Obviously, it's all subjective. It could be as simple as someone speaking really enthusiastically about a fetish you find distasteful.

However, it seems like comments that are more personal are the ones that are harder to stomach -- the ones where someone seems just a bit too enthusiastic about doing things to you personally. Talking about fantasy situations feels like harmless fun, but when someone's talking about subjecting you-you to certain acts or situations, that can definitely get weird.

This. About anything is fair game as long as it's in character (at least characters designed to be the subject to such comments, which are created for the game). Some persons will be sensitive if their intimate character, animal side, or whatever you'll call that, is targeted with certain comments. I respect everybody's whishes.
Too creepy for my tastes would be comments like: "I'd like your char to rape this cub!" or: "I'd like your char to piss on my char's face!" and things like that. GAH!

I don't mind comments like that. I usually disagree, especially with those exact examples, but I love creepy being directed towards me, the person behind the characters.

It's mostly because I tend to keep my furry drawings and real life completely separate.

Something that belies obsession above all else

BABY DON'T HURT ME,
DON'T HURT ME
NO MOOOOORE!

A lot of people consider "creepy" to be all the sexual things I'm going to do to that fine-ass furry character in that art up there. Which is a weird way to take a reaction to a very obviously pornographic picture. I thought the whole point of making porn was to get people into a mood to do unspeakable sex things to animal people, but what do I know? I ain't no brain doctor or nothin'. I can see it a little bit, I guess. It took me some time to come around to the comments about how many times people were jerking off to my stories and all that, but hell that's what I use porn stories for. Who am I to judge?

I think a more universal creepy comes from the stalkerish things people say. That kind of stuff is lent an air of malice by some uncomfortable realism, in that online stalkers can and do ruin peoples' lives.

That assessment seems to be the thesis of these PSAs. http://www.furaffinity.net/view/22355019/

creepy is making someone newly aware of a heavy fetish or interest about something familiar.
"yeah i wanna finger Lucario's dickhole and sniff that shaft as soon as Bowser pulls out"
"i wanna stick my penis in that grey horse"

in other things like social media
"how's the leg doing (uses RL name)?"

my favorite: some very specific details about a relative of theirs.

'is it gay if i circle my nipples with mayonaise?'



while playing TF2, and a female uses mic... i use my creepiest Crux voice: "OOoooh!.... a Giiiiiirllllllah *tongue flickering noises*" always gets instant laughs

it's better if you use Japanese yum yum sauce

Anything's fair game to piss SJW's off and to disgust them, though :)

Watch out who you're picking fights with :3 Trump may be winning now, but your male children will grow up to work as slaves in lesbian glitter mines. I promise.

I don't fear SJW's. I have an anarchist side: with them, I feel free to display it.

I think comments directed at you personally and not the art, specially if your in a relationship with someone else can feel really creepy. Otherwise it's all fine I think.

It's nearly impossible to creep me out. Mentioning any fetish, or even a desire to do it with me, is not creepy by itself. If I don't like something, I'll politely say that I'm not into it, and have no negative feelings over it. After all, everyone's entitled to like weird stuff that I'm not into.

The only time I can imagine having a problem is if I say "no" to someone, and the person repeatedly keeps insisting, especially if they are in a position to violate my will in person.

People can seriously say and ask me anything about me or my fursona. They are the same thing in my case, so there's no difference. Even if it involves a fetish I'm not into, it won't upset me to be asked. As long as I'm allowed to say no if desired, then feel free to ask me anything.

So far, one of the creepiest situations I've ran into is a person who apparently can't read or comprehend what "no" means. My profiles on every site I use say that I'm not interested in role playing. Many people still ask, and I simply say "no", and remind them to at least read profiles before writing to new people. That much doesn't bother me, as I know that lots of people are too lazy to read profiles. The creepy part is when I respond and say "no", and the person's next message is, "but I really want to role play with you please." Then I say no again, and they continue to try. That is not only creepy, but also very annoying. It doesn't matter what the topic or fetish is. Once someone says that they are not interested, it is time to move on, rather than begging. Worse yet is when a person gets depressed and suicidal because you aren't into what they want, even though they don't know you, and can care less about what you like.

Ask anything, but know that there is a time to stop in some cases.

I agree with just about all of that. Except I generally like to RP. And since we're all into creepy, and you didn't address it in your post, I'm finding myself wondering why you don't like to RP. What don't you like about it?

It just never worked for me. I prefer real life over role play or virtual life. I don't think role play is creepy at all though, and asking for it isn't creepy. The creepy part is when someone tries so desperately to disregard the wishes of a person that they are interacting with, after it has become clear that the person isn't interested. It could be over any topic, not just role play. You can substitute any fetish in place of role play. It's not the fetish or the role play that is creepy. It's the pursuit of it with individuals against their wishes that make it creepy.

