while i dont know what the assignment was i would have to say the right side is a much stronger piece without the left. i wouldnt say cut it up. Its probably more becuase the left side feels a bit unfinished what with the pencil shaded squares in the back. There both intresting but if i had to pic which one felt like a strong piece at this exact moment i might have to say the one on the right. Thats just me opinion tho.

what was the assignment? it does look really cool, but i feel like they are two separate pieces. they r really interesting!

They are 2 different ones, but its been so long that I dont remember what i had to do.. Also for the black and red one. I had to do include Black gray and some kind of color so that is what i came up with. Also yes it is finished.