Note: The talisman can’t bring Charlie or 5 back to life cuz they already left into heaven.
The difference between 9 and Js fate and The lost fives fate in my head canon is that J and 9s Spirits remain on earth while the others are already in the afterlife.

However they are given an opportunity to visit their loved ones as ghosts, similar to Star Wars force ghosts, they just can’t return to their bodies

9: shaneacker
art: me