(Geoff)
On the other side, Geoff heard some shuffling.
"Hold on, sport," Geoff heard a familiar voice say, "Coming!"
Geoff, w/ an angry expression, realized that the voice belonged to none other than yet another False Natas. After a bit, the door finally opened. As Geoff expected, a False Natas did open the door. This one was different from the others as this one wasn't glitching, and he clearly wasn't stuck in an endless loop. Peaking out from behind his legs, there was a small, fluffy monster child. They weren't wearing anything but shorts, and he gazed at Geoff w/ big curious red eyes. Geoff realized while cringing that this was clearly a younger version of Chester. He even had the same cowlicks and everything.
"Why, hello there," The fake dad said, "How may I help you?"
"Move aside, you cuntstain," Geoff said through gritted teeth.
"I'm sorry, what was that?" False Natas asked.
Not having any of this, Geoff promptly and roughly shoved the faker aside and forced his way into the house. Mini Chester, now scared, couldn't help freeze in fear.
"Chester, can you please cut this shit out already?" Geoff asked the de-aged monster.
Mini Chester took some steps backwards, clearly very frightened. Geoff then felt a hand gently but firmly clamp a hand on Geoff's shoulder.
"I don't who you are, and I don't know how you know my son's name, but I suggest you leave now before I have to do something I'll regret," False Natas said menacingly.
"Oh, now you care about your kid?" Geoff asked bluntly.
"What are you talking about?" False Natas asked, "I've always cared about my son."
"Hm. Then why did you leave him?" Geoff asked coldly.
"What the-? I never-!"
"Shut up."
Geoff then casually tore the fake hand off of his shoulder and turned towards the faker.
"You aren't even real, you son of a bitch. The Real Natas died a couple of months ago after having left Chester for 15 years. You are just a damn fake based on what Chester thought Natas was like," Geoff said w/ absolute bluntness.
"Of course I'm the Real Natas!" False Natas said, "And as the Real Natas, you have five seconds before I call the police."
Geoff, not having any of this, pulled out his staff.
"And what's that supposed to do?" False Natas asked while crossing his arms.
"Oh, this?" Geoff asked, "This is just to prove that you aren't real!"
False Natas gave a skeptical look while still keeping his eyes closed.
"And just how are you going to do that?"
A shadow fell over Geoff's eyes.
"I'm glad you asked..." Geoff said, deathly calm.
Before anyone could react, Geoff moved lightning fast towards the faker and tackled him to the ground! False Natas flailed and struggled to get up, but Geoff forcibly held the faker down.
"Get off of me! The police will have your head for this!" False Natas said.
Geoff rolled his eyes.
"No, the fuck they won't."
Then, w/ no signs of hesitation, Geoff raised his staff and forced it through the faker's chest right where the heart should be! It was a little tricky as this fake seemed to have some mass to him, but Geoff eventually managed to force the weapon all the way through as False Natas and Mini Chester screamed all the while. As Geoff got up, the faker screamed for a few more seconds. After a bit though, he stopped moving. Still screaming, Mini Chester finally got the nerve and quickly ran over to his dead "father."
"Daddy?! DADDY!" The child screamed as he shook his fake dad's corpse.
Geoff, despite feeling bad for doing this to Chester, knew that it was necessary to break the illusion. As Mini Chester cried over the body, Geoff noticed that the body wasn't even bleeding and sighed in relief.
I knew it wasn't real, Geoff thought.
He'd been a little doubtful as this fake wasn't like the others, but he turned out to be right about this. Geoff then knelt down.
"Chester. Please. Stop this illusion already."
Mini Chester turned to Geoff w/ a fierce, crying expression and backed up w/ his fists raised. Geof got a pained expression at that but kept pressing on.
"Chester, please. This was clearly a fake you made for yourself. I mean, it isn't even fucking bleeding!"
"No, you're wrong!" Mini Chester shouted, "My daddy was real! But you killed him! I hate you! I hate you so much!"
It pained Geoff to hear Chester say that and to do this to the poor guy, but Geoff didn't have any other choice. Geoff glanced at the body again and sighed.
"As if you needed any more proof that this thing isn't real..."
Confused, Mini Chester followed Geoff's gaze and became horrified. False Natas' body was slowly disappearing! Mini Chester immediately rushed over to his "father's" corpse.
