Dissenting opinions
4 years ago
General
I want to clarify something about the previous journal.
I don't want people to think I don't like any opinions different from my own. I don't mind people voicing their opinions, and if they wish to counter something I may have said, they are welcome to do so, as long they do so respectfully. If I say, "I believe in X", then I would want anyone believing in "Z" say something to the effect of "I see your point, but this is why I don't think the same."
Who knows... it could be possible that I may be wrong in some things, and at the very least I would consider the other person's words. But if someone just says "You're stupid for believing in X" and goes hellbent on a hateful tirade of why X and everything related to it is crap... then we have a problem.
That is what someone did in my journal. I barely read a couple sentences, and decided it was enough. That one person whose comments I removed (who must have been a watcher who unfollowed after leaving his comments, because I can't see how else they would have found my journal) was in that latter camp. I don't want insults towards me, towards my boyfriend, nor all my followers who enjoy my works.
If anyone reading this thinks the only way to make their point across is to be rude, I kindly ask that you unfollow me. Otherwise, you are welcome to stay.
I don't want people to think I don't like any opinions different from my own. I don't mind people voicing their opinions, and if they wish to counter something I may have said, they are welcome to do so, as long they do so respectfully. If I say, "I believe in X", then I would want anyone believing in "Z" say something to the effect of "I see your point, but this is why I don't think the same."
Who knows... it could be possible that I may be wrong in some things, and at the very least I would consider the other person's words. But if someone just says "You're stupid for believing in X" and goes hellbent on a hateful tirade of why X and everything related to it is crap... then we have a problem.
That is what someone did in my journal. I barely read a couple sentences, and decided it was enough. That one person whose comments I removed (who must have been a watcher who unfollowed after leaving his comments, because I can't see how else they would have found my journal) was in that latter camp. I don't want insults towards me, towards my boyfriend, nor all my followers who enjoy my works.
If anyone reading this thinks the only way to make their point across is to be rude, I kindly ask that you unfollow me. Otherwise, you are welcome to stay.
FA+

Based on your bio, you think bad ideas don't hold up to scrutiny. There are plenty of moments in history when bad ideas (with especially violent rhetoric) did gain traction and the consequences were awful.
I think it's commendable to dedicate yourself to non-violence on an individual level, but you won't get very far if you try and hold entire people groups, especially if they are victims of violent oppression, to your own personal standards. And if you can't provide safety for these victims of oppression in your nonviolent aims, nonviolence just guarantees that they'll get wiped off the earth.
I'm not trying to be a dick or anything, but do you think that's a fair point?
And believe me, the times in history where violence was necessary to deal with a problem are very clear - they go like this: People go out to PEACEFULLY protest, they are met with brutal repression in the form of physical violence and social sanctions and then, having been radicalized out of necessity, organize a violent rebellion - this of course only happens after the oppressive authorities have become so degenerate with corruption that they can fight the revolution off.
The people you see today using rhetoric are nothing more than LARPers who think they'll be "in the Party" and living as the 1% in their brave new world. Stalin called these people "useful idiots" and what typically happens is they either get lined up against the wall and shot along with the liberals who stupidly side with them (communist saying: Liberals get the bullet to) or sent to gulags, which basically has the same effect.
Because you focused on that kind of person in your message, and because you're so used to being disappointed by it, it seems you might be losing sight of the people who aren't merely projecting victimhood, and aren't merely appropriating and virtue-signaling. There really are people whose lives are a living hell, and those who feel deep-seated convictions to fight these unnecessary evils. Unless you're friends with them or constantly connected to this firsthand, some of those legitimate cases may seem like this crappy strawman one tends to run into on social media. I've only seen your comment and bio, and I don't know how you act in other spaces, but It would be a shame if your frustrations towards a certain type of person steamrolled over the people you'd otherwise want to support.
My point is, it's all extremely nuanced and, like the rest of reality, cannot be generalized, which is what left wing activists do - and the people who do this sort of activism aren't trying to improve anything for anyone - they're revolutionaries who think realizing Marx's degenerate, alcohol fueled rage fantasy will make their unfilled lives perfect and happy. Meanwhile, ignore all the necessary genocide that comes from that type of thinking. I fought these people in college and got more than one "professor" in trouble with administration for trying to radicalize students.
We also know this idea of Social Justice hardly started with Marx. Buddhism started with a rich person feeling convicted after witnessing abject poverty. Islam has a welfare model built right into the Qu'ran. Jesus' brother James explicitly warns against showing preferential treatment to the wealthy. People throughout history and today continue to fight for their survival against whole systems that oppress them. Sometimes, many people as a whole really do enact evil things. Sometimes it's millions of people encouraging evil without realizing it. You're right, that's not exactly a monolith, but I bet you think facing accountability for evil actions is a good thing. and there are ways we can seek equity for those wrongs. Twitter drama-mills and virtue-signaling can be really fucked up sometimes, and sometimes people oversimplify in ways that rightly frustrate the hell out of you. While that's true, I don't think it's particularly nefarious to accept that Haitians fought for their independence in violence because they were tortured and killed by the hundreds of thousands. It's okay that social justice is real and necessary, even though the term gets co-opted by real assholes sometimes.
I can validate the frustrating things you've seen firsthand while also sharing what I've witnessed: all the communist I know personally are extremely careful about what they say to fellow communists. No one wants to be a bigot by mistake. They may meme on Twitter about guillotines and gulags, but all of them know how erroneous it is to take one school of thought and project it into another time and culture indiscriminately. They also laugh at how much more people capitalism has killed than even the most generous death stats under all kinds of Communism combined. Sounds like you might be surprised by some of the details. I sure as hell was. But that's for another time and place.
