- Pinhead (Hellraiser)
- Annie Wilkes (Misery)
- Nancy Downs (The Craft)
- Reggie Bannister and the Tall-Man (Phantasm).
- Gizmo (Gremlins).
- Martin Blank and Grocer (Grosse Pointe Blank). I know it's not a horror franchise but what the hell...what I wouldn't give to be able to play as Martin or to play as insane gun-happy Dan Aykroyd.
- Hessian Horseman (Sleepy Hollow). It would be a great way to introduce a classic horror character into the game.
- Krampus (Krampus).
- Edgar and Alan Frog (The Lost Boys).
- Ahmanet (The Mummy, Dark Universe)
- Ray Erikson (Mansquito).
- Ludban (Leprechaun).
- David Kessler (An American Werewolf In London).
- Angela Baker (Sleepaway Camp)
- Angela Franklin (Night Of The Demons)
- J.P Valkenheiser (Nothing But Trouble).
- Matt Cordell (Maniac Cop)
- Killer Klowns (Killer Klowns From Outer Space)
- Jerry Dandrige (Fright Night 1985)
- Dexter Morgan (Dexter).
- Collector (Demon Knight)
- Herbert West (Reanimator).
- Lillith (Bordello Of Blood)
- Sidney Prescott (Scream)
- Buffy Summers (Buffyverse)
- Seth Gecko (From Dusk Till Dawn)
- Pennywise (IT)
- John Wick (John Wick)
- Eddie and Marsha Quist (The Howling).
- Mary and Charles Brady (Sleepwalkers).