Look at the NBA's history of All-Star Jerseys

It looks a lot better than the previous one, for sure.

I'm really not sure why all the hate... aren't we supposed to encourage creativity in the FBA, not bash it?

They are a little roughly rendered (I'm guessing it's your art program), but the idea is just fine! I have seen much crazier All-Star jerseys than these for sure. These actually look well in line with something that would be worn at an NBA All-Star game. I can tell you've done a little bit of research to come up with this. :)

Not to mention the Team Spirit font works for All-Star games of nearly any sport

Not bad at all! I like these designs. Pretty flashy, but the kids like that.

And I love how you've used both FBA logos! Giving old-school some love! Nice!