An Open Letter To My Fans (please read)
8 years ago
General
Fans and friends,
I have a very difficult announcement to make. I've been agonizing over this situation for months, and I've come to a decision that scares me to death, but that my conscience and my life situation demand of me. I believe that I must come clean with you all. Please know that I understand that you may be distressed, disappointed, even disgusted with me, and that I believe that you have every right to be any or all of those things, but I hope that you will hear me out in full as to why I made these choices and why I must now come to you.
To get straight to the point: I am not a female.
As I have already experienced both ends of this spectrum, I realize that some of you have suspected for some time that this may be the case, and this will not be a surprise, and I also realize that some of you have come to know me as a woman and this will be a huge and possibly unpleasant shock. I know that you may feel betrayed, and you may feel that this conduct casts doubt on all of my behavior. Your feelings are justified, yet I hope that you will hear me out to the end.
When I started out on my own in May of 2016, I needed to find a way to monetize my artwork, as I have great difficulty finding traditional work. I was already in the process of securing an illustration job in Black Hole Dawn, but I needed something else to supplement my income. My previous experience had taught me that adult artwork is an excellent source of income for furry artists, and as I was living on my own, I decided to pursue that avenue. However, as I already had an online presence of sorts, because I wanted to be able to pursue SFW opportunities without my adult work causing problems, and because I did not want to risk alienating my family, I decided that it would be prudent to create a pseudonym under which to operate my NSFW business. I created the Robin Wright name to this end, and presented myself as female in order to further separate my artistic identities. I needed a female fursona to be the face of my brand, so drew from an old favorite character design from my college D&D games and created the Robin that you all know.
In preparation for this, I spoke with many of my female and LGBT friends about my plans and only went forward with this practice under their blessing. Had anyone I knew objected, I would never have continued, as I care deeply about women's rights and consider myself a feminist. I hope that those of you who visit my streams and Discord channel know this. I believe that this initial plan was a simple matter of "conducting business as:" and I do not believe that I had crossed the line in this initial intent.
The trouble started when I began to interact more with my clients through notes and streams. People wanted to interact with the artist, and of course the artist was this sort of construct; Robin started to slip into a full persona. As contradictory as it may sound to claim, I strive to be an honest person, and so I have been completely truthful—if a little cagey sometimes—about my life and self, only altering the truth slightly to protect my identity. In the interest of transparency, the only information that I have changed, to my knowledge, is as follows:
• I am not female; I am a cis male. Any "lady things" that I have spoken of have been drawn from my experience with the women in my life. Neither am I transgender; I identify personally as male.
• I am a father; when I have talked about my nephews, I have been referring to my children, and, in a related note, when I have talked about my sister, I have been referring to my ex-wife.
• I realized that I may come off as noticeably less feminine than one might expect, and so I have stated that I grew up with brothers to wave that off. I have only one brother, and when I have spoken of "a brother", I was referring to my only brother.
• I posted a picture of a young lady on my FurAffinity page; this was a friend of mine who modeled specifically for the picture and fully understood what I intended to use the picture for (this picture was taken down some time ago when I first began to deliberate my feelings on this situation).
• I have given false birthday information.
These are the only things that I have misled you about; my life experiences have been shared in truth and from the heart. However, a deeply convicting conversation with a good friend made me realize that I had also become glib about this practice; it is a simple fact that in the field of adult work, women do have some advantages, and I was all too happy to benefit from that.
As time has passed and I have found my fans becoming friends, I have become less and less comfortable with the Robin persona for a variety of reasons, which I will enumerate.
1. It was one thing to use this persona for business and security, but as stated, many of my fans have become my friends and supporters, and some of you have even supported me financially through my hardships. Bear in mind that these hardships have been very real and I have been truthful about them—I have never ever lied about my life situations or tried to use the Robin persona to try to garner sympathy—but I have felt increasingly uncomfortable accepting these outpourings of support given the mask that conceals me from you.
2. I have come to feel as though some of my friends may be developing feelings for me as Robin, and I worry that some of the outpourings of support mentioned above may be the result of those feelings, and I feel awful about it if that is the case. I am pansexual and these feelings are not necessarily unwelcome; however, I also feel awful about the possibility that someone might be falling for someone whom they will never know.
