Creamy's description by her player, yadda yadda

Creamy is a fairly pudgy pegasus, her time spent working in her little ice cream shop apparently proving to be a bit too tempting for the mare. Unlike most other pegasus, her belly is round and her flanks are plump and soft, but it all makes her just the cuddliest pony in the area - seriously, she's pretty damn comfy. Try it.

Her coat is a very light tan, light enough to where you could even call it "off-white." It's identical to the color of a perfectly crafted frozen custard or soft-serve cone, which is probably where she got her name from! Her mane and tail are suspiciously puffy and light, feeling like they're made of clouds to the touch - but no, it's hair, and both her mane and tail are a very light gray, looking almost like whipped cream ontop of a sundae.

Her cheeks are freckled, but it looks a bit weird - they're shaped, and colored, like sprinkles! The mare looks entirely like an ice cream sundae should, right down to her cutie mark... which is literally an image of an ice cream sundae, if her namesake wasn't driven home hard enough already.