ~ https://qimera-forge.com/
Starspawn Toys ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/StarspawnToys
StrangeBedfellas ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/StrangeBedfellas
The Dirty Botanist - https://www.thedirtybotanist.com/
The Toy Sheep ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/TheToySheep
Twin Tail Creations ~ https://twintailcreations.com/
Vaquero Toys ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/VaqueroToys
Xenocat Artifacts ~ https://www.etsy.com/shop/XenoCatArtifacts
Twilight Meadow Creations - https://www.twilightmeadowcreations.com/
Organotoy - https://www.organotoy.de/

https://www.etsy.com/shop/HodgePodgeEntourage
I love these guys!

Sinnovator:
https://www.sinnovator.com/
https://twitter.com/sinnovatorhq?lang=en

Lots of interesting suggestions, but nobody has yet mentioned SquarePeg. They're not exactly furry, but they make some great stuff with some interesting shapes. They also sell puppy & pig tails, and they claim to have invented the "wagging" puppy tail plug.

https://www.squarepegtoys.com

Elypse Art makes a range of canine, equine, and alien dildos with an inflatable knot and squirting option.
http://elypseart.com

FetishZone also makes inflatable knot toys and a number of other animal shapes.
https://www.fetishzone.net/store/

People are recommending dread the empire but personally their toys are too short/not enjoyable
Damn Average on etsy has made some of my favorites but they've been on haitus for a bit - but i'd def recommend them over anything. I've enjoyed every toy i bought from them, and they feel really really good.

Damn Average is more than likely not coming back, but they did sell some of their models to other makers before disappearing

the quality is in the mix not molds though

https://redpanda.toys/
A brand from my country. Their prices are very good but I'm warning you: their customer support is bad, taking lots of time to reply and they take very long time to produce their toys. The best way to get in touch with them is joining their telegram group and sending a message to the owners themselves. But you'll get your products anyway, don't worry.