3. I consider myself a feminist and deeply invested in the empowerment and furtherance of women's and LGBT interests. I did not and do not believe that this practice started in the wrong, but as my business operations changed, it evolved into something inappropriate and disrespectful. I believe that I have been appropriating one of the few advantages that women have without dealing with any of the disadvantages, and in so doing have unfairly set myself alongside the likes of women artists far more worthy of their accolades than I. This needs to stop.
4. As of January, I have had, and been fighting for, custody of my children, and no longer feel as though I can support myself through the sale of adult material, as I do not feel comfortable using pornography as a cornerstone of my work when there are children in my home. In my estimation, the chances of that going wrong is too high. That said, many of you are waiting on adult commissions from me, and I will need to work out details with you on how to deal with that, and I won't be able to do so without being honest with you about my situation.
Please know that I never wanted to hurt anybody, and that a large catalyst in coming to this decision was when revealing my identity to a friend caused her to feel hurt and betrayed by this practice. I care deeply about each and every one of you and I hope that you will accept my sincerest apologies for any distress I have caused you.
I would like to address some questions that I anticipate about my plans moving forward.
Who are you really?
I think it's likely that some of my fans will be able to figure this out, but I have decided not to fully and publicly reveal my identity at this time. The intention of the pseudonym still stands: I do want to keep my NSFW work history at least one step removed from my other projects, and whatever I do with my gallery here, this persona is inextricably tied to NSFW material.
Will you continue to offer commissions after this?
I'm not sure; I imagine it will depend on the general response to this announcement. It is possible that I will be largely decried, and if that happens I will remove myself professionally from the community. I never meant to cause harm, and if my continued professional activity would cause distress, then the right thing to do is to retire from this field of work.
If I do continue to work under the Robin pseudonym, it will be under full disclosure that Robin is in fact a pseudonym and character, and that I am male. No more misinformation.
What will you do with the Robin character?
Robin is a character close to my heart. It has been suggested that I sell her or otherwise give her away, but I think I will either keep her around or else retire her, depending on the overall response.
Will you allow Robin to be used in adult material that you do not create?
I'm honestly not sure. I obviously do not object to adult material, and fan art of Robin has deeply touched me in the past, but again, it will largely depend on the response to this announcement. As stated, I did not and do not want to hurt anyone, and I don't want to throw this character in the faces of people who may find her representative of inappropriate behavior.
Has anyone somehow forced you into this decision?
No. While my decision to "out" myself has been strongly influenced by people that I have discussed this with, the decision is fully mine. I believe that I need to accept responsibility for my choices, whatever the consequences of those decisions may be, and that I have allowed this to go on for too long already.
This sounds an awful lot like fraud.
I don't want to get into a big legal discussion in my apology, but suffice it to say, I never sold the fact that I was a woman; I sold art, and those who have received art from me got what they paid for. This is not to say that what I've done is acceptable; only that it isn't fraud.
It sounds like you're hoping people will just let this go.
I am not in any way trying to sweep this under the carpet, nor do I expect this to just go away. I fully expect this to be a dark mark on my work history, and there is every possibility that it will spell the end of this arm of my art career. I do hope, at least, that you will believe me when I say that I never meant to hurt anyone and that I take this action in order to move towards healthier, more respectful business practices.
How can you call yourself a feminist if you're willing to do something like this?
I fully understand your distress, anger, and frustration, and again, please know that I am deeply convicted that I allowed this to go too far, and that this announcement is specifically because I am not willing to do this. In way of explanation and not excuse or justification, as I've stated, I had discussed this with female and LGBT friends beforehand, have had the assistance of women in the execution of this practice, and have revealed my identity to a trusted few who have expressed understanding. The transition into this realm of inappropriate conduct happened subtly, and I realized the potential for harm only recently, at which time I began to reconsider very carefully.
In my history as an artist, I have had the opportunity to interact with and work with several female artists, and I truly believe that some of the greatest wells of talent and ability I've seen rest in the female contingent of the furry subculture, and deserve attention and praise. I also believe that female artists in the subculture work hard to overcome a variety of unfair challenges such as inappropriate comments and behavior directed towards them, a general lack of respect and understanding, and other such difficulties.
I have tried to encourage respectful and positive behavior both within and without the Robin persona, so it does not escape me that my own practice is both disrespectful and potentially harmful. I realize that some of my fans and friends may have been happy to see a strong and successful female artist. I feel terrible about how I have let myself be blind to the negative ramifications of my actions.
