FA's site navigation could use some adjustments
7 years ago
None of this is new, but I don't think I ever voiced my opinion on the matter and I'm curious what others have to say.
Every time I go to browse through the submissions I'm stuck at a fork in the road: As my username suggests I have a certain affinity for comics AND transformation, but why are comics listed as a type, not a category? Furthermore it feels like all of the types listed under "General Things" would have better keyword synergy if listed as Categories, then change the Type listing to something like Genre or Interests.
While I'm on the topic why use a drop down list in the first place? Why not check boxes? It doesn't seem like any retrofitting would be required on the developer side of things, and users would have the ability to go into past submissions and check off all relevant options.
And lastly, why is the search bar separate from the browsing section. It feels like search results should pop up in the browsing section but there are two separate, distinct forms of site navigation and I don't understand the thought behind it. It separates keywords from the distinct drop down options. I don't hate the idea of a drop down list or check boxes. It seems like a good way to provide recommended categories that make it easier to filter and find new submissions. For that matter combining the two would provide more access to what is arguably the most important section --the "Sort By" drop down.
I'm wondering if there was a reason for all of this or it was just invented early in the site's infancy and never revised.
Every time I go to browse through the submissions I'm stuck at a fork in the road: As my username suggests I have a certain affinity for comics AND transformation, but why are comics listed as a type, not a category? Furthermore it feels like all of the types listed under "General Things" would have better keyword synergy if listed as Categories, then change the Type listing to something like Genre or Interests.
While I'm on the topic why use a drop down list in the first place? Why not check boxes? It doesn't seem like any retrofitting would be required on the developer side of things, and users would have the ability to go into past submissions and check off all relevant options.
And lastly, why is the search bar separate from the browsing section. It feels like search results should pop up in the browsing section but there are two separate, distinct forms of site navigation and I don't understand the thought behind it. It separates keywords from the distinct drop down options. I don't hate the idea of a drop down list or check boxes. It seems like a good way to provide recommended categories that make it easier to filter and find new submissions. For that matter combining the two would provide more access to what is arguably the most important section --the "Sort By" drop down.
I'm wondering if there was a reason for all of this or it was just invented early in the site's infancy and never revised.
Wat
~watsup
The answer is probably that it's all already in place and it would be a lot of work to fix, so they won't :V

I see your description and raise you a 'that boy ain't right' lol

It is a tad unusual I suppose, not sure any place has a perfect system though - at least Inkbunny seems to want to keep like submissions on one page (perfect for comics or sequences), actually Transfur does that too, but other sites haven't adopted such a system.
GrahGolt
~grahgolt
I'm moreso annoyed that you can only browse page-by-page. Furaffinity really needs the option to skip to pages by number like Deviantart. I'd also love to browse by popularity or last to first, instead of just most to least recent. Kinda like how Transfur does it.
nothingspecial
~nothingsp
Yeah, it's not very good. Unfortunately, everything about the last half-dozen rumblings from the dev team has pointed towards dA-style terrible attempts to be the "Web 2.0" "Facebook of Art!" so I'm stuck hoping they just never, ever, ever touch it in spite of its current shortcomings, because whatever replaces it will doubtless be a dozen times worse.
Von Krieger
~hellkat
The answer generally to "Why is FA's UI complete and utter shite?" is generally because "for the better part of a decade there was only one dude working on it who basically clung to it and would "MY PRECIOUS" at anybody else who offtered to help."
SenorIncognito69
~senorincognito69
There's que a lot of small annoyance with FA they make the page feel clunky and archaic... ><
Beau Jackal
~bucephalus
This feels like one of those "Common Event Reported as if it Were News" headlines from the Onion.
comicTF
~comictf
OP
Oh it's definitely not news. I just wanted to hear what people had to say.
FA+