FA+
Shop
My Worst Critique Part 2
19 years ago
General
Well, it seems Succendo has struck back. He was being an ass to someone else about their art when I pointed out that most everyone also thinks his "critiques" stink, and told him about my journal I posted. He of course wanted to see it and basically said all of you who have sided with me are whining morons who were just "patting me on the head" and stroking my ego.
Then he banned me from #FurryPub IRC channel.
I had a conversation with someone else (unnamed at their request) where I said I did nothing more than what he did, rip on something that was "publicly posted. I did the same thing he did, and he got mad and used his banhammer.
Basically what happened during this new confrontation with Succendo is that he maintained that not being brutally honest (i.e. rude) to an artist about their work is some kind of disservice to them.
I dunno furs, all I know is I want back in that channel. All my friends are there.
I mean seriously, am I wrong? Is it so horrible to attempt to use some tact when telling someone there's something wrong with their work? Isn't it possible to still communicate something negative without being a jerk about it?
Then he banned me from #FurryPub IRC channel.
I had a conversation with someone else (unnamed at their request) where I said I did nothing more than what he did, rip on something that was "publicly posted. I did the same thing he did, and he got mad and used his banhammer.
Basically what happened during this new confrontation with Succendo is that he maintained that not being brutally honest (i.e. rude) to an artist about their work is some kind of disservice to them.
I dunno furs, all I know is I want back in that channel. All my friends are there.
I mean seriously, am I wrong? Is it so horrible to attempt to use some tact when telling someone there's something wrong with their work? Isn't it possible to still communicate something negative without being a jerk about it?
thanks
now delete it. :
Also: Insulting the owner of a channel = bad, bad, bad mistake
QFE
<Succendo> Of course the picture is flat, but as Escher so eloquently proved, you can fool the mind with flat lines
<Succendo> The breasts shouldn't be "completed"
<Succendo> In that you shouldn't draw the full half-circle
I even complimented parts:
<Succendo> WhiteLynxDragon, your art is also nice and clean
<Succendo> The hair and fuzz effects were done nice.
That's taken from your own log, by the way.
Don't take it so negatively, Lynx.
You misunderstand. I am not mad. I'm am not even displeased. I am mildly annoyed. Your whining was grating on my nerves, and I banned you for annoying me. Has nothing to do with my personal liking of your character. If you'd stop bitching so much I'd leave you alone.
Dougie asked for my opinion, and I gave it to him. His little "WAHHH MY ART I NEVER WANT TO DO IT AGAIN" was a joke. You used it as an opportunity to make a jab at me (Which missed) and act like a general whiner. The only "critique" in that journal you posted was at the very bottom, and was valid. The rest was saying I'm jealous, blah blah blah, bunch of fanservice.
My favorite line is this:
<WhiteLynxDragon> He just happened to not like me and have admin powers.
I mean, it's not like I started the channel, have maintained it since its creation, and have been the major force behind the channel's progress. Nope. My adminship is TOTAL coincidence.
"Would you, WhiteLynx, happen to be from Netherlands?" :3