I do consider myself a feminist, and I want very much to see women as well as LGBT individuals empowered and successful. I try to do my part to that end, and right now that means putting an end to this practice of appropriation.
Are you saying that adopting a cross-gender persona online is wrong somehow?
No. There are many in the furry subculture who adopt cross-gender personas for their interactions online in a sort of pseudo-transgenderism. Whether it makes them more comfortable in their interactions, or is the only way in which they can express their very real transgender identity, or simply allows them to explore a side of themselves that they are otherwise unable to, or frankly most reasons I can think of, as long as the way a person presents their self online doesn't hurt others, in my opinion, it's fine.
As enumerated above, I believe that there are special circumstances that have caused my own use of a female persona to be inappropriate. I am not here to condemn or condone anyone else's behavior, only to take responsibility for my own.
A final word: I apologize deeply to everyone, but most especially to my most regular fans and followers. You have been there for me and supported me and in all this time there has been this mask between us. Please know again that I do care about each one of you, that aside from this matter of gender, you do know the real me, and I believe that this small community of friends that we've created through streams and Discord has been good for all of us, and I hope that we can continue to be friends, but also that I understand fully if you feel hurt or betrayed and no longer wish to support or even acknowledge me. The people that I've met through Robin have been some of the kindest and most thoughtful and positive people that I've ever had the pleasure of knowing, so I thank you for that from the bottom of my heart.
I will be closely watching feedback and ready to answer questions. I will understand if you need to vent your frustrations at me, but please be civil to each other in any discussion that may arise.
UPDATE
As I am no longer able to provide pornographic commissions, I have opted to clean them out of my gallery as I feel they create a false impression of my services. I believe that I have supplied all of my customers with high resolution copies of each of these works, but if you have misplaced yours, contact me and I will resupply you with them. I have left in ref sheets and artistic nudes because I do not feel that they constitute pornographic material.
I have a very difficult announcement to make. I've been agonizing over this situation for months, and I've come to a decision that scares me to death, but that my conscience and my life situation demand of me. I believe that I must come clean with you all. Please know that I understand that you may be distressed, disappointed, even disgusted with me, and that I believe that you have every right to be any or all of those things, but I hope that you will hear me out in full as to why I made these choices and why I must now come to you.
To get straight to the point: I am not a female.
As I have already experienced both ends of this spectrum, I realize that some of you have suspected for some time that this may be the case, and this will not be a surprise, and I also realize that some of you have come to know me as a woman and this will be a huge and possibly unpleasant shock. I know that you may feel betrayed, and you may feel that this conduct casts doubt on all of my behavior. Your feelings are justified, yet I hope that you will hear me out to the end.
When I started out on my own in May of 2016, I needed to find a way to monetize my artwork, as I have great difficulty finding traditional work. I was already in the process of securing an illustration job in Black Hole Dawn, but I needed something else to supplement my income. My previous experience had taught me that adult artwork is an excellent source of income for furry artists, and as I was living on my own, I decided to pursue that avenue. However, as I already had an online presence of sorts, because I wanted to be able to pursue SFW opportunities without my adult work causing problems, and because I did not want to risk alienating my family, I decided that it would be prudent to create a pseudonym under which to operate my NSFW business. I created the Robin Wright name to this end, and presented myself as female in order to further separate my artistic identities. I needed a female fursona to be the face of my brand, so drew from an old favorite character design from my college D&D games and created the Robin that you all know.
In preparation for this, I spoke with many of my female and LGBT friends about my plans and only went forward with this practice under their blessing. Had anyone I knew objected, I would never have continued, as I care deeply about women's rights and consider myself a feminist. I hope that those of you who visit my streams and Discord channel know this. I believe that this initial plan was a simple matter of "conducting business as:" and I do not believe that I had crossed the line in this initial intent.
The trouble started when I began to interact more with my clients through notes and streams. People wanted to interact with the artist, and of course the artist was this sort of construct; Robin started to slip into a full persona. As contradictory as it may sound to claim, I strive to be an honest person, and so I have been completely truthful—if a little cagey sometimes—about my life and self, only altering the truth slightly to protect my identity. In the interest of transparency, the only information that I have changed, to my knowledge, is as follows:
• I am not female; I am a cis male. Any "lady things" that I have spoken of have been drawn from my experience with the women in my life. Neither am I transgender; I identify personally as male.
