Well, there's punishing cow tippers or those who jump on hogs to see how long they can stay on.
Guys who chase birds for fun.
Petting zoo jerks. (throwing feed at the animals, etc.)
Hit and run drunk drivers. (Deer, moose, skunk, ect.)

Those kind of suggestions?

yes, those are good!

Have any more specific thoughts? Anything ideas that float your boat abit more? I like to brainstorm ideas with people.

Does it have to be punishment?

Nature's revenge can only go so far and often times only use a rather select animal or group of animals. Kinda hard to payback someone who was being mean to crabs.

Probably would not suit for this storyline, but perhaps in the future some ideas for a marine environment would be whalers, and commercial fisherman- a few even shoot and kill marine mammals near their gear to "protect their catch" I personally work pretty closely with the fishing industry and hear of that happening once every few years.

But in a taxidermist setting. Normally when I see these displays, they usually look like they're frozen in time while they are doing something. For example, a bear in middle of catching a salmon, A wolverine frozen in place, scanning out for potential predators. Perhaps the last victim could have his body transformed, and be locked in a similar situation, while keeping his sentience. Going with an adult theme, he could be locked into a carnal state where he could be almost tipped over the edge of climax, but can do nothing to find release, or escape the situation.

Thanks! I'll keep the fishing industry in mind for sure!

I really really like the idea of being locked in a frozen state. Especially being trapped on the edge like that. What an appropriate idea. I might just do that! U have any specific species you'd like to see for that?

Unfortunately, nothing comes to mind at the moment.

I'm not sure how much you like Chimeras, but some taxidermists will mix and match parts of animals together to create chimeras. I can't imagine the level of rage / horror that would go through Elysia's mind seeing something like that... Just though i'd note that to fuel the fire :)

Oh yeah I really like that!

Seeing chimera taxidermy would certainly enrage her.

As for his transformation, I suppose he'd still be living flesh, just physically frozen and stuck at the moment just before before climax. Possible idea is after transforming him she promises to reverse all the transformations once she experiences a female orgasm. Perhaps she pleasures herself or enlists the help of the other two transformed victims. Then frozen in the most embarrasing of positions right before climax.

Or I could just go for simple being mounted by a male, and the same result.

Hmmmm...

That trickery, I like that initial plan!

Thank you! I'm going to go with this idea. This is why I like getting people's ideas, they help me come up with more interesting ones!

Haha! It was fun! Always happy to help!

Another idea for a potential animal is the ferret, they go into heat and don't come out of it until they get mated :P -- Although through magic, it seems lot of these victims experience that anyways.

If you want to go for an exotic animal, you could try making something up with a Pangolin, I hear they're a big part in illegal trafficking.

How about this: a previous ( unwilling and in denial ) victim confronts herself with a doppelganger of herself representing her lust and desire to be mated and it tries to convince her ( that she is a whore ) making both of them get fucked and showing her how much they are both enjoying it .

i can see it with some self verbal abuse in it.