Format feedback. Horizontal or vertical
4 years ago
I thought I had poked about this once already, but I'm a little curious since I'm paying more attention to layouts and composition. Is there a preference, or a problem I'm not aware of, for a layout of a comic or even single image? I'm used to doing most everything on a monitor, and a wide one at that, which clearly favors the horizontal. But I know a lot of people use their phones and that's good for more vertical ones with endless scrolling. But they can auto orient if you turn them on their side so maybe it doesn't matter.
My own little bit of experimenting is I don't think it matters anymore, but it helps to know if it does because I'm trying to structure that much earlier when I get an idea than I used to. I used to just doodle/sketch lots of poses and then 'Ah, I'll squeeze them in somehow'.
So what do you all think? Thanks for any responses.
My own little bit of experimenting is I don't think it matters anymore, but it helps to know if it does because I'm trying to structure that much earlier when I get an idea than I used to. I used to just doodle/sketch lots of poses and then 'Ah, I'll squeeze them in somehow'.
So what do you all think? Thanks for any responses.
FA+

Dominus tecum
For individual images, it's generally best to try to match the aspect ratio of the majority of target devices. If we include both desktop systems and also all mobile devices that can be rotated with ease, that makes horizontal the clear winner.
For comic strips, and other groups of detailed images where the images are connected but it's not necessary to see all of them at once, it's best to assume there will be scrolling, decide which scrolling direction would be better, and then design layouts with that in mind. For longer sequences, a vertical comic-book-like layout, just like what you've been doing lately, is usually the best answer to this.
None of this is really a rule, though, as the situation changes depending on the content. A little thought and a little experience will generally steer you in the right "direction" though.
tl;dr: You've been doing it right.