Honestly? It doesn't matter to me if quick smashes are in or not. I used them all the time but it's just as easy to press the two buttons together for a split second.
No loss on this end.

It's a bit slower coming out, and sometimes it registers as a tilt instead of a smash.

honestly i think the quick smashes thing is kind of cheap

Why? It's just a smash without charging.

thats excactly why
a strong attack shoudlnt be that fast

They're not that strong, though. In fact, generally the tilts are stronger and have more launch power than uncharged smashes from what I've played so far, and they're instant. Megaman's uptilt is a perfect example. Or basically all of Mario's tilts.

i think the uncharged smashes were always stronger.
I just dont like quick smashes
you can use them but i wont and im glad they are not on the 3ds
and i hope they wont be on wiiu either

You're just plain wrong about that. Ganondorf's up tilt can kill at barely any damage in Brawl, for instance. Samus's down tilt is probably her most powerful launching move, since both her down smash AND up-smash have little to no launch power at all. In the new one, Megaman's up tilt is MANY times better as a launching move than his up smash, even if you charge the smash a bit. Many of the characters in the past had better tilts than smashes. If the smashes were stronger in the new one I might agree with you, but unless they're charged, enemies take upwards of 150% damage to get a kill since everyone's recovery is basically the entire map, now. Taking away the quick smash hasn't made the game any deeper, it just makes it take longer since your enemy has to basically stand still and let you charge it to get a kill, or you need to tilt (which for some reason never works with the circle pad and always does a smash unless you hold it for like 2 seconds in a position, making it easy for them to dodge since it's really obvious what you're going to do). Unless you're allergic to the shield button, the quick smashes still aren't fast enough in most cases to stop you from blocking it.

I can guarantee they'll bring back using the right-stick for quick-smashes. If they don't, there are a lot of people that just won't even bother and would stick with Brawl. Heck, unless they fix how awful the launch power is, I question if I'm even going to buy the game. Dodging is way easier than hitting, so matches can go two minutes in PVP with zero kills and barely any damage taken, and I'm not even good. Pros have discussed lowering the stocks from 4 to 2 for the new game solely because it takes so long to get kills now. The time-limit they use is 8 minutes, and they think any more than 2 lives and they'll hit that time-limit. I don't know what Sakurai was thinking, but he's made it feel much less enjoyable than Brawl, and Brawl had tripping.

i know some tilts are stronger than some smashes
but that one up tild of ganondorf takes time and therefor its not cheap at all.
Yeah megamans up tilt is better than the up smash altough it could leave you defensless if you dont hit with it.

i can do tilts just fine on the 3ds O.o


I managed to get 7 kills in 2minutes on the demo before
with two enemies so i dunno if it really takes much longer to do kills in the new one.
I personally wont go back to brawl at all cause it overall just seems not as fun anymore
besides having less chars the chars are not as detailed and i despise tripping.
Overall it seems to me much better than brawl
but thats me and not you and if you like brawl more its your opinion

I play Project M, not vanilla Brawl. No tripping in that version, and the characters are better balanced.

And I was talking 1-on-1 fights. I've never gotten more than 2 kills without exploiting the AI, and if I get two it's usually due to the AI playing poorly (exclusively talking about level 9s). It's obviously way easier with multiple people racking up damage. I'm also talking specifically about no items, since items are completely overpowered.

Yeah megamans up tilt is better than the up smash altough it could leave you defensless if you dont hit with it.

The same is true of most smashes, even if you use the c-stick to use them quickly. Most smashes have pretty significant end lag. I don't see how making them quick to use with the c-stick is any different, since the strong ones suffer the same drawbacks as Megaman's uptilt.

I can never do Megaman's uptilt. It ALWAYS does his upsmash, or a jump. It's ridiculously frustrating, but that's fixed by going into the menu and turning off tap jumps. The demo just doesn't let you change the settings, unfortunately.

i know of project m but i cant do that on my wii etc cause its a pal one

I also can easily do 1kill a minute in 1vs 1 fights
and i mostly dont use items myself even if i see them i usually just try to get them
so the enemy cant get any.

For mario tough every smash is stronger than his tilts
tilts are good for getting the damage high tough

I can do megamans uptilt multiple times in a row if i wanted to
i dont know how i do it but if i want to use a tilt i use one
and same for smashes