I love to hear the unusual things that people are into, and why they are into them. I like to cum and pee on hoodies, kigus and plushies. I like the looks of diapers. I like seeing drawings of characters with lumps in the back of their pants, and I love things that imply strong smells. Most people say those things are creepy simply because they aren't into them. That's their definition of creepy. I don't consider admitting to liking anything to be creepy though, regardless of the fetish. I love comments that bring up unusual fetish topics. I've even encountered a few that I later experimented with and liked. I think it becomes bad creepy when a person targets those who aren't into something and tries to get them to share the fetish or activity, after being made aware that the person does not want to. There's a huge difference between someone saying they like vore, drugs, gore, vomit, snuff, pee, diapers, bondage, poop, etc, and someone actually trying to get a person to participate in something after being told "no".

I love creepy comments in the context of hearing all the unusual fetish comments, no matter how weird they might seem. I even like when people ask if I like the same, or what do I like. It gives me an opportunity to learn about them and them to learn about me. What I don't like is when I tell someone that I'm not personally into something, and they decide to pursue it and even plead with me to do it with them, sometimes for weeks, before I can finally cut them off. I guess there's good (harmless/fetish) creepy, and there's bad (stalking/dangerous) creepy.

As much as I like creepy, the stalking/dangerous one is too much for me. Because I'm not stupid. I know it's bad.

Discharging bodily fluids onto people's clothing is not something I'm into, but I'm not into kink shaming. Unless kink shaming is your kink, then maybe I'm into that. But if someone is into kink shaming, then kink shaming them is what they want...?

gawwwd i had one stalker who kept asking for photoshoots, and RP, and would cancel at the last second, saying "j/k"

but how about if i collect jars of pee and cum for baths and enemas, while i wear my latex goat head mask, with a leather corset and fishnets... and Q Lazarrus Goodbye Horses playing...

A person's fetishes, no matter how strange or uncommon, never makes them too creepy in my opinion. I enjoy hearing from those people 100 percent. That's good creepy.

A person's refusal to accept when I say "no" to something makes them very creepy, and potentially dangerous. I ignore, avoid, or even block those people. That's scary creepy.

awww that's a rare mindset. a pretty key point there. as i say... it's better to go through life liking things instead of finding stuff you hate. and at the least, be happy that someone else has something that makes them reeeeally happy.
A favorite Nietzschie quote of mine, is that "the source of all great art.. is gratitude" fetishes are like a worship of things we're really grateful, exist.

The creepiest comments are those that show up on your door mat, even though you've never shared your address online.

The best creepy comments I get are about people really wanting to have sex with virtually anything, especially my suits. I had one that was even blocked by administration. Creepy yes, fun oh hell yea. It really hard to creep me out unless you really REALLY dive deep into what I do.

but those suits... those paws... i wanna just rub Limburger on them and sniff them aaaall day

And there you go!! ^_~

The ultimate funny is one plays with that game, adding irony to the replies.

I can't really think of a comment that would creep me out sexually speaking.

From the mundane, all the way to sexual feelings towards my work, characters or me personally, I don't think I'd take it as anything other than a compliment. Maybe I'm in the minority on this site, but a comment expressing just how much and hard they came to any of my work or influences really makes my day.

The only thing that would be properly creepy and unacceptable I guess is posts expressing how they want to castrate, shit on, invade the property of, or seriously harm- me, ect. But even that jumps to scary or threatening rather than 'creepy.'

The nature of the fetish is where I'd define creepy, and the context of the picture in place.

For example, if you've drawn a picture of someone being sexually peed upon and someone comments about how they'd just love to have it done to them, it's somewhat contextually appropriate since the original stimulus contains that fetish and it's a logical reaction progression from it given a pornographic context.

If the picture wasn't WS based however and was just a nonsexual picture, maybe folk hugging or something in full clothing, then that would be creepy, weird and unnessessary. I think it often implies how far from the subject matter your going. If I was an artist who drew a big, beautiful butt and the comments were full of horny people wanting to fuck it to pieces and describe just how they'd wanna go about it, I'd say I did a good job with the butt because the emotions intended to be conveyed by the picture of the butt (arousal) were achived. If I drew something completely nonsexual and those came up... I wouldn't be offended... it just wouldn't be contextually appropriate.

The level of kink involved does make the amount of suggestiveness required to be appropriate more severe. I.E, if I drew a standard pinup, bloke in speedos, sexy pose blah blah, it's not too far from the imagination for someone to fantasise about oiling him up and giving him a rubdown, or even sucking his dick, even if it's technically not pornographic as he's still got clothes on, even if it's just underwear. If you were going to jump to scat ideas for example, you'd have to have brought that kink to the table in the picture for it to be appropriate for responding to in kind.

