So, I got an interesting email from a Catholic yesterday. They'd visited my website, and wrote to tell me I'd be better off fornicating (with women mind you) than entertaining the fantasies that I do. He supplied links to a couple books he suggested I read.

His email footer included a link to his website, and I googled it to see if perhaps others had heard from this guy.
http://www.atheistparents.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=20931 ; The classmate mentioned in this thread is the dude who contacted me.
So, I'm not even special. He judges and criticizes tons of people!

I emailed him back a pretty lengthy response. If I get an answer, I'll start posting this entertaining exchange.