"No, NO!" The de-aged monster shouted.
Mini Chester then began to bring his fake dad back. He tried to shake the faker, push on his chest, etc., but to no avail. As the corpse faded further, Geoff couldn't help but feel like the biggest heel as Mini Chester got more and more desperate. Eventually, though, the body was gone. Mini Chester, devastated, began to sob w/ his face towards the floor. Geoff, still feeling horrible, reluctantly kneeled down and kept it going w/ the tough love.
"Chester, you can't keep doing this," Geoff said calmly, "This house, that body, this whole place. It's all fake. You can't just live in the past like this."
At that, the sobbing stopped. Mini Chester became deathly silent as he lowered his head and held it in his hands.
"Chester...?" Geoff asked quietly.
"Heh... HEH... HEH..." Mini Chester forcibly chuckled.
Geoff flinched at that. Slowly and very hesitantly, Geoff moved his hand out to Mini Chester. Suddenly-
"AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"
This scream was even worse than the last one! Suddenly, as Mini Chester let out the constant scream, the illusion began to become rapidly distorted and twisted as the house faded away and Geoff was left floating above a nightmarish land! Geoff became very much afraid as everything began to glitch and distort beyond recognition! Even both he and Chester were barely recognizable as Chester kept on screaming his heart out while slowly reverting back to his real age! Geoff, scared out of his mind, ran over to Chester's twisted and distorted form. As he got close, though, an invisible force stopped Geoff from going forward! Too determined to stop now, though, Geoff tried to push through, but sadly, the force overpowered and threw him back pretty painfully! Despite being hurt, Geoff painfully got up and ran back over. As before, he was thrown back. Undeterred despite the pain, Geoff kept on going. It didn't matter how much his body wanted to quit, Geoff refused to give up. After a bit, though, his expression became fierce, and his exasperation had reached its peak. Reaching the force part again for the umpteenth time, Geoff put all of his power into pushing through it. At first, Geoff made no progress. Slowly but surely, though, Geoff managed to push through. Bit by bit, Geoff distortedly made his way forward. When he finally made it to Chester, Geoff, w/ much difficulty, wrapped his arms around the screaming monster.
(Song: Worthless) (Link: https://www.furaffinity.net/view/41209740/)
"Chester! CHESTER!" Geoff shouted.
If Chester heard, he didn't show it. He simply kept on screaming.
"PLEASE STOP THIS ALREADY! I'M SORRY THAT YOUR DAD ABANDONED YOU! I'M SORRY THAT YOU'VE HAD TO BE ALONE ALL THESE YEARS! BUT PLEASE, IF YOU DON'T STOP THIS, WE'RE GONNA DIE! PLEASE, I'M BEGGING YOU!" Geoff shouted desperately.
Chester, unfortunately, didn't seem to notice. Geoff, not knowing what to do anymore as he hung on for dear life, painfully crawled up a bit higher. Even though Geoff could barely recognize Chester, at this point, it didn't matter to him anymore. Slowly, w/ eyes full of tears, Geoff planted a slow kiss on Chester's connected mouth. Geoff didn't care about anything else at that moment. He had to stop this madness. At first, it didn't seem like the kiss did anything.

(Chester)
Eventually, though, Chester began to slowly calm down. His screaming slowly died down, the distortion began to go away, and cracks began to form in the world. After a while, the illusion broke away to reveal Geoff and Chester's real, unlit house and Chester's face went back to normal. Finally, everything had gone back to how it should be (for the most part). After a few seconds, Geoff finally broke the kiss. Once he did, though, Geoff collapsed from exhaustion. Chester, w/ a shadow over his eyes, caught Geoff as Thread coughingly came up for air (he'd been trapped in Chester's body the whole time). W/o saying a word, he carried his unconscious lover over to the couch in the lightless living room. After gently setting Geoff down on the sofa, Chester glumly made his way upstairs. When Chester was fully up, he went over to his room, opened the door, and stepped in. Chester silently surveyed the room. All the tally marks, all the drawings, and all the memories spent simply waiting in this place... Deathly silent, Chester made his way over to a corner and began to slowly rock himself, tears slipping down his face. Thread, not sure of what to do, simply sat on Chester's shoulder, offering what little company he could...