Springtrap remembered the fateful night where his butt was completely destroyed by nightmare but today he was taking his revenge. Today was nightmare's birthday and well springtrap had invited nightmare to give him his "gift" sooner which nightmare gladly accepted and quickly teleport to springtrap " so where is my gift springy?" nightmare said happily he always was so cheerful the day of his birthday " over there" springtarp said pointing at beautiful decored box nightmare nodded and quickly ran to the box bend down and started to open it getting a confused look when he noticed the box was empty " springtrap where is myhaaaaa!" nightmare screamed out as his red heart printed boxers were yanked up his back giving him a horrible wedgie. Springtrap chuckled " nice boxers nighty" nightmare grunt in pain as he tried to talk without squealing " springtrap w-what is that for?" springtrap smiled devilishly as he started to bounce nightmare around by his boxers " it's revenge!". Nightmare grunted and yelped at each bounce kicking his legs as springtrap completed a shoulder wedgie when he hooked the boxers over his shoulder however springtrap wasn't down as he pantsed nightmare. Springtrap was surprised when he saw not nightmare's black cheeks no a pair of briefs underneath the boxers and not any kind of briefs, briefs with springtrap's face on it, he bursted in laughter while nightmare's whole face became red out of pure embarrassment " wanna tell me about those, nightmare?" springtrap asked sassily only getting a low embarrassed growl out of the dark bear " now, now, I have to show the whole world how much you actually love me" he said as reached down the shoulder wedgie and started to bounce nightmare again but this time by his briefs. The bear couldn't take much more his poor behind was in so much pain but he knew he couldn't escape from springtrap's wedgie they had weakened him too much for him to use his powers so he just grunted and yelled in pain while waiting for springtrap to finally finish him off which springtrap had gladly done by pulling the briefs over nightmare's eyes " now don't worry it's almost done " nightmare's eyes widened underneath his briefs " w-wait you mean it's not over yet?!" the bear responded making his wedgie giver laugh " Nah everyone knows a party needs a pinata!" nightmare started to struggle when he heard the words pinata but he knew it was useless.

Nightmare had been stripped of all his clothes except his two torture devices also known as his boxers and briefs as he helplessly kicked the air as springtrap and hanged him off the ground by his boxers and written down on his butt " spank the pinata here! ~springy :3" despite everything nightmare wasn't mad he smiled through the pain knowing how good springtrap got him back as he now simply waited on his friends to show up and knowing full well that his black butt of his would turn red before being let down