• I am a father; when I have talked about my nephews, I have been referring to my children, and, in a related note, when I have talked about my sister, I have been referring to my ex-wife.
• I realized that I may come off as noticeably less feminine than one might expect, and so I have stated that I grew up with brothers to wave that off. I have only one brother, and when I have spoken of "a brother", I was referring to my only brother.
• I posted a picture of a young lady on my FurAffinity page; this was a friend of mine who modeled specifically for the picture and fully understood what I intended to use the picture for (this picture was taken down some time ago when I first began to deliberate my feelings on this situation).
• I have given false birthday information.
These are the only things that I have misled you about; my life experiences have been shared in truth and from the heart. However, a deeply convicting conversation with a good friend made me realize that I had also become glib about this practice; it is a simple fact that in the field of adult work, women do have some advantages, and I was all too happy to benefit from that.
As time has passed and I have found my fans becoming friends, I have become less and less comfortable with the Robin persona for a variety of reasons, which I will enumerate.
1. It was one thing to use this persona for business and security, but as stated, many of my fans have become my friends and supporters, and some of you have even supported me financially through my hardships. Bear in mind that these hardships have been very real and I have been truthful about them—I have never ever lied about my life situations or tried to use the Robin persona to try to garner sympathy—but I have felt increasingly uncomfortable accepting these outpourings of support given the mask that conceals me from you.
2. I have come to feel as though some of my friends may be developing feelings for me as Robin, and I worry that some of the outpourings of support mentioned above may be the result of those feelings, and I feel awful about it if that is the case. I am pansexual and these feelings are not necessarily unwelcome; however, I also feel awful about the possibility that someone might be falling for someone whom they will never know.
3. I consider myself a feminist and deeply invested in the empowerment and furtherance of women's and LGBT interests. I did not and do not believe that this practice started in the wrong, but as my business operations changed, it evolved into something inappropriate and disrespectful. I believe that I have been appropriating one of the few advantages that women have without dealing with any of the disadvantages, and in so doing have unfairly set myself alongside the likes of women artists far more worthy of their accolades than I. This needs to stop.
4. As of January, I have had, and been fighting for, custody of my children, and no longer feel as though I can support myself through the sale of adult material, as I do not feel comfortable using pornography as a cornerstone of my work when there are children in my home. In my estimation, the chances of that going wrong is too high. That said, many of you are waiting on adult commissions from me, and I will need to work out details with you on how to deal with that, and I won't be able to do so without being honest with you about my situation.
Please know that I never wanted to hurt anybody, and that a large catalyst in coming to this decision was when revealing my identity to a friend caused her to feel hurt and betrayed by this practice. I care deeply about each and every one of you and I hope that you will accept my sincerest apologies for any distress I have caused you.
I would like to address some questions that I anticipate about my plans moving forward.
Who are you really?
I think it's likely that some of my fans will be able to figure this out, but I have decided not to fully and publicly reveal my identity at this time. The intention of the pseudonym still stands: I do want to keep my NSFW work history at least one step removed from my other projects, and whatever I do with my gallery here, this persona is inextricably tied to NSFW material.
Will you continue to offer commissions after this?
I'm not sure; I imagine it will depend on the general response to this announcement. It is possible that I will be largely decried, and if that happens I will remove myself professionally from the community. I never meant to cause harm, and if my continued professional activity would cause distress, then the right thing to do is to retire from this field of work.
If I do continue to work under the Robin pseudonym, it will be under full disclosure that Robin is in fact a pseudonym and character, and that I am male. No more misinformation.
What will you do with the Robin character?
Robin is a character close to my heart. It has been suggested that I sell her or otherwise give her away, but I think I will either keep her around or else retire her, depending on the overall response.
Will you allow Robin to be used in adult material that you do not create?
I'm honestly not sure. I obviously do not object to adult material, and fan art of Robin has deeply touched me in the past, but again, it will largely depend on the response to this announcement. As stated, I did not and do not want to hurt anyone, and I don't want to throw this character in the faces of people who may find her representative of inappropriate behavior.
Has anyone somehow forced you into this decision?
