My contribution to the discourse
2 years ago
Apparently the wiki translates the Japanese for Rookie stage Digimon as "child" (and that may well be an official translation, idk) but 成長期 looks more like "growth period" so "child" seems a bit off as a translation, especially if you're going to ban people over it.
Whoever made the rule for this doesn't really know Digimon..., especially since Gatomon is banned, but it's a higher level than Renamon, which is allowed???
No, seriously, we cited Pokemon and Digimon as examples of non-applicables every single time. And even Digimon itself doesn't take those labels all that seriously.
Keeping the rules vague and/or fluid invites whataboutism; for people to complain over and over "you said this was wrong but not that" over and over and over.
Make the rules clear-cut with a well-defined line, on the other hand, and people are going to deliberately get as close to that line as possible.
For example: A movie will get the NC-17 rating if it has four hundred or more swear words in it. Want to hazard a guess how many swear words were in the South Park movie?
The best possible approach is the latter: To make the rules clearly defined and just accept the fact that there will occasionally be trolls testing those limits. Which is what F.A. originally did with its stance on underage NSFW, to which the trolls started up with the "vampire loli" stuff.
But instead of just sucking it up and accepting it, or drawing a new line on the other side of "vampire loli" and seeing what comes after that, they had the administrative equivalent of a temper tantrum and plowed headfirst into this shit.
And I have no sympathy for them because, as I said, we warned them every single time they toyed with the idea of this in the past. Over and over and over.
Admins: "What do you think would happen if we swan dived into the Grand Canyon?"
Users: "You'd die."
Admins: "Are you sure? I think we should swan dive into the Grand Canyon."
Users: "Don't. You'll die."
Admins: "I don't think so. Why would I die?"
Users: "Because it's hundreds of feet deep and there's nothing but rocks at the bottom."
Admins: "So you're saying I should swan dive into the Grand Canyon?"
Users: "No. Because you'll die."
Admins: "I'm going to do it. I'm going to swan dive into the Grand Canyon."
Users: "I'm telling you, you'll die!"
Admins: *dives*
Users: "God dammit, I'm going to Itaku."