I wonder, as a foal, if Applejack an Big Mac would have dressed Apple Bloom in such a costume?

Do you remember the episode where Granny Smith went through the family photo album and showed Apple Bloom in a diaper while another diaper was wrapped on top of her head? Perhaps the next page would have shown Applejack and Big Maccarrying baby Apple Bloom around in a basket dressed as an apple?

This could definitely have been an idea Big Mac and Applejack would have done. They would go out for Nightmare Night and have Apple Bloom look all cute in her apple costume to get an extra piece of candy. "The lil' apple here would not mind havin' a sweet treat, too." could be a line the two older siblings would mention as they well knew this would be seen as a way to get more candy from those they visited.

The other possibility would be with Granny Smith. They would have varous apple treats to give out for Nightmare Night. So, while Apple Jack and Big Mac went out to get candy in their costumes, Granny Smith would have baby Apple Bloom dressed all cute in a baby basket filled with apples. Nightmare Night visitors would maybe hear Granny share a scary tale about the Everfree Forest as Apple Bloom cooed and babbled within a nearby basket of apples. Then Granny smith would hand out spooky fruits and vegetables with all sorts of fun designs in the spirit of Nightmare Night. :)

Thanks for sharing another wonderful idea, Sweetie. You always do a great job in getting my imagination to make stories.

Hehehe you're the one who puts a lot of imagination about my drawings And really interesting story about the Nightmare Night that the apple family should have. Sounds pretty possible for me