I just went to random.org and entered the list into their list randomizer (I even included the folks who replied to the journal rather than sending me a note. Next time, I'm being a stickler...).

I hit the "randomize" button five times without viewing the list and the name that popped to the top when I looked was:

ThroneZwei

Since this wasn't a race, I won't say who came in second and third

Thanks very much to all who entered!