No. While my decision to "out" myself has been strongly influenced by people that I have discussed this with, the decision is fully mine. I believe that I need to accept responsibility for my choices, whatever the consequences of those decisions may be, and that I have allowed this to go on for too long already.
This sounds an awful lot like fraud.
I don't want to get into a big legal discussion in my apology, but suffice it to say, I never sold the fact that I was a woman; I sold art, and those who have received art from me got what they paid for. This is not to say that what I've done is acceptable; only that it isn't fraud.
It sounds like you're hoping people will just let this go.
I am not in any way trying to sweep this under the carpet, nor do I expect this to just go away. I fully expect this to be a dark mark on my work history, and there is every possibility that it will spell the end of this arm of my art career. I do hope, at least, that you will believe me when I say that I never meant to hurt anyone and that I take this action in order to move towards healthier, more respectful business practices.
How can you call yourself a feminist if you're willing to do something like this?
I fully understand your distress, anger, and frustration, and again, please know that I am deeply convicted that I allowed this to go too far, and that this announcement is specifically because I am not willing to do this. In way of explanation and not excuse or justification, as I've stated, I had discussed this with female and LGBT friends beforehand, have had the assistance of women in the execution of this practice, and have revealed my identity to a trusted few who have expressed understanding. The transition into this realm of inappropriate conduct happened subtly, and I realized the potential for harm only recently, at which time I began to reconsider very carefully.
In my history as an artist, I have had the opportunity to interact with and work with several female artists, and I truly believe that some of the greatest wells of talent and ability I've seen rest in the female contingent of the furry subculture, and deserve attention and praise. I also believe that female artists in the subculture work hard to overcome a variety of unfair challenges such as inappropriate comments and behavior directed towards them, a general lack of respect and understanding, and other such difficulties.
I have tried to encourage respectful and positive behavior both within and without the Robin persona, so it does not escape me that my own practice is both disrespectful and potentially harmful. I realize that some of my fans and friends may have been happy to see a strong and successful female artist. I feel terrible about how I have let myself be blind to the negative ramifications of my actions.
I do consider myself a feminist, and I want very much to see women as well as LGBT individuals empowered and successful. I try to do my part to that end, and right now that means putting an end to this practice of appropriation.
Are you saying that adopting a cross-gender persona online is wrong somehow?
No. There are many in the furry subculture who adopt cross-gender personas for their interactions online in a sort of pseudo-transgenderism. Whether it makes them more comfortable in their interactions, or is the only way in which they can express their very real transgender identity, or simply allows them to explore a side of themselves that they are otherwise unable to, or frankly most reasons I can think of, as long as the way a person presents their self online doesn't hurt others, in my opinion, it's fine.
As enumerated above, I believe that there are special circumstances that have caused my own use of a female persona to be inappropriate. I am not here to condemn or condone anyone else's behavior, only to take responsibility for my own.
A final word: I apologize deeply to everyone, but most especially to my most regular fans and followers. You have been there for me and supported me and in all this time there has been this mask between us. Please know again that I do care about each one of you, that aside from this matter of gender, you do know the real me, and I believe that this small community of friends that we've created through streams and Discord has been good for all of us, and I hope that we can continue to be friends, but also that I understand fully if you feel hurt or betrayed and no longer wish to support or even acknowledge me. The people that I've met through Robin have been some of the kindest and most thoughtful and positive people that I've ever had the pleasure of knowing, so I thank you for that from the bottom of my heart.
I will be closely watching feedback and ready to answer questions. I will understand if you need to vent your frustrations at me, but please be civil to each other in any discussion that may arise.
UPDATE
As I am no longer able to provide pornographic commissions, I have opted to clean them out of my gallery as I feel they create a false impression of my services. I believe that I have supplied all of my customers with high resolution copies of each of these works, but if you have misplaced yours, contact me and I will resupply you with them. I have left in ref sheets and artistic nudes because I do not feel that they constitute pornographic material.
FA+

What matters is that you keep the people you can trust close, and that you can be honest about yourself. Being that I don't know you particularly well, I'll just say that I applaud your bravery, and I hope this community of friends will help you to see support and love.
One suggestion? Don't snuff out your gifts because of this. Keep creating. You're an incredible artist, regardless of who you are. I support you.
