Everyone was doing it… I swear!

(++++) Orgasmatastic
(+++) –SPROING!-
(++) So hot…
(+) Mmmm tasty
(~) …shrug
(-) ehh not so much…
(--) umm yeah, no thank you
(---) blech not good
(----) RUNAWAY!

* Denotes the ones I added to the list
I've tried to make the list as comprehensive as possible. This is one of those memes that keeps evolving...

Anal (+)
Breast (+)
Breast expansion (~)
Bondage (++++)
Clothing (~)
Leather (++)
Stockings (~)
Shoe/Boots (-)
Muscle *Male (+)
Muscles *Female (~)
Herm (++) [ how can a bi guy not dig the best of both worlds? ]
Fur (?)
Babyfur (~)
Transformation (+) [ Depends ]
Macro (~)
Micro (~)
*Hyper (++)
*Stretching (+++)
Pregnancy/Birthing (+) [ mpreg more than anything else ]
Lactation (~)
Vore (+++) [ mmm tasty :3 ]
Footpaws (+) [ only rubbing tho ]
Suit and tie (+)
Incest (+++)
Yuri (+)
Yaoi (++++)
*Bi (+++)
*Str8 (++) [ why is this not on the list? ]
Sissy boy (+++)
Mind control (+)
Rape (++)
Uniform (~)
Orgy (+++)
Subbing (++++)
Domming (++)
Biting (+++)
Cheesecake/Pinup (~)
Solo masturbation (~)
Watersports (+)
Glasses (~)
Tentacles (+)
Oviposition (+)
Masochism (+++)
Sadism (+)
Cub (+)
Multiple body parts (-)
Expansion/Inflation (+)
Partial nudity (+++) [ Especially bottomless guys! ]
Gore/Guro (+)
Snuff (++++)
Zoophilia (++)
Electricity/E-stim (-)
She-males (+)
Cross-dressing (+++)
Skunk spray (---)
Oral *Fellatio (+++)
Oral *Cunnilingus (+++)
Cybernetics/Biomech (~)
Asphyxiation (+++)
Tabletops (~)
Public sex (+)
Scat (----)
Fisting (+)
Frotting/Docking/Rubbing (+)
Latex/Rubber (++)
Castration (+++)
CBT (++++)
Voyeurism (++)
Sounding (++)
Whipping/Paddling/Spanking (+)
Bukkake (++)
Roleplay (+++)
Necrophilia (--)
Cutting (---)
Fingering (+)
Rimming (++)
*Felching (-)
*Snowballing (+)
Toys (++++)
Fat (+) [ a little bit of pudge is teh sex ]
Master/Slave (++++)
WAM (???)
Mummification (~)
Underwater (+)
Yiffing machines (+++)
Chastity & Orgasm denial (+++)
Medical (~)
Underwear (+)
Tank tops (+)
Nipple play (+)
*Exhibitionists (~)

Do not judge me based on my fetishes!