Survey for Patreon
9 years ago
General
To sum this whole thread up: What would you expect me do on a Patreon if I had one?
Long story now:
Some people asked if I have a patreon. I had to ask them the same question: Why would it worth me have one? So should I put my arts behind a paywall so I can end up on lulz.net to see myself back there? Well, sounds like it would be inevitable in either way.
I seriously see no benefit of it in my own eyes. I don't produce as much you would assume i could produce. I just do some timely, and not much. I might have been productive years ago, but I prefer produce quality than quantity in the expense of my quality.
However I would like to know your opinion how does this whole thing work and how does this benefit me if I had one? What should I produce in exchange to make it worth both side? You guys, and mine on a reasonable level.
Answers below, go!
Long story now:
Some people asked if I have a patreon. I had to ask them the same question: Why would it worth me have one? So should I put my arts behind a paywall so I can end up on lulz.net to see myself back there? Well, sounds like it would be inevitable in either way.
I seriously see no benefit of it in my own eyes. I don't produce as much you would assume i could produce. I just do some timely, and not much. I might have been productive years ago, but I prefer produce quality than quantity in the expense of my quality.
However I would like to know your opinion how does this whole thing work and how does this benefit me if I had one? What should I produce in exchange to make it worth both side? You guys, and mine on a reasonable level.
Answers below, go!
FA+

I refuse point blank to use it and hate when I see artists use it as a paywall, which it was never designed to be.
Give it a miss a you don't need it as you say, your not that active.
And that's what I would like to avoid to happen.
I mean, it probably wouldn't hurt to just set it up as a donation thingie, without putting anything there. Like. "I like your stuff, here's a dollar."
And, lets be honest. This is the digital age. Anything that is uploaded to the internet WILL be leaked.
"Are you kidding me? How can you ensure people are not going to leak out a digital copy of what they have already acquired? What's so sure they won't do that any further?"
Point taken.
From a personal perspective i respect the choice from artists to use patreon as an income because we all need to eat but when they start cock blocking to get any results i may eventually reconsider my subscription to their works.
Greets!
I'm not a big artist and I rarely take paid work, never more than 2 pieces and I have probably done less the 50 commission pieces in total. All of my personal work goes up free for people to take and choose as they like. But my Patrons help me, I have actually changed some of my anatomy styles and developed whole aspects of the world that I never would have thought of under their direction. I won't lie, I would love for it to get to the point wherein I can live off it/go part time with my work so I can really throw myself into it. The final project of the comic and some of the bonus elements would go up for free consumption but I'll keep rewarding the people who would be wonderful enough to help me do that. It might get pirated and if it does then the people who look at that would probably never support me in the first place. I'm not responsible for their conduct. Only mine. So there is a paywall and if I was good enough, my work would be pirated but that can happen anyway so fuck it. I'll do this regardless and hope people want to share it with me. And those who want to be there will. I know what it's like not to be big bucks so I would keep things as accessible as I can.
Patreon isn't a perfect platform and there's a lot of things I dislike about it but I am not aware of an alternative where the benefits outweigh the costs for me and my partner. I'm not even a perfect artist. I work full time and will soon be going to Uni full time. But Patreon keeps me accountable or rather my Patrons do. The interaction with them has even helped pull me out of some real bad days. So it's what people put into it and expect from it.
Someone like Jay Naylor has succumbed to what you guys are commenting on but it's not all bad.
Also thanks to things like "Breeding Season" and how that turned out I imagine many people are a lot more hesitant to back patreons. Myself I just don't have the amount of free funds to really back many artists (5 dollars to 20 artists would already be 100 dollars a month as an example). So when artists go Patreon exclusive they really cut their fanbase off.
On the other hand, folks that do first release to patrons and then later release to the public are still able to get some money out of their work. There is nothing wrong with supporting an artist, for sure. I do like those that give art based rewards for higher tier patrons. Some do a monthly raffle drawing, others do specific tiers of artwork (though that might get awful tedious if you have 10 people to do a picture for just for supporting your work).
Best of luck to whatever you decide, though my opinion of Patreon is rather low.
Personally, I see it as a trap, where a person can suddenly become isolated. Some do repost publicly, ...but for those that don't, when all of a person's output suddenly becomes hidden behind a clique of just a few paying watchers, I agree with you again, no benefit.
The artist just becomes hidden into a private club and into obscurity. Or as you also said, except for those things re-posted by someone :\
I love so many artists that if I were to go to everyone of their Patreon pages, I'd be working a week or two of each month just to pay for it all. It's a trap for both artists and patrons.
I much rather pay for commissions the traditional way, or even send appreciation donations spontaneously every so often, but subscribing to everyone, all you do is go broke fast.
Wishing you the very best, no matter what! *winghugz*
E.g. you could share WIPs there doodles and stuff you don't post on FA or anywhere anyway. and you can post your finished works a day(or sth) sooner than on any other of your websites. Well, at least that's what I'm offering behind 'the pay wall"(not mentioning art prizes I make for them etc., just saying what's in the hidden posts on mine^^)...