FA+
Shop
critique for critique (let's stab each others' egos!)
4 years ago
in case you're either too full of yourself OR you're a fellow artist looking for honest but (hopefully) constructive criticism on your work so as to improve, why don't we trade words?
i feel like this kinda speaks for itself. if you think i could give you helpful art advice and vice versa, i'd be willing to give your work the once over and tell you what i think about it in exchange for you doing the same to my stuff
skill level is basically whatever to me. i'd prefer people who aren't like beginners right out the gate - idk how much either of us would benefit from that - but otherwise, whatever your skill level is, i figure you know something that i don't. honesty, even kinda brutal honesty, is welcome so long as you're not being a dickface. i promise i'll be nice too!
if you're interested, throw some of your work at me in the comments that you'd like feedback on, and i'll do the same to you. you can also ask for critique regarding a specific aspect of a piece and i'll focus on that. lemme know whether you'd prefer feedback in private, like via notes, or if you're cool with public crit. idc whether you call my sloppy ass out in the comments or not, just tell me how i fucked up the other eye lmao
i feel like this kinda speaks for itself. if you think i could give you helpful art advice and vice versa, i'd be willing to give your work the once over and tell you what i think about it in exchange for you doing the same to my stuff
skill level is basically whatever to me. i'd prefer people who aren't like beginners right out the gate - idk how much either of us would benefit from that - but otherwise, whatever your skill level is, i figure you know something that i don't. honesty, even kinda brutal honesty, is welcome so long as you're not being a dickface. i promise i'll be nice too!
if you're interested, throw some of your work at me in the comments that you'd like feedback on, and i'll do the same to you. you can also ask for critique regarding a specific aspect of a piece and i'll focus on that. lemme know whether you'd prefer feedback in private, like via notes, or if you're cool with public crit. idc whether you call my sloppy ass out in the comments or not, just tell me how i fucked up the other eye lmao
So feel free to shoot your shot about my own stuff, I won't bite...
Hard~
Critique piece: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/40884205/
I felt like he was one of my misses of all the dragons the most.
The gallery of other dragons so far just for reference: https://www.furaffinity.net/gallery.....yro-The-Dragon
Ngl I am more of a visual learner, so redlines are best for me but I'll try to absorb any thoughts you got!
Gotta say. I don't even know who Andor was until seeing that post. I looked him up and you seemed to really nail him! The only things I can say are missing is he has two spikes on each shoulder instead of just one. I honestly really like your piece, and the only shape inconsistency I can see is the Andor's shoulders in game go at a constant slope while you gave yours less slouched slopes and instead more of that "Lifted Heroic Style" If that makes any sense. But, I don't know how the character moves and can only see what I see based on the artworks and game models I can find online.
Aside from those, I really love the piece~<3 I hope Heebjeeb can give way better critique than I can!
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41819823/
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41051924/
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41550719/
So, these are some of the pieces I'm most happy with recently. I've been trying to improve heavily within this last year and a half. I actually only about 2-3 years ago got serious about drawing.
It's one of my favorite things to see people and their critique, and I feel like artists all around could use it every now and then. I wouldn't be here now if it wasn't for a couple of my artist friends helping me get better.
Critique piece: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41851798/
I feel like this is the piece I need critiqued the most, please feel free to be as rough as possible!
Anywho enough of my blabbering. :)
I have these two:
I'm trying for a more paler kind of thing in terms of colouring for this one, but I feel it is still really off. But anything that's off lemme know :))
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41719807/
And this one:
https://www.furaffinity.net/view/40285885/
You can post critique publicly.
@U@b I'll do my best with your stuff, too! :'''D
<3 Also thank you for this, I find critiques are such an important thing for all of us artists, and it's a shame it's very discouraged nowadays. I definitely didn't get where I'm at right now without all them helpful critiques.