This is a re-write I did about a year ago, but recorded it today in honor of Prop 8 being ruled unconstitutional.

You can get a free download here: http://drop.io/zi5g1cf

Lyrics:

When we first met I could've sworn I knew him
Everything about him just seemed to be sink or swim
Instantly I knew who he was to me
From then on he was on my mind constantly, he was

That boy was so sensitive in high school
That boy wouldn't dance with me if I asked him to
That boy always makes me feel like a fool
That boy is the one that I'm sure I belong to

He's the one I planned my schedule around
We played hide and seek and he's the one I never found
He was the friend of a friend of a friend I knew
And he was very cool, yeah he was

That boy was so sensitive in high school
That boy wouldn't dance with me if I asked him to
That boy always makes me feel like a fool
That boy is the one that I'm sure I belong to

This boy isn't right for me
I'm now ready to see clearly
Our relationship has never been steady
But to me he will always be

That boy was so sensitive in high school
That boy wouldnt dance with me if I asked him to
That boy always makes me feel like a fool
That boy is the one my heart belongs to
My heart belongs to that boy