-Netty
I know saying don't worry about it will simply won't make it go away, but I'm sure a good majority will understand and just keep treating you as normal :)
Thank you for your support 💖
That being said, don't beat yourself up over it. It feels a lot worse because it is you.
Although, it is good you realize the problems that come with not being yourself online, and have taken steps to fix them.
Just take a step back, take a deep breath, and move forward to a better future. Growing up never stops once you hit 18. Growing up includes growing old, and all of the life changes along the way.
You are going through a major change in your life. Change will always feel uncomfortable. You don't grow when you are comfortable.
Anyway, enough of me saying all of the dumb platitudes. I will still watch you. I will still enjoy what you make. I will still send you links to my lewd artwork.
Be happy, Be safe.
I was looking forward to some art (I won that little raffle in stream back in maybe November - which never actually made it to your queue, but I do have emails of)
I'm just going to forgive it at this point, you don't really owe me anything now if you don't want to.
I'd be at the end of the queue regardless, and would probably entirely forget about this conversation by the time you do get to it. It's ultimately up to you.
(thanks 💖)
And for the NSFW part I totally understand why you'd try to distant yourself from it while being around children and isa thought I have been having if I ever get to have my own, but then I remember my art teachers who draw nudity on their workshops and they take it as something normal just as a I do, well pron is a step further and for that I'd simply say "private workshop /roomworkshop"
Robin is still waifu tier tho.
29. On the internet, all girls are men, and all kids are undercover FBI agents or Justice Decoys.
30. There are NO girls on the internet.
I mean, like, it's right there in the rules, y'know. The main thing is to be upfront with people about it when real emotions get to be a factor in a relationship and it seems that's what you've learned. But, whenever emotions become involved, it's hard to be predict any sort of outcome.
You're taking care of it now, loud and clear though, that's what matters. Just keep on doin' what you do and have fun with life.
The biggest things to me, is that 1.) You came clean about it, and 2.) You're openly communicating about it at this time. At the least this allows for some recovery & progress to be made. The loss of adult-tier work is a bit saddening - because let's be honest, this is FA, a large majority of us, myself included, came here for adult erotica in one form or another, whether we admit it or not.
That said, while you're planning changes and arrangements for future art, the current 'backlog' of art I imagine hasn't moved forward any - and I understand that may be due to other outside circumstances (such as a custody-battle, that will never be a 'good' thing to be tied-up in) - but I am interested in hearing how you plan to tackle that? (refunds?, alterations for adult & other works, etc)
I don't know if you've been around during it, but Jailbird recently 'came-out' about their outstanding-commissions-backlog issue, and while I'm personally not involved in any way, I've seen how others can get very vocal about their disappointment over such a matter, and I'd at least recommend tackling that issue next in some form or another.
This isn't fraud, its a pen name and "doing business as" both of which are 100% legal. If someone took it personally its an issue sure, but it doesn't make you a bad person for this choice you made.
Honestly I love your art and the brief chats we have had in stream. I still love your art knowing what bits you have in your pants, and still want to get to know you as an artist, as Robin or otherwise. It seems like you are hurting over this, obviously because you are making an announcement about it, but I do hope that coming out about it clears your thoughts soon and doesn't weigh on you. you aren't a bad person for this, allow yourself to learn from it to heal and to continue to be a awesome person, pen name or no pen name.
you don't know me really but I'm proud of you and wish you the best of all luck to get your kids! It takes a lot of guts to open up about a thing like this, and hopefully it makes you more comfortable with the work with this account to be free to be you. Both as a person, a persona, and a artist. Dropping porn in this fandom is a scary thing, but whats best for your kids trumps people's need here to see wang. I am certain you will find your way and find a niche to happily call home with people who adore you and your art for what it is.
We are only human, even here.
You mentioned future commissions, current commissions posted, all the good stuff, but I can't see a part that addresses outstanding commissions. What's going to happen to the lot of us that have been waiting?
The rest of it seems strange. I've never seen someone apologize for pretending to be something they're not.
Still, if needing to make such an admission was something you wanted and desired, I can only be supportive. I don't mind and I'm not offended or feel deceived. Frankly it's not my business what anyone is or presents as or doesn't present as. Unless I'm sleeping with someone, none of my business.
Kudos on you though for doing what you felt was best for you.
Thank you for confirming this again! ;)