You did decently well, a few incorrect details here and there. The point should be less rounded as the blade was designed to both stab and slash. Also not a huge fan of the gold as the blade was based off Shade the Raven (I did make a version coloured after Amatsu himself but Wyr designed to pick the Shade version) I'm also struggling to see a profile taper, but that could be the diagonal angle as I'm having trouble seeing the taper I KNOW I put on my own drawing. I never intended for this blade to have a fuller but it's a nice addition. Lastly, it's clearly missing the runes, this is a magic sword so they are kinda importent XD

I mean, at the end of the day, you're free to make stylistic choices and I'm not trying to attack you if that makes sense. Just pointing out my own design choices for the sword.

Thank you. One of the reasons I chose to go with the gold was to add some contrast. With just the black metal, details became lost. You could not tell the details in the winds or the separation of the beak parts.

I do have a way to go back in and do the runes. The taper your referring to.... do you mean in the blade? I used the image from you and laid the blade over it while creating it.

I will try to rework it for you to get closer to your vision. If you want to note me any more specific changes, I will try to make them happen. I wasn't trying to negate anything you did, I love the design and wanted to take it further, but I meant no offence or ill will.

to save doing it as a seperate response, I do find it nice, but it does miss a couple of the details that Synix pointed out above me.

Little errors aside, it does look lovely in 3D <3 thank you!

The taper is indeed the blade narrowing towards the tip, as stated in the original post I can't see the taper I know I added to the original drawing.

You didn't harm or offend me in anyway, I'm very honored that you did. I'm always happy to see my characters/designs done by others.