The Classic Daddy: Phil Hartman. Even though we are supposed to hate his character in Jingle All The Way because he is such a smarmy jerk who is even more of a 'Flanders' than the actual Ned Flanders, it's the fact he's played by Phil Hartman and Phil had such swagger and charm to his personality and voice that made even the most unlikable characters he played sound like 'daddy' material.
Badass Daddy: Bruce Campbell.
Slick Daddy: Chris Sarandon.
Smug But In A Cool Way Daddy: Billy Zane. The guy can't help it if he is always evil.
Reluctant Daddy: Will Arnett.
Warm and Protective Daddy: John Goodman.
Sassy Smart-Alec Daddy: Glenn Shadix. The guy was a master at playing smarmy/sarcastic characters, I know we're supposed to LOATHE Otho Fenlock but come on, Glenn's signature Southern baritone voice and warm tone and dry sense of humor make the character, I can't find it in my heart to hate Otho even thoug he did nearly get the Maitlands killed...AGAIN (partially it was the Maitland's fault for leaving the book there for anyone to grab it and breaking the rule of not trusting the living but come on, at least Otho realized it wasn't a seance once the Maitlands began to age/wither), but he's a mostly polite guy to the Deetzes's even if he and Delia do annoy Charles with their redecorating.
Funny Storyteller Daddy: Robin Williams.
Daddy Who Is My Spirit Animal: Dan Aykroyd.
The Big Lovable Daddy: John Candy.
Gruff But Is Actually Quite Nice Daddy: Clancy Brown.
The Facinatingly Weird Daddy: Kyle Maclachlan.