This time around, I still used paper for the blade but instead of Sharpie, I bought some hammered black spray paint. And instead of paper for the handle and loop, I used a wooden dowel and a toy wheel with a whole in it. Much better results, and a lot better feeling.

Sorry the pic is so blurry, I am hoping to find a better camera to take pictures with, or a stable stand to hold my phone with instead of my jittery hand.