Since I don't expect to be able to go to any reptile shows anytime soon with how things are still going, I reached out to a breeder online and got several more mantis babies. Luckily they all came in alive, in part because of the fluctuating weather, but also because they didn't come overnight like I had paid them too. But everyone seems to be doing fine. And even though they weren't labeled I believe I know what each one is, left to right, top to bottom:

Sphodromantis sp
Sphodromantis lineola
P paradoxa
Idolomantis diabolica