If I can share how you sound from my POV, you've been so frustrated and annoyed in the past by people being short-sighted or insincere, and that comes out in your writing until you end up sharing incomplete ideas. You're accusing leftists of taking on some monolithic perspective, but I can tell you don't know leftists well at all. If you did, rather than the monolith angle you see from liberals on Twitter, you'd be better off making fun of Leftists for all their in-group fighting. You seem to jump on anything associated with Karl Marx as evil, and for anyone who supports communism as blindly justifying crimes against humanity. In your messages or journals I'm not seeing you question your own ideological shortcomings or your own personal blind spots. I'm definitely not seeing caution for the crimes against humanity that capitalism incentivizes. I said earlier that you potentially steamrolled those who need help based on your rhetoric, and your next message continued to focus on others rather than questioning yourself. That strikes me as an important detail to highlight.
In telling you this, hope you don't think I'm being patronizing. As someone who used to have beliefs closer to your current ones, I just hope you get to meet some cool new people, have some more incredible experiences, and open yourself up to some new perspectives. I hope instead of prioritizing your frustrations , you question how you can help others who need it the most. I don't think it's fair to keep this dialogue going on poor Kaa's page after someone was really insensitive an exciting life update of theirs, so I won't keep it going here. But thanks all the same for sharing your perspective with me. Good luck with whatever life throws at you, and I apologize if anything I said came off as dismissive.
Aaaah okay so that's what happened.
Well I can tell you I'm not much of a fan of the UK personally in regards to it's politics and it's Progressive Stack system of justice. But let's be real for a moment...that may be my opinion of the UK but it's not me making the decision to move there ergo it's none of my business, really. Not even my place to try and convince you not to move there.
The reality is every country has its pros and cons. For some the pros outweigh the cons and for others it's the other way around.
My take on this whole thing though is I've known of you for the better part of 20 years and aside from your art one other thing that has stood out to me is just how long you have had a lonely heart and sought romantic companionship. Then
I'm seeing this from the lens of someone who spent such a long time with a lonely heart and now you're about to get married. Doesn't matter where you choose to marry and live. I mean you've lived in the US mainland for how many years now? Moving to the UK will just be another experience. It's not as though you cannot leave if things there don't pan out for whatever reason but I don't suspect that will be the case. I had a friend who moved from the US to be with someone there. I'm not sure if they're still together following some recent stuff I heard of (we no longer keep in touch) but either way she's still there in the UK instead of back in the US with her family so obviously the pros are still enough to keep her there.
So yeah. That all being said all that matters here is another major chapter in your life is going to be starting soon and it looks to be a grand one.
Cheers, dude.
Actually, I've just been reading and apparently there is no requirement for us to do this and hasn't been since the 60s. So a judge is allowed to rule differently and say "No, they've been getting it wrong all this time."
I guess that's the difference when you don't have a written constitution. Unless the magna carta counts....and it doesn't, as many anti-mask people have found out this last year or so...
https://youtu.be/DVCBjCf8YZM
Really all you gotta do is "not feed the trolls" keep the comment up and ignore it.
At any rate, congrads on everything, and best of luck!
Too many are hyper-fixated on looking at things from a political viewpoint. That's the problem with it cuz they'll always fixate on the negative as a result. It's like... they're glossing over the fact Kaa here is going to be getting married and just nitpicking about where he's planning to live with his soon to be husband. It's like wtf XD they're acting like he's moving to North Korea or something.
My only advice is, don't stick your hand out of a rolled down window in a car, apparently that's not good/ illegal/ a traffic infraction, they never told me, but that was the strongest anyone ever scolded me there. Even when I had a bit much to drink at a pub. XD
Also, there is no kraft cheese there only REAL cheese as they call it.
The only thing I can think of is that they didn't like you doing it because it could be mistaken for a hand signal indicating that you were planning to turn....and misleading other road users isn't a good idea.
We do have what you call "Kraft singles" but you're right in that we don't have "American cheese"...the stuff that is like Kraft singles but comes in a big block and is sliced off. Though I suspect France laughs at both of us.
As for the hand out of the car thing, I was behind the passenger side. They said my hand be ripped off by another car. We were in the Wide open morres of the north.
Not sure where all that came from, I thought the comments seemed misplaced. I'm still happy for yuns two and wish nothing but the best!
With that said, I agree with you. Society today has fostered this atmosphere where you can say anything you like, anyWAY you like, and everyone is just expected to deal with it. We do have the right to speak freely, but that should NOT mean that you do not need to put any thought into HOW you say things. Taking a few extra seconds to make sure the things you say are worded as inoffensively as possible should be a reflex for everyone. But it's not. Internet Trolls are becoming, more and more often, face-to-face trolls. And it's not right.
Anyway, I refuse to end this on a sour note, so congratulations again, and I sincerely hope that your plans all go smoothly and you are in the arms of the one you love in no time at all! And don't think for one moment that just because you make the transition from American to Britain citizen that I am going to stop following your work. The good ones are the ones worth holding onto, in all facets of life! ;)
Opinions are fine and might differ, but there is never a reason to become a dick about it and condemn others for their opinion. To live and let live, I'd say. And at least most other comments was positive, we shouldn't lose track of the good things too.
Since comments was blocked in the last journal due to these issues I had no chance to congratulate you two to your new steps in life and the upcoming marriage, so I'll do it now. I definitely wish you two just the best and a fruitful relationship!
There are major problems in many countries of the world right now, but it's important to have someone you can call lover and partner through all of it. It's the foundation we need for making a change.
And in the online world of today, it doesn't matter where one resides... But it helps if you're living under the same roof with your love. 'w'