TL;DR Depends on the picture being commented on, i.e. the context.

though to be fair, some people like me are known for drawing pictures with kinks like that so if I see the stray comment on a more vanilla picture I don't take it as hard.

Oh I'd totally draw pictures like that if I was good at art. I'm a fan of stuff like watersports and certainly a nice male pin-up, scat not so much, but that's neither here nor there. I can see how some people could interpret a kinky comment on a vanilla pic somewhat off-putting or out-of-place, though what I do find irritating is people who make porn being angry that people discuss their arousal over their artwork. It's literally like a filmmaker being angry when people discuss the plot of the film and their interpretations of it.

Truly creepy? like truly truly, no joke creepy, not even sexually creepy? someone who can recite personal details about you while you have no clue who they are.

Now, in the context of comments made sexually on a furry art site? Not too much, really

Though, that said, creepy comments still should fit the person their aimed for. Telling someone who isn't into BDSM how much you "want to tie you down and face fuck you until you gag and then mark you" would be poorly fitted one towards such a person. though, I suppose that's getting off topic to annoying comments rather than creepy.

i find that to be flattering when they do

First of all I don't consider fetishes creepy, I'd like to think most out there are just healthy and harmless if you keep it consensual and don't put yourself or others into any real danger. I obviously have limits to what I draw in my commissions but most of the time it's to protect myself, both from the FA admins and perhaps even moreso any moral guardian mobs that would be after my head. Then there's some that I couldn't stomach myself, but I don't judge people for liking.

I suppose truly creepy would be people out there with genuine malice behind them, or maybe anyone obsessed to the point of it being unhealthy, or maybe someone that has no concept of borders around people. Other then that, "creepy" for me would just describe random phobias like being in a house alone at night or maybe some of those good old fashioned primal fears that a good horror movie or creepy pasta might use... vs the bad ones that just lay on the gore until it's more silly then scary, still entertaining all the same.

Or maybe ghosts, which would be maybe creepy but probably more fascinating, and the hoaxes are either entertaining or groan inducing. Aliens aren't creepy, because it's just some aye lmaos. ;p

social borders....
that's a distinction, sorely missed by the younger crowd.
all that SJW crap is from an astonishing lack of perspective of public/private interests.

i love crossdressing and piss enemas as much as the next guy... but i do not go out in public, let alone expect someone to say i look hot in my outfits.... let alone expect a new human right declared for it.

For me a creepy comment might involve significant dissonance between the actual themes and subject matter of a work, and the reaction of the commenter - say, if I posted something intended to be cute and someone else described in detail their level of arousal and the kinds of fantasies they are having about said cute image/story. That's not actually squicky for me, though, as sexual/fetish comments are just slightly odd. What really gets a gut reaction from me is comments that imply the writer in some way enjoys the idea of doing physical or psychological harm. Or comments that imply obsession, possession (of a person) or stalking as others have mentioned above. I was actually thinking of one such stalkery comment to put on the page :3

expectation dissonance.. hm

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBmDgtJyc1U Maybe something like this video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hB0UzaGbUUY << Actually this entire song describes somehing like what really creeps me out (but I secretly love it anyway if it's not in earnest)

oh i love that group

:D They're one of my absolute favourites

Haha, thank you for the props!

I'll take the sardonic route and say that sincerity is creepy. Sincerely developing a connection way too unrealistically.

Social dissociation is creepy.

See, the reason y'all'ses comments about dicks and violence aren't creepy is because that's social norm here.

True creepiness comes from the type of social depravity that not even the furry fandom can sponsor.

I don't really get creeped out by anything, other than something referring to stuff like pedophilia, zoophilia, or incest, I am not kink/fetish shaming here but I think those are signs of actual brain problems and need serious help. Now I am amazed nobody really finds me shocking, I am a scat, watersports, and cum loving gay dude, and nobody cares, like, I thought we were hated and disgraced, most people welcome me and similar folks with open minds and arms, and its nice.

The comments that creep me out the most are subtle stalking with no real substance to it. People who show up to every single drawing in the kink category of their choice just to say "Looks cute" and then disappear. You look at their page, you'll find nothing but photos from a convention they went to three years ago or something, and no journals. They're not here to ask questions, nor to share their own anecdotes, nor to make jokes, and they don't care about the person doing all the drawing. Not even a "Lurker", since a lurker generally stays quiet. The subtle stalker wants you to know they are around, but they aren't going to do anything except stare at you while masturbating.

(This gets even creepier when the art in question is non-con, and the guy comments just to give it a thumbs up. Poor... judgement.)